3 ms·
> It just feels easier to traverse stairs as close to the inside as possible. I would expect that depends on the design of the spiral staircase. In a spiral s
by Someone 3y ago
> It just feels easier to traverse stairs as close to the inside as possible.
I would expect that depends on the design of the spiral staircase.
In a spiral staircase, you want to go up about 3 meters in a 360° turn because you need a bit over 2m of headroom and some space for the stair itself.
That means that, 1m away from the center of the staircase, the slope will be about 50%. The ideal staircase has more or less “step width + twice the step height = 63cm” [1], so that would give a good step width of 31cm and a step height of 16cm.
However, 2m away from the center, that same stair would have a slope of about 25%, and the ideal step would be 41cm wide and 11cm high or thereabouts.
3m from the center you’d have a 16% slope, and the ideal step would be 45 cm wide, 8cm high, etc.
Now, in ‘standard’ designs [2], step height can’t change with distance to the center, so the designer has to pick one, and thus has control over the distance from the center where it’s easiest to step.
[1] https://www.practicalarchitecture.com/blog/the-geometry-of-a-comfortable-staircase https://www.practicalarchitecture.com/blog/the-geometry-of-a.... Of course, that’s a heuristic, and the ideal will be different for different persons, but what’s important is that simply scaling up a staircase in order to get wider steps is not a good idea.
[2] very wide stairs can and sometimes do have steps that are sloping upwards. I don’t think these are non-standard, but can’t think of a better word now.
- Scarblac 3y agoI don't think spiral staircases generally get even 1m wide, it's not trivial for two people going in opposite directions to pass each other. You walk on the middle of the step as there isn't much room to the left or right to go to.
- Someone 3y ago> I don't think spiral staircases generally get even 1m wide, They can get wide. Try climbing the lower part of the dome of St. Peter’s basilica in Rome, for example (https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/view-of-a-young-man-and-woman-as-they-hold-hands-while-news-photo/1605673457 https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/news-photo/view-of-a-yo...) Also, in the context of “it just feels easier to traverse stairs as close to the inside as possible”, I think spiral staircases that are less than a meter wide aren’t relevant. On them, the only option is to walk in the middle of the stairs.