3 ms·
Please tell me where this fairy tale comes from that either Apple or Google are excluding apps that compete with its own?
by scarface_74 3y ago
Please tell me where this fairy tale comes from that either Apple or Google are excluding apps that compete with its own?
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoApple, for iOS? You have to use their browser engine, you can't install anything like a JVM or the .NET runtime that competes with their APIs, you can't replace the Apple libraries that other apps use even if you were willing to implement the same interface, you have to use their App Store app to install other apps, you can't produce kernel drivers for third party hardware, pretty much all of the software they include with the device you're proscribed from replacing with a competing offering from someone else. Google uses different methods (e.g. until fairly recently third party app stores couldn't auto-update the apps they installed, now many apps require attestation that fails if you don't run Google's code), but somehow or other the vast majority of Android phones still end up with Google Play and Google services.
- scarface_74 3y agoAll that and you still haven’t shown where “you can’t install an app that competes with their own” Microsoft and Google both have cross platform frameworks for iOS and Android.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoBrowsers with their own browser engines and bytecode runtimes are apps. These are the exact things Microsoft got in trouble for in the 90s -- because they enable competition. A translation layer between a generic API and Apple's isn't the same thing. It can't add things Apple's doesn't already have. For example, how do you run CUDA or OpenCL code on Apple's devices? Can a cross-platform framework provide a payments implementation so your cross-platform app can use a cross-platform payments system for in-app purchases? No, because they make you use theirs and apps that compete with theirs aren't allowed. Visual Studio Code is clearly an app. Apple doesn't allow it on iOS. Apple makes a competing app -- for which they want you to buy a Mac. You can't just use a definition of "app" that means "whatever is in their app store" and then claim that whatever they don't allow in their app store isn't an app.
- scarface_74 3y agoA bytceode runtime is not an “application”. Apple never stopped VSCode from being on iOS. There are plenty of IDEs for the iPad built by third parties. No one would ever call a virtual machine an “application”. Are you making up things now? You don’t run CUDA on any non Nvidia hardware. But yes, you are free to port OpenCL to iOS if you want to. > Can a cross-platform framework provide a payments implementation so your cross-platform app can use a cross-platform payments system for in-app purchases A “payment API” is not an “application”. Yes the cross platform frameworks do expose the underlying API. And you can have a cross platform app that forces you to subscribe outside of the App Store - Spotify, Netflix, Microsoft, etc all do that. > No because they make you use theirs and apps that compete with theirs aren't allowed. Are you saying that their no competitors on iOS to AppleTV, Apple Music, Apple Podcasts, Apple Books, the iWork suite?
- smoldesu 3y ago> You don’t run CUDA on any non Nvidia hardware. CUDA drivers exist for pretty much every platform. They don't work without an Nvidia GPU, but in-theory nothing stops you from running CUDA code on iPhone besides Apple. > Are you saying that their no competitors on iOS None with the same competitive advantage as Apple. Whether that is fair or not seems to be up to individual markets.
- scarface_74 3y agoSo exactly how is Apple stopping you from implementing the entire CUDA API as a library to include within your application noting that no one has done it on non Nvidia hardware? So are you saying that - Apple Music is more popular on iOS than Spotify? - The iWork’s suite is more popular than MSOffice or GSuite? - AppleTV is more popular than Netflix? - Apple Books is more popular than Kindle?
- smoldesu 3y ago> So exactly how is Apple stopping you from implementing the entire CUDA API Well, neither the hardware or software supports PCI access, so... connectivity would be a start. It's about time iPhone supported Thunderbolt anyways. > So are you saying that {Apple Music is more popular on iOS than Spotify?, ...} I'm saying that Apple exerts a literal anticompetitive advantage by choosing their own margins (among many other things). Nothing about legislation like the Digital Market Act accuses Apple of monopoly. It designates them as a Gatekeeper (a position Apple chose) and holds them subject to additional guidelines. That is the cost of owning a userbase in Europe, now.