6 ms·
Disney's Loki faces backlash over reported use of generative AI
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jb1991 3y agoSquiggly lines and generative artifacts would match the story line of the season of "time slipping" however. If it is not AI, I can see a designer giving a Dali-like style for that reason.
- londons_explore 3y agoIt's true that in this case, the artifacts are pretty fitting to the show. But they are clearly diffusion-model artifacts.
- tetris11 3y agoYes, give a big studio the benefit of the doubt. They have great track records of not exploiting the industry, and are usually fair conscientious actors that provide unity and financial stability to all the artists and creatives they empower.
- shadowgovt 3y agoIf anything, in this case it appears that a contracted artist made an error. The bigwig studio executives don't composite their own ad posters.
- lolinder 3y agoThe article mentions it was copied from a Shutterstock photo, and if you go to the creator's page you can see they produced a series of Escheresque clocks, and this is the least obviously AI one [0]. The others have nonsense symbols, repeating numerals, and also just feel like AI images. [0] https://www.shutterstock.com/g/Svarun https://www.shutterstock.com/g/Svarun
- mcphage 3y agoI think it’s pretty clear there’s AI in it. But it also fits in perfectly with the show, so this usage is appropriate.
- CaptainFever 3y ago> A Loki season 2 poster has been linked to a stock image on Shutterstock that seemingly breaks the platform’s licensing rules regarding AI-generated content. A human-made poster uses a stock photo for the background, which is suspected to be AI. This is such a non-issue.
- kylebenzle 3y agoHollywood might well spend a decade fighting this AI straw-man, with increasingly kooky demands. How stupid of them :(
- soco 3y agoFrom the crowd earning a living with copying code from SO and tutorials, I wouldn't expect they see any issue with copied imagery. Let's chat again when AI does some proper coding.
- shadowgovt 3y agoIt really is a fundamental difference in goal, for it is the duty and objective of a dedicated software engineer to replace themselves.
- pizzaknife 3y agothis made my monday morning, thank you (i am a member of the society you describe however i too appreciate the irony you have pointed out).
- shadowgovt 3y agoThe end game for AI generation technology is almost certainly not that it will pit studios and IP owners versus artists so much as it will pit artists versus artists. The copyright issues become moot once several companies pay a lifetimes fortune to a thousand or so artists for exclusive and complete rights to their collections to seed their algorithms. And I can't believe for a second that professional solidarity is going to extend to every talented visual creative on the planet.
- artninja1988 3y agoUnbelievable! Cancel the artist on Twitter! Shame them! Crucify!
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoThis is ironic. If you had to pick a patron god of generative AI, it would definitely be Loki.
- shadowgovt 3y agoThat was actually the plot of an old X-Men comic. Loki came to earth and started granting wishes. Basically turning regular people into Forge-style creative mutants. One was a master architect who gained the power to realize anything he dreamed of. But the X-Men later realize the gift is tainted; it's powered by human creativity. The architect discovers that while he can fabricate any structure he ever imagined, he can't imagine any new ones. Confronted with accusations of treachery, Loki is chagrined. He more or less thought he was bringing something to humans they actually wanted, and is infuriated when they reject his gift. He fundamentally cannot understand what it is that people desire.
- jncfhnb 3y agoSeems… a little silly. I might be willing to trade my ability to generate new creative ideas for the ability to execute on all the creative ideas i have but cannot possibly implement due to time, resources, and talent constraints. Not being able to think creatively sounds scary but there’s also the alternative which is dying without doing things. Like, you could potentially make it a worse trade that sounds less scary by just making it trade years off your lifespan in exchange for creative execution and I think that’s not crazy. It’s actually fairly banal considering all the things we do to survive today.
- shadowgovt 3y agoThat's just what Loki thought! Humans... So impossible to please.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoIf I had this, I would be a billionaire. I don't need to come up with any new ideas. I would just hang out on Hackernews listening to ideas that I would then execute on. We also have all the ideas we need to fix climate change, and world hunger, we just need execution. I would gladly take the trade of executing on existing ideas, versus coming up with new ideas that we cannot execute on.
- londons_explore 3y agoSomeone in the art team is getting a stern talking to right about now...
- MrPatan 3y agoWhat's wrong with using generative AI?
- benterix 3y agoAfter a brief period of fascination, it's become a synonym of low quality and low effort. See e.g. the relevant KitKat campaign: https://www.creativebloq.com/news/kit-kat-ai-ad https://www.creativebloq.com/news/kit-kat-ai-ad
- MrPatan 3y agoWhat's the problem with low quality and low effort? Let the market decide if they like it or not.
- ghusto 3y agoThe problem is that there's the presumption that "the market"'s choice is what we want. "The market" has decided on what gets pushed to the top of your social media feed, and that is by all accounts turned out to be terrible for humanity. Idiocracy is what happens when we tailor to the lowest common denominator. "The market" will decide on the cheapest and easiest, not what's in your best interest.
- MrPatan 3y agoThe actual market's choice is hard to fake. It's people voting with their dollars. Don't like it, don't watch it. Don't care, watch it. Disney are not the market, and neither are they "the market". They are indeed betting on lots of people not caring about AI one way or another, so that they can save some money. Good for them.
- ghusto 3y ago> The actual market's choice is hard to fake. It's people voting with their dollars I'm not saying it's being faked, I'm saying it's wrong to allow it when it goes against the best interest of the many, or worse, us as humanity as a whole. People vote with their dollars by buying cheap crap to eat every day, and manufacturers save a ton of money pumping that crap out instead of nutritious food. That doesn't mean it's good or should be encouraged, or even tolerated. The market is not god.
- throwaway743 3y ago[flagged]
- andrew_eu 3y agoIt's surprising that the article doesn't mention the ongoing strikes in Hollywood [1], driven largely by concerns about the use of generative AI in film production. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_Hollywood_labor_disputes https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_Hollywood_labor_dispute...
- nerdjon 3y agoif you checked the link you posted it even says the strike is over. So not sure why it needs a mention in the article. Edit: I stand corrected, not all of the strikes are over. However it does seem like coverage of it basically ended once the writers strike ended. I had no idea it was still going on. I don't even see it on Instagram anymore.
- zzzeek 3y agofor some insight on how AI generated images can quickly ruin everything, go onto Threads and "like" one or two AI-generated landscapes; your feed will instantly turn into and endless stream of hyper-colorful, mind-bending AI-generated landscapes, each one more dramatically trippy than the last one, and within 5 minutes your brain just shuts off to the whole thing, images that if you saw an artist make just one would be amazing now looks like meaningless trash. It's like playing Minecraft with full mods turned on that find you all the diamonds to mine automatically, or like drinking 4 liters of Coke and trying to enjoy a high quality pastry afterwards.
- jncfhnb 3y agoSounds like a problem with Threads, not AI
- zzzeek 3y agodid you miss the part where Threads' feed algorithm is also "AI" as much as any other machine learning model is ? Human appreciation of art is linked to human creation of art and I think AI is going to show us that truth in new ways.
- jncfhnb 3y agoAs a data scientist, no, I think that’s a dumb take. Without bothering to debate the definition of “AI”, One is a synthesis of general knowledge that can be used to generate new ideas. The other is a multi arm bandit and some collaborative filtering. Maybe there’s some AI there to classify what things are to begin with, but the decision of what to show is a very different kind of thing.
- zzzeek 3y agoI don't want to use the term "dumb" for your take since I don't really address people that way but it does not matter if threads shows me ten AI landscapes or 100, the point is that once images displaying what would take a human dozens of hours of technical skill to produce are easily churned out by the thousands each hour, the entire value of such art for human enjoyment drops to zero as it's no longer special or interesting.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nerdjon 3y agoSo I do have strong ethical problems with AI usage especially when talking about how a model was trained and properly paying people. However I think Loki brings up an interesting question. Wether or not "AI" art could become its own style? Like to me the Loki series would benefit from those inconsistencies, weirdness, etc that comes from an AI generating art. Not that a Human can't do it, but the results would likely be different. Not really defending its usage here, just an interesting thought I had about this in this particular use case. It happens to fit the theming very well.
- simonw 3y agoThat was the argument that was used for Secret Invasion, which used AI generated imagery for the animated title sequence.
- tobr 3y agoTo my eyes the stock image is unlikely to be 100% generative AI. It appears to be an Escheresque spiral projection of an AI generated image. The AI artifacts are exactly identical between each layer of the spiral, only scaled down, which would be hard to explain in any other way.
- makomk 3y agoIt also counts from 1 to 12 correctly with the numerals following the curve, which seems... quite impressive for generative AI.
- tiahura 3y agoI hope they do use AI. I do, and I know it has improved both the quantity and quality of my output at work.
- GaggiX 3y ago"AI image checkers" are complete garbage, I had a lot of fun with them, but they shouldn't be used for anything other than entertainment.
- lostlastacc 3y agoLooks terrible like most uses of AI art does. Just embarrassing
- GaggiX 3y agoAs VFX it is only noticeable when it is done badly.
- lostlastacc 3y agoI can flesh out my snarky comment. Just embarrassing that Disney cuts costs for creating a poster instead of just contracting any talented artist that would like to work for them or any artist that currently does. But it doesnt matter.
- GaggiX 3y agoThey just use a stock image as background and probably don't even notice it was AI.
- lostlastacc 3y agoAgreed, Its not neccessarly about AI. Loads of AI assisted artwork / effects are great. But using AI instead of hiring an artist almost always look like crap.