8 ms·
Well done. There would be so many more cool applications of e-ink if it wasn't $2,500 for a 42" display: https://shopkits.eink.com/en/product/detail/42''Monochr
by xnx 3y ago
Well done. There would be so many more cool applications of e-ink if it wasn't $2,500 for a 42" display: https://shopkits.eink.com/en/product/detail/42''MonochromeePaperDisplay(VB3300-RBA) https://shopkits.eink.com/en/product/detail/42''MonochromeeP... (minimum order 3)
For comparison a 42" full-color 60fps TV with remote, speakers, wifi, etc. etc. is $140.
It seems like the patent holder could be making a lot more money if they dropped the price.
- slg 3y agoWho is going to do the math and figure out how long you need to hypothetically have these screens on before the power costs of the TV actually make up the $2360 difference in price?
- mrd3v0 3y agoThe E-ink patent holder is one of the most egregious cases of patent trolls. They won't lower the prices.
- mahdi7d1 3y agoI guess people only care and notice theire own prefrences. I never thought about 42" eink display but I'm constantly wishing for the price of 10" and 13" modules to drop cause that's the usecase I'm interested in. I think their demand would be much much more compared to a 42" panel (what even is the use of such thing) so they can benefit from scale.
- herpderperator 3y agoWhere does it show the minimum order is 3?
- xnx 3y agoThe article. "Some advanced Google-fu was used to find a supplier shipping to Europe. Minimum order quantity: 3 pieces."
- adql 3y agoYeah I'd love to have big display/dashboard on a wall that isn't acting as extra light in the room but not at those prices. Transflective LCD is other option bit also pretty hard/expensive to get a big screen...
- layer8 3y agoWell, Apple’s 32” Pro Display XDR is $5000, there’s always something.
- graypegg 3y agoHmm. I wonder what the whole-sale price is? A TV with wifi is partly subsidized by the ads you see when you turn it on. This 2500$ display seems like it’s for small run signage, so they know it’s being sold for government/business use. Probably a bit inflated. Does Rakutan/Amazon/Pocketbook really pay a similar cost/size ratio for the panels on their ereaders? I hope not!
- lawlessone 3y ago>so they know it’s being sold for government/business use. Probably a bit inflated. You just reminded me, a few years ago i wanted to buy a transparent screen for a DIY project. The company said they couldn't sell it to me because they're b2b. I think it was both a volume thing and a tax thing.. and possibly a liability thing.
- tomcam 3y agoOr they may have no procedure for selling one-offs to end users. It’s not uncommon.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>For comparison a 42" full-color 60fps TV with remote, speakers, wifi, etc. etc. is $140. Because it's a lot easier and cheaper to manufacture large LCD panels at scale than E-ink film. >It seems like the patent holder could be making a lot more money if they dropped the price. I don't know any company or shareholders that would say no to making more money so if this would actually be true then it would, but that's not the reality. The FUD that large e-ink displays are expensive because of some patent conspiracy needs to stop. Large e-ink screens are expensive because manufacturing yields are very low and so are sales volumes. Source: worked with e-ink on products with big and small displays Edit: So I'm saying the truth and getting down voted for it? Fine, then feel free to keep believing whatever you think is the truth. No point in discussing it further.
- bigmattystyles 3y agoOne thing I don’t understand - why are the iPhone screens that can run in display mode run at 1hz a feature - what’s hard about driving a display typically driven at 120hz(?) at 1hz to save on power difficult? Or it’s not and the it’s a differentiating feature price.
- solardev 3y agoIs the refresh really a big power draw vs the backlight or even the pixels themselves? I think the thing about e-ink is that it's a chemical producing/retaining the pigment, rather than a light source. So even when it's off, it retains its current colors. When a LED is off, it's just... nothing. But you still have a point. Even if a LED display has "only" a 2 or 3 day battery life, that's still pretty huge to mere hours. How do smart watches (like the Garmins with 1-week batteries) do it?
- pxeboot 3y agoThe Garmin watches with 1+ week battery life have memory-in-pixel displays. Like E-Ink, this seems like another technology that could be amazing if they were available in larger sizes with lower prices.
- 3y ago
- mikepurvis 3y agoI've read (probably on prior HN discussions about this?) that the manufacturing process still has major yield issues— when you're making small displays, you can slice around the bad pixels and not have to waste as much, but making a large display requires a huge sheet to all be perfect. Then again, if that was really it, surely there'd be a market for people who want a 42" e-ink display and are willing to accept some proportion of bad pixels in exchange for a deep discount. Which really shouldn't matter much, particularly for applications where distance-viewing is the expectation.
- diggan 3y ago> if it wasn't $2,500 for a 42" display Try $3000 :) > Driving boards are not included in the display module package. E Ink Salt kit is designed to support this module > Salt Driving Board - $500.00 - https://shopkits.eink.com/en/product/detail/SaltDrivingBoard https://shopkits.eink.com/en/product/detail/SaltDrivingBoard
- ThrowawayTestr 3y agoThe first flat panel tvs started in the $x000 price range. I'm amazed an eink display this big is actually affordable (minimum quantities aside).
- bufferoverflow 3y agoE-ink has been around for a long time. It's not one of the first panels.
- qingcharles 3y agoMy first 40" flat panel TV ran something around $6000 IIRC.
- red_hare 3y agoMy dream is, when these finally come down in price, to build a dynamic DnD map.
- spullara 3y agoWhy not just put any other kind of display flat and put glass over it to protect it? Edit: Someone has your dream display already :) https://www.etsy.com/listing/1463146123/43-4k-dnd-tv-table https://www.etsy.com/listing/1463146123/43-4k-dnd-tv-table
- KennyBlanken 3y ago[flagged]
- jamestanderson 3y agoI'm sad to see this comment, scoffing at an independent creator just selling something cool online. I wonder why this reaction? Is it the imagined profit margin? Or just the choice of words in the listing? The listing says it's a 43" 4K Samsung display, which a quick look on Amazon shows goes for at least around $270. They also offer free shipping, so shipping is effectively included in the price. I don't know how much walnut or acrylic costs, or desktop CNC's. The price doesn't seem unreasonable to me for a turnkey complete package, since I don't have the skills or tools to make this myself.
- jsjohnst 3y ago> The price doesn't seem unreasonable to me for a turnkey complete package, since I don't have the skills or tools to make this myself. I have the skills and tools to build this myself. Based on some napkin math, materials and labor comes out to around $500 give or take. If GP knew anything at all about developing and selling physical goods, they’d know that the price is about right. Etsy charges non-trivial fees, payment processors charge fees, marketing costs money, wear and tear on tools, taxes, insurance, warranty, customer support, fraud, etc etc etc
- prewett 3y agoIf it's a 4k TV it also has more pixels and better refresh rate. And color. But for that extra $2360 you get the feature that your image is still there when the power is off. I expect that feature would be substantially more costly regardless of the patent holder's extra.
- malfist 3y agoBut that's not the only benefit of eink. EInk doesn't have a backlight. So it's easy to see in glaring light. It's also not disruptive if so, you want to use it as a digital picture frame and you don't want light from the display bothering your eyes day and night. EInk is a more peaceful display technology, and some people put a lot of value on that.
- nomel 3y ago> you get the feature that your image is still there when the power is off How is that a realistic feature? Who is losing power and being happy that they spent a few thousand more, nearly 40x, than a 36" photo quality print, just so the image can remain while their lights are off?
- k1t 3y agoThe point is that it only uses power when changing the image, so a small battery can run it for a long time - not that it works during a power outage. (and of course it is a lot easier to change than a printed photo)
- nomel 3y agoFor $2,200, you could run a 35W 43” $160 TV for 29 years, if your power is $0.3/kWh. In reality, much more, with a dim display at night. I understand being eco friendly, but that’s an absurd, entirely negligible, justification. I would claim the reflective display is the killer feature.
- callalex 3y ago