3 ms·
The "refused to discuss draft state" thing is remarkably common. I am unsure why so many governments do this. I suspect it's because a large number of bad ideas
by ggm 3y ago
The "refused to discuss draft state" thing is remarkably common. I am unsure why so many governments do this. I suspect it's because a large number of bad ideas get dropped before public draft, and nobody wants to wear the newspaper headlines which say "Government considering mandating second head for all voting citizens" when the 2 head idea is only going to get dropped before the document goes live.
There's also the problem of multi-draft convergence. They don't want to "out" a proposal being thought out in concert with another agency, or economy. In effect the document has to remain sealed until the most important one decides it's time to declare. So, across the life of the drafting there are huge reserved chunks. This happened in the TPP docs, which had sealed sections. They enraged local IT people in Australia because of the strong likelihood of the US trying to wedge the Australian 'right to repair' laws and their effect on DRM/IPR locks.
I have very briefly seen 'behind the curtain' of this kind of thing (a ministerial communique for a meeting) and people take the secrecy seriously, because you won't be invited back to draw up the next one, if you blab about this one. It doesn't have to reflect anything particularly special. I think it's likely the mystique is maintained for it's own sake: Vanity.
- qp11 3y agoThat's a response to the problem of things scaling to global levels faster than they can react to it.
- ggm 3y agoYes. If you see a lot of "move fast and break things" happening in a space which you may need to regulate, you throw everything into the bag, shake it around and see what sticks when you turn it out again. Every idea under the sun including internet licences, eyeball scanning, and second heads will be in the bag at some point. The Second head speaks french. Don't ask me which one they will keep...
- qp11 3y agoThey need to be taking stakes in the companies when things (exploitation/loss of control etc) start escalating ala British East India Company taken over by the Queen after shit hits the fan. Or atleast the threat should be hanging over everyones head. There is no other way to slow the self important tech buffoon class down. Their 3 inch chimp brains aren't growing at the same speed as the tech and consequences of tech are. We already see some of early stages of this, with internet shutdowns every time they lose control of Jurassic Park. Regulations and the law are a total waste of time.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoI for one am happy for only Zaphod Beeblebrox be allowed to vote.