3 ms·
The core problem with trust fund debt is that if the government maintained assets for the social security trust fund the way vanguard or fidelity did, the under
by daft_pink 3y ago
The core problem with trust fund debt is that if the government maintained assets for the social security trust fund the way vanguard or fidelity did, the underlying assets would be so high that the government would start to own and control a large part of the American economy.
Do we really want all our company's to be majority owned by the government?
The practical answer from the government's perspective was to just the loan the money to itself. Except the problem now is that the government owes itself a lot of money.
Reality is that there is not trust fund and current payers simply have to pay the benefits for existing retirees. That's the way it has always been and that's the way it's always will be.
There will be economic problems no matter how the government handles such a large amount of money.
I believe that whenever there is a crisis or issue they will simply raise the income limits to correct it, and that's largely been happening as the income limit is going up and up and up every year. Way more than it did 20 years ago.
- hotnfresh 3y ago> Do we really want all our company's to be majority owned by the government? Not sure I’d want them to have voting shares, but actually—yeah, that sounds pretty good.
- daft_pink 3y agoBut this is the problem they grappled with when they created social security directly after the great depression market crash. It's important to understand that they invested in risk free assets ie government bonds, because it was a social safety net in reaction to problems in the market. Except it was much smaller then, the problem is that now they've created so many bonds that the bonds are the problem. Anyway you look at it, creating a giant government program like this is. going to be a problem.