5 ms·
"MP3 is dead" missed the real, much better story (2017)
- Semaphor 3y agoDiscussed at the time with 290 comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14347648 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14347648
- justsomehnguy 3y agoOne of amusing outtakes from the previous comments: I somewhat recently found out my phones do support FLAC natively, so I don't need to transcode. It's not like I did transcode anything in years, besides obvious CD ripping decades ago, but there is no need to do so for some years because everything just plays and the storage is not a concern with both TransFla^W sorry, microSD cards and modern phones with gigabytes of flash.
- pimeys 3y agoI used to use FLAC in my phone, but now I have over two terabytes of music in my Plex server, so I just stream it as OPUS which works great for this.
- Semaphor 3y agoI only recently started switching to FLAC, because I always felt space-constrained ;) At some point, I’ll have to redownload all those Bandcamp .ogg Albums.
- everyone 3y agoYou know FLAC is an archive format right? If you are planning to transcode the music in future into new files then it's ok. If you're planning to simply listen to it, then mp3 v0 sounds identical and is much smaller.
- Semaphor 3y agoWell, while I listen to FLAC natively (pretty sure Jellyfin knows that all my clients are capable of FLAC playback), the whole point is that I won’t be dependent on Bandcamp existing in 40 years to still enjoy my music in the LLM generated meta-crypto-space that only supports Matroobis files ;) With the quality of my speakers (the fanciest being a Logitech 5.1 system), I could probably go even lower without hearing a difference ;)
- TonyTrapp 3y agoIt's good to treat your music collection as an archive - it's not unheard of that artists pull their albums from Bandcamp or other services, with no possibility for you to redownload it if you ever decide that the format you downloaded it in is no longer up for the task. And especially with commercial releases you will never know if buying the release again in some other place will give you the same experience - it might be a bad remaster and getting hold of the original version might be impossible legally.
- bayindirh 3y agoWell, it doesn't but I'll not reiterate why, for the third time. If your system is not transparent enough, you can't hear what FLAC or a CD offers, and that's OK. MP3 v0 sounds pretty impressive given the album is not brickwalled.
- majkinetor 3y agoI also use FLAC exclusively now. Space is not a problem any more and your archive can be used in many situations - different players, parties, as samples etc. Its not worth thinking about it. Furthermore, people that share FLAC are way more pedantic about their archive in general - like checking for re-encoding low quality mp3s, file hashs etc.
- deadbunny 3y agoI'd highly recommend bandcamp-collection-downloader[1]. As a heavy buyer of music from bandcamp it's great to just run a command[2] and have everything download while also keeping track of previous downloads so it doesn't re-download them. Personally I have them moved to a temp folder then I process/tag them with Picard[3] but you could probably automate that step with Beets[4] but I've not delved into it yet. 1. https://github.com/Ezwen/bandcamp-collection-downloader https://github.com/Ezwen/bandcamp-collection-downloader 2. https://gist.github.com/ryanwalder/d5d6d1d43b4b77fb92bde75b5eec2105 https://gist.github.com/ryanwalder/d5d6d1d43b4b77fb92bde75b5... (stick it in ~/bin/bandcamp and just run `bandcamp` to download everything) 3. https://picard.musicbrainz.org/ https://picard.musicbrainz.org/ 4. https://github.com/beetbox/beets https://github.com/beetbox/beets
- Semaphor 3y agoThanks, I actually got the idea from recently finding bandcamp-collection-downloader, as doing it by myself just does not sound like fun, at all :D The tagging I’ll keep manual (I have the Jellyfin library location shared via SMB and added the share to MediaMonkey on my Desktop PC) as I have specific needs for genre, by far my most important field besides the basics (Artist/Album/Year/Song, and those are all tagged properly by Bandcamp).
- lloeki 3y ago> The tagging I’ll keep manual Picard is not automatic, I'd describe it mostly as "assisted". There's a two step process of track clustering and release metadata searching that are automatic, but each transition to the next step is manual so that you can review and adjust (either by using another matching method, fixing the lookup by pointing it to the correct release, or manually editing). There's a "gold disc" visual feedback for when it detected perfect matches. You can also decide if some/all tags should be updated from the global database or kept from the original file thus using the database as enrichment.
- Semaphor 3y agoYeah, but what is the advantage? Artist/Album/Track are already correct, genre I do manually. I don’t really use other tags.
- pizza234 3y ago> AAC and other newer audio codecs can produce better quality than MP3, but the difference is only significant at low bitrates AFAIR this is not correct (it's based on the Opus marketing page). In the last decade, interest in transparent bitrates (192+ kb) has faded, so it's hard to find listening tests. A few blind tests on the Hydrogenaudio page¹ report MP3 to be inferior to AAC at 192 kbps. A research reports² that the quality is the same (although if I understand correctly, looking at one analysis, results of noise/distortion are inconsistent, e.g. WAV being in some cases noisier/more distorted than MP3³). The same research references another research that find MP3 to be transparent at bitrates >= 256 Kbps. Something I remember is that MP3 spends a disproportionate amount of storage in order to encode frequencies > 16 Khz. This may explain why in some tests, it performs worse in mid-high bitrates (160/192 Kbps), although I don't know the technical details. ¹=https://hydrogenaud.io/index.php/board,40.0.html https://hydrogenaud.io/index.php/board,40.0.html ²=https://www.hindawi.com/journals/ijdmb/2019/8265301 https://www.hindawi.com/journals/ijdmb/2019/8265301 ³=https://www.hindawi.com/journals/ijdmb/2019/8265301/fig2 https://www.hindawi.com/journals/ijdmb/2019/8265301/fig2
- earthnail 3y agoMost encoders apply a low pass filter to cut off frequencies above 16kHz. Some do it above 18kHz but most choose 16kHz as default setting. This is common in all lossy codecs - mp3, aac etc.
- pizza234 3y agoIt depends on the bitrate. AFAIR, LAME applies at 16 KHz cutoff at 128 kbps, and 17 Khz at 160 kbps. I don't have data about the others, but AFAIK a similar approach should apply. I'm not able to hear above 16 Khz. I've tried only once an experiment with another person, and they were definitely able to discern the difference.
- fsiefken 3y agoHE-AACv2 is better at low bitrates (spoken podcasts) then mp3. ffmpeg -i input.wav -c:a libfdk_aac -vbr 3 -b:a 32k -profile:a aac_he_v2 output.m4a There is also xHE-AAC https://gitlab.com/ecodis/exhale https://gitlab.com/ecodis/exhale https://www.mainconcept.com/hubfs/PDFs/User%20Guides/MainConcept%20xHE-AAC%20Encoder%20Plug-In%20for%20FFmpeg%20User%20Guide.pdf https://www.mainconcept.com/hubfs/PDFs/User%20Guides/MainCon...
- earthboundkid 3y agoIt is annoying that a lot of Wikipedia pages still have sound samples in some crazy Ogg format that normal people’s browsers cannot play.
- kibibu 3y agoWikipedia has, rightfully imo, chosen to use an open format. My browser plays it just fine.
- earthboundkid 3y agoRTFA. MP3 has been a free format for over 6 years.
- Kwpolska 3y agoDoes every desktop Linux distro include MP3 support in the base system? How many of the audio files on Wikipedia are older than 6 years old?
- earthboundkid 3y agoLinux users are self-selecting. Wikipedia is an encyclopedia for everyone, not tech enthusiasts who decide to pick software that doesn't support an extremely common, non-propriety (!!!!!!) file format.
- 0xDEADFED5 3y agoOgg Vorbis kicks ass. the 320k ogg that spotify uses are top notch
- waysa 3y agoAccording to caniuse.com [1] all major browsers support ogg vorbis except for one: Safari. [1] https://caniuse.com/ogg-vorbis https://caniuse.com/ogg-vorbis
- 3y ago
- h4kor 3y agoI've build an analysis of audio usage in podcasts. Currently 93% are using MP3 and 7% AAC. Ogg and Opus have virtually no usage at all. https://podcast-standard.org/audio/ https://podcast-standard.org/audio/ "Spotify for Podcasters" is the biggest hosting service pushing AAC usage, with ~30% of their inventory being AAC. https://podcast-standard.org/hosting_systems/spotify/ https://podcast-standard.org/hosting_systems/spotify/
- Flimm 3y agoDo the AAC podcasts provide MP3 files as a fallback for podcast players that don't support AAC? Is that even a possibility? Thank you for the fantastic website, by the way! It's fascinating.
- h4kor 3y agoThere are ways to do that, but I don't know how many pod catchers support these. The most common solution I can see is to provide multiple RSS feeds, one for each audio format.
- qwerty456127 3y ago> Ogg and Opus have virtually no usage at all. I mostly use OPUS nowadays. Just download a podcast/audiobook/whatever, convert it to 32 kbps (which even is redundant! even lower is totally Okay, 24 kbps still can sound subjectively lossless for human speech, 16 kbps will probably be still good yet audibly different) OPUS with the voip profile and fit tons of content to listen to offline on whatever a humble storage your portable device has left. OPUS really saves the day as today smartphones storage usually is filled with high-quality pictures and videos you have taken and apps getting gigger and bigger every year. I wish Apple would introduce first-class OPUS support in the M4B container in iTunes but as long as it doesn't (and I doubt it ever will) 3-rd party audiobook players do a great job.
- teruakohatu 3y agoWhat audiobook player do you recommend?
- rjst01 3y agoThis is a great piece and deserves to be revisited from time to time - it shows how much journalism is actually just PR for for-profit companies. The most insane thing about this is that none of the patents specify enough detail to actually implement MP3 - the official specifications are behind lock and key, and can no longer be purchased for any price. Unless they leak from someone who had a license, the public will never get to see them. For all intents and purposes, the LAME source code is now the official specification for MP3.
- goodluckchuck 3y ago> none of the patents specify enough detail to actually implement MP3 So, it was never a valid patent to begin with.
- hoseja 3y agoUnlike other software patents?
- Retric 3y agoNo, you misunderstood what parents are for. Patents only cover the non obvious details to do some very specific thing. They aren’t CAD drawings with every detail specified, so you may be able to make a windshield wiper from one but it wouldn’t be a drop in replacement for a specific vehicle’s windshield wiper, in fact multiple different designs can all fall under the same patent. The existence of multiple MP3 related patents makes it clear it’s not simply implementing a single idea. So you may be able to make a similar compression algorithm, but it wouldn’t be MP3.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- l33tman 3y agoI remember fondly that I did a masters thesis back in 1997 implementing an MP3 decoder on a 40 MIPS DSP, that was also network connected. It might have been the first networked audio streamer in the world :) But I had to go with their super-unoptimized C-based specification. I did have the MP3 standard to read as well as a reference, and I'm sure it's spread all over the internet and its corners..
- immibis 3y agoPatents give patent pirates an advantage while hindering people who play by the rules.
- extraduder_ire 3y agoSoftware patents also don't apply in some jurisdictions, like the EU. For a long time, linux mint didn't bother asking if you wanted mp3 support on install (like ubuntu of the era) because it was packaged in France.
- Clamchop 3y agoThat's true for any law and its scoff laws.
- sowbug 3y agoAnyone know of a Rust crate that encodes MP3? I'm looking for one that isn't a wrapper around LAME, whose licensing is complicated.