4 ms·
Remember that executives are never fired for bad decisions, they are fired for bad press. The Unity business model & strategy changes/price hike were most defin
by paxys 3y ago
Remember that executives are never fired for bad decisions, they are fired for bad press. The Unity business model & strategy changes/price hike were most definitely approved by the board. The CEO's job was to make it digestible to the general public, and he failed at that. Don't expect the new one to pull a 180. He will simply hire better PR firms and do better sugar coating.
- alexpetralia 3y agoBut who proposed those changes? Ultimately the CEO is accountable.
- dboreham 3y agoThe board
- AlexandrB 3y agoI'm not an expert on corporate governance, but does a board of directors get into the nitty gritty of pricing models? I can totally believe they told the CEO to "bring in more revenue, or get replaced", but I have a hard time imagining they got too involved in the details how that would happen. Many board members sit on multiple boards or are CEOs of other companies. Do they really have time to do the kind of market research you'd need to propose such a change?
- hiatus 3y agoHaving been in board meetings where members went in on the nitty gritty of our _salesperson_ compensation structure, I would say yes.
- airstrike 3y agoPublic company boards?
- jojobas 3y agoThey'll sure scrutinize this or that, I'd be surprised if they _suggested_ a salesperson compensation structure.
- Groxx 3y agoNah, it'd fit. Everyone knows that sales is the only part of the company that actually makes money. Everything else is just a cost center that needs to be shrunk aggressively.
- airstrike 3y agoI'm an "expert" on corporate governance and I can say that no, boards do not get involved to the degree of making any market research -- they don't "initiate" initiatives such as a pricing model change (if you will pardon the redundancy). Public company CEOs (and their teams, really) come up with these plans. Boards do vet the executive's team business plan at the time of budgeting and during quarterly updates, but it's the CEO who is in charge of ideation and execution.
- otteromkram 3y agoBoard members aren't doing research, bud. Lol Research and information is compiled for them, which they then review. What're your thoughts on politicians who are in multiple subcommittees? Not smart enough?
- ezconnect 3y agoA majority holder on the board dictates how the company operates. It usually goes like give me a plan to get maximum revenue so I can collateral the company to get more debt to acquire other company or get me maximum profit so I can exit and invest on other company.
- mvdtnz 3y agoIt is not the role of the board to make executive decisions like this. That's what the 'E' in CEO means.
- anticensor 3y agoIn certain companies, everything above a certain size (money spent or count or items or staff affected) requires a board decision, by charter.
- airstrike 3y agoNegative, it's the CEO.
- paxys 3y agoUnity has been hemorrhaging money, and the shareholders want to see profits. The board and the CEO have no choice but to execute on their demands.
- drewcoo 3y ago> The CEO's job was to make it digestible to the general public, and he failed at that. No. It was to either do that or be the scapegoat and take the golden parachute. Either way it's wins all around. Now he can be blamed for the board's decisions. Meanwhile it remains to be seen how much anything will change. After all, the cause of the problem is gone now, right? /s
- majani 3y agoAnd it will fail again. Companies that target indie creators really don't fit into the VC model. Their customers will riot every time they try to maximize profits.
- kibwen 3y agoUnity, like every other shitty tech company these days, is just an ad company. Their customers are ad purchasers, not game devs.
- wongarsu 3y agoBut just like Google has to make sure you keep searching on google.com and keep watching youtube, Unity has to make sure people keep playing Unity games, which requires people to make Unity games. You can't sell ads when you don't have anywhere to put them.
- telchior 3y agoArguably, Unity could survive without the game engine -- they just need to survive the consolidation of the mobile ad business. Many companies already used Unity Ads without using Unity engine, even moreso after the acquisition / near merger with Ironsource. That acquisition was entirely about staying a step ahead of the consolidation wave, and nothing to do with the engine. Of course, while that idea may be arguable it's also absolutely idiotic. But I won't be at all surprised if Unity continues to steer in that direction, especially now that the Ironsource people comprise a large part of the company.
- golergka 3y agoUnity is mainly targeting mobile games studios, who are certainly not indie creators, but are pretty big companies themselves. I don't think that indie game developers who release games on steam make up a significant portion of their income.
- grotorea 3y agoBut what class of customer doesn't riot when they try to maximise profits?
- jojobas 3y agoWhat makes a bad decision then? Excellent press while customers still bailing out wouldn't make it a good decision would it?
- NotYourLawyer 3y ago> The Unity business model & strategy changes/price hike were most definitely approved by the board. I mean.. maybe? But it would be surprising.
- JimDabell 3y ago> Remember that executives are never fired for bad decisions, they are fired for bad press. Executives are fired for bad decisions all the time. You just don’t hear about it when there isn’t bad press.
- falcor84 3y ago{{citation needed}}
- JimDabell 3y agoNo, a citation is not needed. It’s entirely normal that poor performers are fired. What is utterly implausible is the idea that poor performers are never fired. That’s a weird fiction people like to repeat here that doesn’t stand up to the slightest amount of thought.
- activitypea 3y agoIf by "normal" you mean "reasonable", then you're right. If you mean "common", then try working at a large publicly-traded company for a few years. I agree that this stance doesn't stand up "to the slightest amount of thought", but yours doesn't measure up to the reality in the field. The reason people are saying something that makes no sense is probably because it's actually happening a lot.
- SSLy 3y agoI work in a world-famous publicly-traded company and previous top head was unceremoniously fired when their superiors realized we're years behind competition on a lifeline product.
- Draiken 3y agoThat's good! One example. But we need thousands more to be able to say this is common though. There's a reason the term "fail upwards" is so commonly used.
- m12k 3y agoWait until you hear who was until recently the chairman of the board.