3 ms·
The question is, is Social Security's Old Age, Survivors, and Disability Insurance program insurance, or is it a government welfare program. If it's insurance,
by toast0 3y ago
The question is, is Social Security's Old Age, Survivors, and Disability Insurance program insurance, or is it a government welfare program.
If it's insurance, than removing the cap on income charges without removing the cap on benefits is fundamentally unfair.
If it's a social welfare program, having a trust fund doesn't make a whole lot of sense. As well as quite some other things like paying people more benefits when they've had a higher historic income; that's the opposite of what I'd expect from a welfare program.
IMHO, it's a social welfare program that pretends to be an insurance scheme with wacky rules. Maintaining the fiction of an insurance scheme is clearly important to acceptance. There's also lots of features to encourage behaviors... Be sure to stay married for at least ten years to qualify for spousal benefits. Be sure to save up so you can delay claiming, and wink take advantage of our outdated actuarial tables. Don't forget to earn more money now (and pay more taxes now) so you can get higher benefits later.