2 ms·
Seconding this. Affordable housing mandates are counterproductive. Let developers put property to "the highest and best use". Those who are rich/gullible enough
by xnx 3y ago
Seconding this. Affordable housing mandates are counterproductive. Let developers put property to "the highest and best use". Those who are rich/gullible enough to buy new "luxury" units will benefit by getting the luxury properties from 20 years ago.
- dtech 3y agoIf the mandate is to built 5 moderately sized appartements instead of 3 large units they increase supply.
- xnx 3y agoThat seems mathematically true, but doesn't tell the whole story. Imagine a common scenario in my city where the prospective buyer/renter of one of those new apartments is considering tearing down and older multi-unit structure to build a single-family home. In that situation, the availability of an larger unit could result in more total housing units. Because they have financial incentive, developers are often the ones in the position to best understand what the market wants.
- sandworm101 3y ago>> developers are often the ones in the position to best understand what the market wants. Correct. Developers build to what the market wants. But that doesn't mean they build to what people want. If given total freedom, developers often chase the upscale market, rich people wanting high-priced units. That is where profit is to be made. That is what the market wants. But that is not necessarily what a city actually needs.
- hedora 3y agoIgnoring what the market wants doesn't work. If you maximize the return on investment of building more housing, then more people will build houses. If you make housing construction unprofitable, then fewer people will build houses. Also, people act like a glut of luxury housing would be a problem. It absolutely wouldn't. It would displace and therefore depress prices for midrange units. If the developers end up losing money selling their new luxury housing at a loss, then they've effectively just subsidized the US housing supply. That's much less expensive for taxpayers than having the government subsidize + force people to build housing that sells for less than construction costs.
- sandworm101 3y agoWell, history has not shown that. There are countless situations where large houses have been surrounded by legions of the working poor unable to afford living spaces. Or where vacation homes sit empty, owned by people living far away, while cities struggle to find local accommodation for working people.
- hedora 3y agoNeither of those issues have anything to do with housing supply, and they're either be unaffected or exacerbated by affordable housing mandates. The one large house + not enough houses problem is due to income inequality. Making houses scarce increases the price of houses for everyone, so it exacerbates income inequality (it is hard to increase your income and educate your kids while living in a tent). Worse, most affordable housing projects that are currently being proposed deed-restrict the housing (otherwise, unless the initial purchaser is an idiot, they'd immediately sell at a large profit). That prevents poor people from profiting off of the appreciation of property in their neighborhood that and therefore increases long-term income inequality. You also get situations where the low income housing owner can't afford to use local amenities, or maintain their house (which they bought for far less than the cost of initial construction). The second issue (hoarding of vacant houses) can be solved with a vacancy tax. History supports both those arguments. Can you name an example of a city where supply has exceeded demand (measured in months of housing inventory on the market) for an extended period of time (multiple years, so longer than the 2008 crisis), and that also has a housing affordability and homeless crisis? Similarly, can you cite an example of a market where housing has been freely built and sold at a profit over the long term, and that also has a housing supply problem?
- epistasis 3y agoExcept such mandates never exist, the only mandates on unit sizes are minimums, not maximums. Though I do propose such changes as part of my "urban planning is 100% wrong, simply replace the direction of every single cap and you will get a better result plan", this has not caught on with anybody but me. Also, rich people still get around maximums by joining together adjacent units. For example, SF board of supervisors (think city council) member Aaron Peskin did this with two units so that he could have a bigger more luxurious living space, even though nobody else is allowed to bend the permitting rules that way. (SF has permitting rules that disallow making two units into one, but it does not have any limits on maximum unit size, as far as I can tell.)
- snapplebobapple 3y agoThis is the right answer, but it's only the right answer in the face of sane zoning that ensures it's usually cheaper to upgrade lower to much higher density rather than knock down/renovate old high density to create new luxury high density. If you have the north american situation of the vast majority of residential being zoned single family then you will never get cheap high density for long because it will always make sense to upgrade or demolish and rebuild high density luxury on that scarce high density zoned land. My personal opinion is we need to get rid of the split zoning and instead have the higher density residential zones include the allowed uses/buildings from the lower density and then get rid of single family altogether and have the lowest density zoning be something like a 4 story town house (while allowing someone to buy that land and build a single family home if they want). We also need to make the split much less harsh between that zoning and much higher density zoning so there's always an excess of land zoned for higher density but occupied by lower density, older buildings so that every time we tear down something old and cheap to rent we end up with more luxury units that will transition into more old and cheap to rent units over time.
- bombcar 3y agoYou need something like "ratcheting zoning" - if someone wants to redevelop a single-family plot into a duplex; by default it should be allowed; encouraged. If they want redevelop a 4plex into a single-family home; that requires more investigation and a variance.
- snapplebobapple 3y agoI don't agree. If someone wants to do that they should be allowed to without extra government interference because if they are doing that because it's profit maximizing then we screwed up in our zoning already. Our problem isn't the one off (probably rich people) going against the profit maximizing trend on development (probably because it's their own home and they are willing to forgo profit for other benefits like a bigger yard). Our problem is that we have a cascading scarcity of dense land zoning so at every level above single family it almost always make sense to renovate or tear down to be able to charge luxury prices instead of doing basic maintenance to maintain habitability while charging lower and lower rent as the building degrades over several decades before finally being renovated or rebuilt decades later than they are now. So what you need is for the city to ensure there's always a decent supply of excess land zoned for each density level owned broadly enough that oligopoly BS doesn't come into play so that the profit maximizing choice is to always buy a plot of land with less density or with an actually uninhabitable building on it and build more density and they need to do this at every density level in their code. That's the big picture problem with North American cities. There are sub problems to this (like how we are providing parking wrong, suboptimal public service design, especially transport infrastructure) but the above is the big picture biggest problem