3 ms·
When buying the motherboard, you must check if it declares ECC support. This is normally specified in the "Memory" section of the specifications, in something
by adrian_b 3y ago
When buying the motherboard, you must check if it declares ECC support.
This is normally specified in the "Memory" section of the specifications, in something like "ECC & Non-ECC, Unbuffered Memory".
Beware of mentions of "On-die ECC", which is present in Non-ECC memories and which is irrelevant.
You also have to buy ECC DDR5 UDIMMs and you must be careful to not buy by accident ECC DDR5 RDIMMs, which are incompatible with AM5 motherboards. The ECC DDR5 UDIMMs have a width of either 80 bits or 72 bits. The width does not matter, as long as it is not the 64-bit width of Non-ECC DDR5 UDIMMs. (For some vendors it is cheaper to use identical x8 chips in ECC and Non-ECC modules, despite wasting some capacity, which results in an 80-bit width; there is a myth that DDR5 ECC DIMMs must have a width of 80 bits, the myth is wrong, because the standard includes 36-bit channels, which result in a 72-bit width for a dual-channel DIMM; for instance Micron makes 72-bit DDR5 ECC UDIMMs)
The last time when I have checked, ASUS had the most AM5 motherboards with ECC support. I like most the PRIME X670E-PRO WIFI because it has the best PCIe expandability beyond the slot occupied by the GPU.
However there are many other cheaper MBs, when less connectivity is enough.
- wil421 3y agoAbout on-die ECC, as you said avoid it like the plague. Real ECC memory has an extra chip on the stick to support ECC.
- 0xcde4c3db 3y ago> This is normally specified in the "Memory" section of the specifications, in something like "ECC & Non-ECC, Unbuffered Memory". I've seen allegations that for some vendors, text like this on their non-server/workstation boards turns out to mean that ECC modules will work in the board, but without the actual ECC function.
- adrian_b 3y agoWhile there might have existed such vendors, nobody provides more information than that written above in their MB specifications, so it is difficult to know for sure which is the case, before buying a MB. The only way to gain more confidence is if the downloadable MB manual has an exhaustive description of the BIOS options. If in the BIOS options there is one for enabling ECC and perhaps additional related options, e.g. for configuring scrubbing, only then there is complete certainty about ECC support in the MB. However most recent MB manuals no longer have a complete BIOS description, so they may be not helpful. At least with the ASRock or ASUS AM4 or AM5 MBs that I have used, whenever "ECC & Non-ECC, Unbuffered Memory" was specified, the MB really had ECC support.
- formerly_proven 3y agoSometimes the OS is unaware of ECC support on the hardware as well, e.g. Linux doesn't/didn't enable the Intel edac driver on i3's running on server chipsets using ECC memory, despite the CPU actually utilizing ECC in that scenario (they simply forgot to add them to the whitelist). So edac-util went "No ECC MCs found!", even though the platform worked.