3 ms·
> A bytceode runtime is not an “application”. It's not hardware. Would you be happier if I said "excluding software that competes with their own"? Why would
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> A bytceode runtime is not an “application”.
It's not hardware.
Would you be happier if I said "excluding software that competes with their own"?
Why would it be any better if they are excluding hardware that competes with their own?
> Apple never stopped VSCode from being on iOS. There are plenty of IDEs for the iPad built by third parties.
VSCode is an app that needs the .NET runtime, in order to run the code you write in e.g. C#. They don't allow the runtime it needs which means they don't allow the app (which competes with theirs).
> Are you making up things now? You don’t run CUDA on any non Nvidia hardware.
iPads have Thunderbolt, so you could actually plug NVIDIA hardware into them. Or someone could port CUDA to Apple's GPUs, as AMD essentially did with HIP. Except that would be this:
> But yes, you are free to port OpenCL to iOS if you want to.
Implementing such a thing efficiently requires driver support, but you can't modify the drivers nor supply your own.
> A “payment API” is not an “application”. Yes the cross platform frameworks do expose the underlying API.
A payments system is a part of an application. They prohibit broad categories of apps that use any but their own payments system.
Using Apple's payments API doesn't allow for apps that use a competing payments system, which was the whole point.
> And you can have a cross platform app that forces you to subscribe outside of the App Store - Spotify, Netflix, Microsoft, etc all do that.
I point to a category of thing they prohibit and then you point to the exception that proves the rule as if that meant they don't impose the rule.
We know they don't do it for a specific subset of subscription services anymore. They still do it in general, which is to say that they still do it.
> Are you saying that their no competitors on iOS to AppleTV, Apple Music, Apple Podcasts, Apple Books, the iWork suite?
This is the same thing again. It's not a question of if they prohibit every app that competes with theirs, it's a question of if they prohibit any app that competes with theirs.
Which they do. You can't get real Firefox on iOS:
https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/add-ons-firefox-ios https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/add-ons-firefox-ios
And it's not because Mozilla doesn't want to provide it.
- scarface_74 3y ago> It's not hardware. So now are kernel extensions also “applications”? > VSCode is an app that needs the .NET runtime, in order to run the code you write in e.g. C#. You could not possibly be more wrong. VSCode is written in Typescript. It is an Electron app. There have been cross platform JS frameworks that ran on iOS for a decade. Besides that, it’s been years since you have needed the .Net runtime to run .Net applications. https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/uwp/dotnet-native/ https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/uwp/dotnet-native/ And Microsoft already has a solution to run .Net code on iOS https://dotnet.microsoft.com/en-us/apps/mobile https://dotnet.microsoft.com/en-us/apps/mobile > payments system is a part of an application. They prohibit broad categories of apps that use any but their own payments system. There is an existence proof that there are applications that exist on iOS right now that force you to pay outside of their ecosystem. Are you really crying over pay to win games? > We know they don't do it for a specific subset of subscription services anymore. They still do it in general, which is to say that they still do it Can you name any none pay to win games that couldn’t be a subscription service outside of the App Store? And your solution to supporting CUDA is a breakout box on an iPad with an nvidua card? Who the hell is going to buy that? There is nothing stopping
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> So now are kernel extensions also “applications”? They're things some "applications" need in order to function, so if you can't include them you've effectively prohibited those applications. But what does it matter if something is an "application" or not? Why is it any better if Apple precludes third parties from competing with their kernel extensions? > VSCode is written in Typescript. It is an Electron app. It's not the IDE you have to be able to run, it's the code you write in it. > And Microsoft already has a solution to run .Net code on iOS That's just compiling the code to a native binary, which you would then have to go submit through Apple's store. How does that help for an IDE expected to allow you to test (i.e. execute) and debug the code you've just written ten seconds ago? > Can you name any none pay to win games that couldn’t be a subscription service outside of the App Store? https://developer.apple.com/support/reader-apps/ https://developer.apple.com/support/reader-apps/ We can see right there some examples of what isn't allowed: Not facilitate real-time, person-to-person services (e.g., providing tutoring services, medical consultations, real estate tours, or fitness training). Apps that let people access digital content such as music or video, but not as the primary functionality, are not considered reader apps and are not eligible for the External Link Account Entitlement. For example, a social networking app that lets people stream audiovisual content is not eligible. > And your solution to supporting CUDA is a breakout box on an iPad with an nvidua card? Who the hell is going to buy that? Presumably the same sort of people who buy the existing graphics card docks on the market for other platforms.
- scarface_74 3y agoThere are plenty of solutions for running Python in an IDE on the iPad. There is an even an x86 emulator and a Linux terminal built on top of it in the App Store. https://ish.app/ https://ish.app/ It can run anything that you can run on an x86 in user mode. I downloaded the AWS CLI (which requires Python) to run some tests By the way, you were completely wrong about VSCode being written in .Net. > That's just compiling the code to a native binary, which you would then have to go submit through Apple's store. How does that help for an IDE expected to allow you to test (i.e. execute) and debug the code you've just written ten seconds ago? There is an existence proof that it could be done. If you ran iSH with remote VNC you could have a full IDE on a Mac. > We can see right there some examples of what isn't allowed: Not facilitate real-time, person-to-person services (e.g., providing tutoring services, medical consultations, real estate tours, or fitness training). You lack imagination. I actually know someone who does fitness classes online where most people use iPads and doesn’t pay Apple a dime - she’s sleeping right next to me. She uses Zoom. > But what does it matter if something is an "application" or not? Why is it any better if Apple precludes third parties from competing with their kernel extensions? It matters because once you allow kernel extensions it can bypass the security sandbox. Do you also think that Apple should allow third parties access to the Secure Enclave?