4 ms·
Batteries are heavy, expensive and we don’t have infrastructure to charge them at the required scale. I don’t believe hydrogen is the answer but methane cells
by baq 3y ago
Batteries are heavy, expensive and we don’t have infrastructure to charge them at the required scale.
I don’t believe hydrogen is the answer but methane cells could be… liquid energy storage is just so much more practical compared to alternatives.
- dangus 3y ago“We don’t have the infrastructure” is a temporary problem. The same could have been said about gas stations and the electrical grid capacity needed for widespread air conditioning. Weight isn’t such a crazy thing either. The Tesla Model Y long range weighs 900 pounds more than a Honda CRV. It’s a lot, but the most popular car in America is the Ford F-150 which weighs about the same as a Model Y at the low end. The weight efficiency can only improve from here and more charging infrastructure and faster recharge times will mean less demand for long range variants. This is ideal for electrics because shorter frequent stops are more time efficient for EVs while for gas vehicles it’s the opposite. The great thing about electricity is that it’s even easier to transport and generate than liquid fuel storage. Generation can be centralized with a diverse set of energy sources.
- baq 3y agoWeight is an air pollution problem - tires and brake pads release fines during normal usage. Regenerative braking helps, but only so much. https://academic.oup.com/toxsci/article/145/1/98/1627384 https://academic.oup.com/toxsci/article/145/1/98/1627384 Electricity is easy to transport but very hard to store and it's the storage that's the problem, see batteries.
- ninkendo 3y ago> The weight efficiency can only improve from here I don’t think this is a given. I can imagine plenty of future battery tech that is much more physically dense, and also more energy-dense, but with an overall mass that’s heavier than what we have now. Consumers really want more range, and they don’t really care about their car’s weight so long as it isn’t prohibitive. (They will definitely care collectively as the roads deteriorate faster and they have to pay more in tax dollars and wasted time spent in construction to repair them, but that will end up being a tragedy of the commons.)
- dangus 3y agoI’m already on board with the urbanist camp that believes car-focused infrastructure is economically and environmentally unsustainable. EVs don’t help the American addiction to stroads and strip malls. I just happen to also believe that EVs are no worse than the status quo and are almost certainly at least marginally better than any other alternative on the table.
- nithril 3y agoIs range really an issue if you can easily find charging spot and recharge in less than 15min?
- ninkendo 3y agoIt is in the mind of consumers, yes (I have not offered my personal opinion and don’t want to, as it’s irrelevant to the point.) There has been a lot of consumer studies on this and range anxiety is a very real thing.
- rootusrootus 3y ago> They will definitely care collectively as the roads deteriorate faster and they have to pay more in tax dollars and wasted time spent in construction to repair them, but that will end up being a tragedy of the commons The difference in wear between a 3600 pound RAV4 and a 4400 pound Model Y is so minor that it'll disappear in the noise. Nobody will notice. The only time it'll even come close to mattering is on residential streets that never see any commercial trucks. And even then, nobody cares now about the 6500 pound HD pickups that are so popular, so I can't see why that would suddenly become an issue.
- ninkendo 3y agoI mean, if we’re picking models to support our points, I’d counter with the Hummer EV which is 9,630 lbs. Road wear goes up with the 4th power of weight, so doubling the weight increases road wear 16x… it’s not something we should just ignore.
- theshrike79 3y ago_You_ don't. We do. There are 6 over 100kW charging spots under 1km of my house. Although I don't need any of them, because I can charge where I park at 2kW all day and night.
- baq 3y ago6 is a number an order of magnitude too small unless you live in a desert. If you live in a city, it's probably closer to two orders. To support 60 assuming ~50% utilization you'll need 1MW per 1 sqkm additional power. This isn't a small number. The grid anywhere is absolutely not ready for such a rapid increase of load. There isn't enough refined copper produced worldwide to upgrade the grid. I mean setting up a copper mine on 16 Psyche is not a batshit insane idea here.
- rovolo 3y agoWhy does a city need ~100 L3 chargers per km2? People don't need to drive as far within a city, so even home L1 chargers should handle most city residents needs. The L3 chargers seem most useful on highways exiting the city.
- wilg 3y agoWell, we have a power grid and not a hydrogen grid.
- alexfromapex 3y agoHydrogen can be created from water and electricity
- theshrike79 3y agoIt can yes, but the efficiency is laughable. It's only viable when you've got essentially free renewables AND you've filled every battery you can.
- alexfromapex 3y agoWater is quite affordable and so is solar. The efficiency of both solar and electrolysis will likely increase as more research is done.
- wilg 3y agoObviously. But if you already have the electricity it's more efficient to use it directly.
- linkjuice4all 3y agoWe (in the US) have very little hydrogen infrastructure but there's high voltage power lines basically everywhere - so it seems like hydrogen has the infrastructure and scaling issues. Batteries are indeed heavy - but so are portable hydrogen storage cell that don't easily explode or require liquid cooling. I agree with you that hydrogen isn't the answer but methane doesn't really seem to be either. Batteries and electric cars are already here - they just need to continue scaling the infrastructure and work on lightening up the vehicles.
- LtWorf 3y agoThere isn't enough infrastructure to power all the eventual electric cars.
- _aavaa_ 3y agoBut there isn’t any infrastructure for fueling the hydrogen cars. A move towards hydrogen means 3-5x more energy requirements (which also cost money) as well as a transmission and distribution network for the gas. At home charging and on street parking charging will be an easier retrofit than the construction of new refueling stations.
- LtWorf 3y agoWell the whole powergrid needs to be basically re-made to handle all the extra load… although I agree that it's probably cheaper than distributing hydrogen. Anyway we should go towards trains IMHO, we should absolutely not even have long distance trucks.
- natch 3y agoYet.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoYou're right, we'll need about 20% more electricity if we replaced all our ICE cars with electric ones. If we stop selling gas cars in 2035 then by about 2045 we'll hit ~99% electric cars. Are you implying we can't increase our infrastructure by 20% in 20 years?
- vel0city 3y agoAbout the infrastructure. I've got many ways to recharge my car available today. I've got zero places to fill hydrogen. I don't even have many CNG options.
- jackmott42 3y ago>we don’t have infrastructure to charge them at the required scale. Yeah we do, or to be more precise, we are having no trouble expanding the infrastructure at the same rate people are buying the cars.