4 ms·
>> i really wish that our searches would prioritize quality of information Use a free service, and the person providing it doesn't have an incentive to give yo
by ethbr1 3y ago
>> i really wish that our searches would prioritize quality of information
Use a free service, and the person providing it doesn't have an incentive to give you what you want.
Which is how we got current Google.
- struant 3y agoThe problem isn't that it is free. The problem is that it is funded by ads. Ads are a disincentive to providing useful information. That is fundamentally what an ad is. Someone paying to spread disinformation.
- darkwater 3y ago> Someone paying to spread disinformation. They prefer you to use the form "their take on reality" . Misinformation is bad! Point of view is good!
- tzs 3y ago> That is fundamentally what an ad is. Someone paying to spread disinformation. So when I see an add for say Kenwood's latest radios in QST magazine, what would be the disinformation being spread? Or an ad for House of Staunton chess sets in Chess Life magazine?
- ang_cire 3y agoThey are presenting a perspective that is designed to not only present the product in the best light, but also to convince you that you should purchase it (whether that is true or not). I think disinformation probably implies a level in malice that is not present (or rather, present in consumerist systems by default, and not specific to advertisers), but obviously trying to convince someone to purchase something which it might actually not be good for them to buy, is misinforming them. If a friend told you to buy a product and you did and it sucked, you'd be upset at them. But when a company does it with an ad, no one gets upset, because we understand that ads are lying to us. We don't expect that they're being honest. Or put another way, we expect that they are misinforming us about our need for, and appreciation of, the product.
- somestag 3y agoHonestly I disagree with this pretty strongly. First, I (and many people that I know) do get upset when an ad misrepresents a product and we get burned. It happens all the time, and people complain about it constantly. You might argue this is wasted breath, but it still happens. I would also say that while everyone accepts that ads are at a high risk for dishonesty, the vast majority of people live their lives assuming that ads convey some useful information, even if it's just the vague intent and target audience of the product. It's easy to pick out specific genres of ads that don't seem to do this, and ad rhetoric can often be complicated and interesting, but generally speaking they do try to convey some sort of genuine information about the product. Saying that ads are fundamentally misinformation people because they are "obviously trying to convince someone to purchase something which might actually not be good for them to buy" seems like a reasonable criticism at first glance, but actually I think that's kind of a ridiculous standard. No one except my closest friends and family have any idea what might be "good for me to buy", and I am not so against the idea of basic commerce that I think it's useful to say that someone hawking their wares is "misinforming" the public simply because they're trying to sell to strangers. This is not to say that the ad industry isn't infested with slimy people with perverse incentives. Of course it is. But advertising itself is a basic extension of human communication, and I think it's awfully cynical to say that any attempt to show someone why they might want to buy your product is spreading misinformation. I do believe that it's okay to advocate for something, and then let people decide for themselves if they agree. If it's not, then nearly all human discourse is an exercise in misinformation. (Inb4 "actually, nearly all human discourse is misinformation")
- ang_cire 3y agoThere is a massive gap between a vendor hawking their wares on the street, and modern ad campaigns and techniques. To conflate those 2 as being remotely similar in levels of influence (even at an individual level) is insane. Also, I'm not sure why you jumped to assuming that I apparently believe advertising shouldn't be allowed, just because I can acknowledge that it is based entirely on selfish intent by the ad creators? All I said was that ads are a form of misinformation. You're the one drawing conclusions about what responses that must entail. If you prefer to pretend it's not misinformation just because you apparently cannot reconcile that stance, and allowing ads to continue to exist, that's a "you" problem.
- akhosravian 3y agoI have a very strong distaste for our based future, but saying ads are “paying to spread disinformation” is like saying joining the army is only for people who want to murder other humans. There’s an element of truth, but it is way too reductive. Are you of the mind that word of mouth is the only moral way to grow a business?
- toofy 3y agoyeah, i mean, this is hn, we’ve been collectively dissecting the “you’re not the customer” issue for years upon years. it doesn’t make it less of a shame. and it certainly shouldn’t stop us from wondering.
- ethbr1 3y agoIMHO, it's the monopoly aspect that really jumped the shark. Google as one among competitors (read: pre-Android/~2005) still had to be a useful enough search engine to attract users. Once their search share attained hegemony, user satisfaction deprioritized (relatively) and revenue was allowed to dominate. And thus, we now get a Google who has little interest in weeding out SEO'd spam. (And not as in 'tweaking their algorithm' -- as in fundamentally detecting and delisting all recipe-story porn and answer-mills)
- kortilla 3y agoGoogle had the same issue pre-monopoly. Since its early history it’s been trying to show users what other users like. “Correctness” was never part of the equation because search engines that paid deference to authority all sucked. You can easily start a search engine using a different model. You’re going to struggle to compete with anything that prioritizes what users find popular.
- ethbr1 3y agoMy memory may be faulty, but ~2000 I remember results being more objectively useful from a user perspective. Versus competitors. Granted, it was a simpler problem then, given early web. But the slide since (in the face of revenue counter-incentives) feels at best like ambivalence about objective value to user.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoCirca 2000 the Web was a lot less commercial and filled with ads (and trackers).
- devonkim 3y agoExcept much of the alt media ecosystem of grifters and influencers are precisely providing people what they want to hear and raise massive amounts of money doing so. They oftentimes do not think they’re grifters because they feel they are responding to a “market need” and so they are providing a service even if they might not even agree ethically with the output necessarily. This is how we wind up with so many conspiracy theorist nutjobs dominating recommendation algorithms again and again across many different platforms. People are highly, highly fallible and what they want may be, in fact, some of the worst things for them. As such I’m convinced that most adults are only physically and legally that way given how incredibly naive and immature people appear to be as a baseline regardless of cultural or even educational background.