8 ms·
The rent is too damn algorithmic
- lozenge 3y agoIt's a funny title but can we link to the full article? "The Rent Is Too Damn Algorithmic" https://washingtoncitypaper.com/article/631326/attorney-general-brian-schwalb-has-started-an-antitrust-investigation-of-a-company-helping-landlords-set-rent-prices/ https://washingtoncitypaper.com/article/631326/attorney-gene...
- hiAndrewQuinn 3y ago> [RealPage's] algorithm is based on pricing data from its own clients, prompting some experts to speculate that the company effectively provides a way for big landlords to collude and fix prices. This seems like it would only be an effective form of collusion if everyone or almost everyone in the same area used, and therefore fed data into, RealPage. If it's only a small slice of a given city's rentals it seems like it would be much less effective. Perhaps the real way to fix this is regulation requiring all landlords to publish their rent pricing data in an open and accessible way. I don't know if such data exists or not in the United States, or even here in Finland, but I would be absolutely fascinated to see it. EDIT: Bloomberg Terminal users, does your magic know-everything machine have this kind of data?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jprafael 3y agoNot a bloomberg terminal user here. But Multiple Listing Services offer this data.
- n4r9 3y agoThe lawsuit alleges that it controls a decent percentage of the market: > RealPage collects up-to-the-minute data on the historical and contemporaneous pricing from participating Lessors, data that, according to RealPage, is updated “every time [Lessors] make or change a [lease] renewal offer,” spanning over “16 million units,” which is a “very large chunk of the total inventory in the country.” https://www.hausfeld.com/media/550bhzyp/realpage-complaint-filed.pdf https://www.hausfeld.com/media/550bhzyp/realpage-complaint-f... Statista reckons this is out of 44 million units total in the USA: https://www.statista.com/statistics/187577/housing-units-occupied-by-renter-in-the-us-since-1975/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/187577/housing-units-occ...
- explaininjs 3y agoPlaying whack-a-mole with the most egregious examples of landlords extorting the need for people to have shelter to relocate as much money into their own pockets as humanly imaginable is fun to watch. But it’s not a solution. Anyone know any actual solutions? I feel landlords need to be removed as a class entirely. Residential property shouldn’t be able to be owned by anyone who does not reside in it (at least “some large X” percent of the year, perhaps).
- derelicta 3y agoRent-seeking is a cancer, it has to be abolished. There is an alternative to all of that, but you won't like its name.
- caskstrength 3y ago> Rent-seeking is a cancer, it has to be abolished. There is an alternative to all of that, but you won't like its name. As someone who was born in USSR I can venture a guess that OP won't also like its implementation.
- derelicta 3y agoAs someone whose (some) relatives were born in the old Yugoslavian Republic, they miss its implementation.
- caskstrength 3y agoSo why they are not voting to get it back? It is not like all kinds of Communist/Socialist parties are outlawed in either exUSSR or ex-Ugoslavian countries, it is just that some old people like to reminisce about it but nobody _actually_ wants it back.
- derelicta 3y agoYou can't vote yourself out of capitalism the same way you can't vote yourself out of slavery.
- username332211 3y agoLet me guess what's gonna happen. There will be a judgement against RealPage, the US being the only country in the world where commercial law is decided with trial by jury virtually guarantees it. Then rents will start rising even more. Landlords will be willing to do price discovery the old fashioned way, offering it with a high rent and letting the unit stay vacant until someone pays it. The cat's out of the bag. Now that people understand how much the market will bear with the present shortage of homes, rents are never going to go down. If RealPage has caused a rise in prices, it's because it showed old assumptions are wrong. Nothing short of mass brainwashing could bring them back. I guess acting against the housing shortage could also solve the issue, but let's be honest, that's never going to happen.
- bsder 3y ago> Then rents will start rising even more. Landlords will be willing to do price discovery the old fashioned way, offering it with a high rent and letting the unit stay vacant until someone pays it. And you fix this with a vacancy tax--which we should have whether this kind of collusion is true or not. Quite often, commercial entities holding apartment complexes are willing to let a property sit vacant because they can tack that onto the end of the financing while accepting lower rent would reset the basis of the financing agreement and force them to cough up cash. A vacancy tax puts the kibosh on this kind of behavior.
- t0suj4 3y agoVacancy tax is insane idea. What is stopping a bunch of crooks scaring away your renters until you sell them a house you intended to hand over to your children?
- earthling8118 3y agoWhat does this "bunch of crooks" look like while they are scaring people away? Seriously, I want to know a valid scenario where this happens. It sounds more insane to plan around that being the expectation than a vacancy tax.
- 3y ago
- iNic 3y agoThe same tech could probably be used to calculate a Land Value Tax.
- hiAndrewQuinn 3y agoA self assessed Harberger tax would be a really good idea with such data available! "The idea is to let each owner assess their property at any value they want, but that assessed value becomes a price at which they offer to sell their property to anyone. (Harberger didn’t invent the idea; it goes back at least to ancient Rome.) Posner and Weyl consider applying this basic idea to most all property, and call it a “Harberger tax.” That is, a simple way to create an incentive for low offer prices on any kind of property is to require the owner of that property to continuously pay a fee proportional to their posted offer price, i.e., the price they announce at which they will sell their property. The lower their price, the less they pay." From OB
- danaris 3y agoThere's a fairly major problem with that in our current environment: Requiring every property owner—or even every landlord—to offer their property for sale at a reasonable price to anyone who is willing to pay it is guaranteed to funnel most or all properties in a given area to one or a very small number of large corporations, which are then at liberty to dictate conditions to all their tenants (possibly even beyond the minimums the law specifies, if they're powerful enough to ignore that). The only way this can be avoided, IMO, is if the law also specifies the maximum rent that can be charged as a fraction of the value of the property (or the fraction of the property a given unit represents). Otherwise, the large corporations can simply buy all the property that is now always on the market, and charge rents just exorbitant enough to make massive profits, while not being quite enough to drive everyone out of the area.
- hiAndrewQuinn 3y agoThere are in fact 2 rebuttals here, one being the econ 101 answer: If I find out that a large company is gobbling up homes for any price I set on them, then I might as well build way more homes in that area because I've got a guaranteed buyer. That argument can still be overruled in the short term by pointing at the current zoning laws of many countries worldwide, and the second rebuttal is more interesting anyway: Who said anything about a 'reasonable' price? The proportionality constant between the tax levied and the listed sales price of the home is a precise instrument. We could just as easily set it to 0.1% per annum, so that people who list their homes for $1m/year still only pay $1000/year in tax and likely never see a serious purchaser, as we could set it to 10% per annum, where a $1m/year house accrues a whopping $100,000/year in Harberger taxes, which leads to people lowering the listed price, WLT many more sales and purchases, WLT considerably more housing liquidity. You could use either tactic to put the squeeze on bad actors, depending on your goals.
- n4r9 3y agoProPublica article from a year ago which I think kicked off the interest in the YieldStar algorithm: https://www.propublica.org/article/yieldstar-rent-increase-realpage-rent https://www.propublica.org/article/yieldstar-rent-increase-r...
- jprafael 3y agoNon US person here. Can anyone explain why is the lawsuit against RealPage and not the landlords specifically? They are the ones hypothetically doing the price fixing. Considering the following scenarios: * A landlord/tenant publishes their rent online: not price fixing. * A group of landlords/tenants publish their rents online: not price fixing. * A group of landlords share their rents privately: maybe price fixing? * A group of landlords share their rents to a 3rd party, which publicly shares aggregated data: doesn't look like price fixing to me. * A group of landlords share their rents to a 3rd party, which privately shares aggregated data: maybe price fixing? * A group of landlords share their rents to a 3rd party, which uses ML/AI to predict occupancy rates at a given price; and uses it to maximize expected profits to each individual: doesn't look like price fixing to me, maybe it is if we consider that it is using non-public data. * A group of landlords share their rents to a 3rd party, which uses reinforcement learning to dictate the best price to set, considering that the same policy will be shared with other landlords: price fixing. Considering the difference between the two last scenarios, is the lawmaker going to evaluate how sophisticated is the algorithm behind the scenes?
- junofan 3y agoThe AG isn’t a lawmaker. p52 of the AG’s contract says False Claim Act, Consumer Protection Procedures Act, Restraints of Trade, and Trusts in restraint of trade illegally. I highly doubt the algorithm is any more complicated than a couple of rules. The YieldStar guy already got busted by the DoJ for price fixing when he was at Alaska Airlines in the early 90s.
- futureamish 3y ago[flagged]
- dang 3y agoRelated: I saw RealPage's crappy rent-jacking-up software so you don't have to - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34926683 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34926683 - Feb 2023 (403 comments) DOJ will examine whether RealPage helped landlords coordinate rent increases - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33744136 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33744136 - Nov 2022 (123 comments) RealPage and landlords illegally created a 'cartel' to set prices, lawsuit says - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33633541 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33633541 - Nov 2022 (3 comments) Lawsuit filed against rent-setting software RealPage - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33317414 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33317414 - Oct 2022 (50 comments) Clever algorithm may be what's driving rent prices so high - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33313028 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33313028 - Oct 2022 (6 comments) Rent going up? One company’s algorithm could be why - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33224502 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33224502 - Oct 2022 (279 comments)