4 ms·
> Can you not see how that would be viewed as insanely predatory? I assume you must be an expert in the cost structure of operating a veterinary practice in th
by lotsofpulp 3y ago
> Can you not see how that would be viewed as insanely predatory?
I assume you must be an expert in the cost structure of operating a veterinary practice in that location, at that time, in order to determine a predatory and non predatory price.
If you are not, I am not sure how you can make any claim about the prices.
>For profit companies should not be involved in human or animal medicine.
What kind of quality of life do you think veterinarians and doctors deserve? Should they be able to buy a Mercedes? C Class or S Class? Should they be able to buy a home in the better school district? How many square feet?
These questions are relevant for determining the predatori-ness of the doctors’ prices. Even more relevant is whether or not you want the top caliber people spending years studying one of the most complex machines. Or they could go study how to deliver ads to people.
- datameta 3y agoI wholeheartedly disagree. After seeing the prices of basics like saline in hospitals, I'm not surprised to learn of inflated prices obfuscated from the general public.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThat one is obvious due to us knowing the hospitals sell to the government and insurers for much less. As far as I am aware, this does not apply to a veterinary business. The article also says it was $10k for emergency services at a vet hospital, including the aftercare. What are the labor costs of having highly qualified people, presumably in low supply, on call to provide these services? What are the costs of supplies like medicine, and malpractice insurance (if that applies)?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- freedomben 3y agoThe vets that I've been too (minus a non-profit clinic I went to once) absolutely charge outrageous amounts for saline and other things. It's a hard business, so like most time-of-use sales points they take advantage and charge for the convenience. I'm not making a value judgment, just pointing out that it definitely is something they do.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoWhat is definitely something they do? Asking for higher prices in high demand low supply scenarios? That is something (effectively) everyone does. It is how the world works. It is the mechanism which the markets use to signal more supply of something is needed (or less demand). If you want me to study advanced biology for 10+ years and then have me work at odd hours of the day and night to be ready to perform surgery, you need to pay up, or reduce the other options I have for earning money which give me a higher quality of life.
- freedomben 3y agoAgain, I'm not making a value judgment (as rationalizations from both perspectives can be made, and a person's opinion will depend on their perspective), just saying that "charg[ing] outrageous amounts for saline and other things" is definitely something they do. In a free market system they're allowed to charge whatever they want, and the consumer is allowed to take it or leave it. But explicitly stating the practice is a fair thing to do.
- watwut 3y agoNon predatory thing then is to help the owner to put the pet down painlessly and quickly for reasonable price. Without guilting the owner into 10000 operation.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI do not see any evidence of guilting. > The incident involved a four-month-old German Shepherd puppy who'd swallowed a skewer and needed emergency surgery life-saving surgery. The cost of the complicated procedure and after care was close to $10,000 – more than the owner could afford. As a last resort, to avoid euthanasia, the clinic offered her the option to surrender the puppy to a new owner who could cover the cost. What is a reasonable price? Unless someone is familiar with pricing from multiple vendors for some period of time, how could one know a reasonable price?
- somenameforme 3y agoIs a million dollars a reasonable price? The point I make is that you might not be able to tell a reasonable price, per se. But you can generally tell an unreasonable price. It's some x-rays, animal quality anesthesia/meds, and labor. It's hard to see how this reasonably adds up to $10,000. Were time not an issue, they could probably take a trip to Mexico, get the operation done for maybe a few hundred dollars, and come back home, all for much less money than the vet was asking. And the reason I think that's particularly relevant is that it's not like the underlying costs really change. That clinic in Mexico is probably importing those drugs and machines from the exact same places. So developing world costs tend to give you a 'raw materials' cost, where all that's left is labor + profit.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> Is a million dollars a reasonable price? If you can’t find someone else to sell to you for less, then yes. Barring broken markets such as due to regulatory capture, etc. > The point I make is that you might not be able to tell a reasonable price, per se. >But you can generally tell an unreasonable price. These strike me as conflicting statements, otherwise I don’t know what per se means. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37846041 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37846041 > And the reason I think that's particularly relevant is that it's not like the underlying costs really change. >So developing world costs tend to give you a 'raw materials' cost, where all that's left is labor + profit. Why are labor costs not underlying costs? How about liability insurance? Real estate?
- stef25 3y agoHow much of that 10K would be Mercedes money ? It goes without saying that a vet should have higher than average income considering the length and cost of study and responsibility etc. Not at all trying to say that they're greedy.
- naniwaduni 3y agoNot sure why this goes without saying.
- pc86 3y agoMore training. More required expertise. More investment - opportunity cost, schooling, etc. The mental/emotional burden.
- dwater 3y agoBecause in the US, higher education is largely a personal investment against future earnings, and vets have longer and more expensive education requirements that most jobs, so they need to have higher salaries to justify the initial investment and to incentivize people to pursue that career path.
- mynameisash 3y ago* FTC acts against private equity firm's acquisition of veterinary clinics[0] * Private equity is buying everything from vet offices to tech conglomerates [1] I'm not opposed to people making money and having a comfortable life, but the fact that private equity is capitalizing on vet clinics is telling. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31728350 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31728350 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36313967 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36313967
- jncfhnb 3y agoPrivate equity companies frequently purchase struggling businesses, not prosperous ones
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 3y agoMaybe, a local monopoly could be a cause for concern. But is the barrier to start a veterinary practice so high as to grant them a permanent monopoly? In this specific case being discussed, it does seem the vet business was acquired by a PE company a few years ago: https://www.mainebiz.biz/article/portland-animal-health-startup-acquires-scarborough-veterinary-hospital https://www.mainebiz.biz/article/portland-animal-health-star... Note that the vet doctors themselves may have ownership in the company itself. The other option is that advanced surgeries for animals are so costly, and the proportion of people who have the ability to pay so low, that there does not exist sufficient demand for a new vet to want to open a new hospital. In short, pet owners simply cannot afford all the pet healthcare they want.
- reisse 3y ago> I assume you must be an expert in the cost structure of operating a veterinary practice in that location, at that time, in order to determine a predatory and non predatory price. You don't have to be an expert when you can compare vet prices in US and in other parts of the world. And unlike human healthcare, vet is not subsidized anywhere, so the comparison is fair. With the price tag of 10K$ I'd say it would be worth to take a flight to Mexico, other LatAm countires, or even Eastern Europe to pay tenth of the price for the same operation.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoComparing prices in different locales makes no sense, especially in an un-arbitrage able scenario like time sensitive emergency surgery. What if tort costs are higher in one country than another, requiring higher insurance premiums? Real estate is more valuable, resulting in higher rents/mortgages? Labor costs higher due to more stringent labor laws/less supply of labor. The list goes on and on.
- cowmoo728 3y agoI considered this for my pet's medical care. I did some things at a very expensive private equity owned bay area vet clinic, and other things at a much cheaper location quite a drive away. The bay area clinic wanted 4x as much for a relatively routine procedure. But they also had new and more advanced imaging equipment and monitoring equipment, and veterinary surgeons with fancier degrees and specializations.
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoFrankly, if a vet can, as a matter of practice, afford to do procedures probono but only if the owner surrenders their pet, it means they are making an absolutely staggering profit from those who are emotionally extorted to pay. That is predatory. I miss the days when vets got into the business to run small practices for a reasonable profit and middle class lifestyle. Few of them wanted mercedes money . It's kind of gross to think modern vet medicine is making vast sums off of pet owner's worst days.
- jncfhnb 3y agoSurrenders their pet to someone who can pay
- throwaway5752 3y agoYou sound like you don't personally know many vets, you don't know what it was like to operate a vet practice back in the day, and you don't know what they drive. I do, and going on about this (incorrectly) on an article about a veterinarian suicide crisis is unseemly. This isn't about you. If vets are so greedy and amoral, why are they committing suicide, for all the reasons listed in the article, at 4-8 times the rate of the general population? You might find it interesting and beneficial to learn more about this topic firsthand. Vet practices, shelters, and vet schools often operate in coordination and are always looking for volunteers and donations. You may find more understanding and empathy with more exposure to the people this area.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoYou think you should dictate the price of someone else’s labor, and that is less predatory or somehow better than someone being able to price their own labor?
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoI can't 'dictate' anything. I just think that healthcare, for both humans and animals isn't the place for a 'the price is whatever the market will bear' mentality. That mentality assumes the participation of cool, rational actors. People making healthcare decisions for their family or pets do not fit that criteria. I feel it's immoral to use the love one feels for their pets to extract as much as possible from the owner. I understand you probably feel differently. Frankly you and I will probably not ever agree on this topic as we have different world views.