4 ms·
Looks to be a extensive update with lots of new and useful features, thanks as always PaulDavisThe1st :) Especially Arrangement and Quick Groups will be good ti
by diggan 3y ago
Looks to be a extensive update with lots of new and useful features, thanks as always PaulDavisThe1st :) Especially Arrangement and Quick Groups will be good time savers for me!
> For several years, people downloading Ardour for macOS have had to deal with various kinds of messages (from Apple) saying things like "This program comes from an untrusted source" to "The file is damaged". As of Ardour 8, macOS users downloading Ardour won't see this stuff any more, because we have given up and paid $100 to join Apple's pay-to-play scheme. Our builds are all notarized now, and so people on macOS should have the same smooth experience they get from other macOS software downloads.
Hope macOS users live up to the commonly referenced "Apple users are more likely to pay for software" and donate either time or money to Ardour if they use it, as it seems making applications available to them cost developers actual money now.
- auggierose 3y agoI don't think macOS users have any more or less responsibility paying for this software than Linux users. $100 compared to the development resources that went into this is nothing, and the developers realised that, too.
- sschueller 3y ago100 USD a year (more in Switzerland because Apple doesn't even pay for the taxes) is not nothing. Why should I pay to place apps that I spend my free time to develop and offer for free? Apple should at least not charge a recurring fee if all apps posted are open source and free. At least over at Google it is a one time fee.
- auggierose 3y agoI'd also prefer if there was no $100 to pay. But it is a fair price, and I find the attitude of programmers that everything should be free quite damaging. If you want to donate your free time, that's really up to you. Don't construe constraints for other people or companies from that.
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoI don't want it to be free. I want Apple to not lie that "This application is damaged" when I don't pay them.
- auggierose 3y agoI don't recall the exact message, but I don't think they say it is damaged. They will probably say something like it may be damaged. Which is perfectly true, as they have no means of verifying its integrity.
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agohttps://ardour.org/images/thanksapple.png https://ardour.org/images/thanksapple.png
- auggierose 3y agoOk, that's bad. I fully agree.
- smoldesu 3y ago> I find the attitude of programmers that everything should be free quite damaging. Many dead UNIX vendors agree.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoIt's more a matter of principle ? IMHO it should be illegal (for a for-profit corporation) to own both the OS and an application store (at least the kind featuring third-party software) - you cannot expect them to be a fair judge of who gets in there and who doesn't !
- tomduncalf 3y agoYou can still run the software, but Apple make it harder to do so (you probably have to Google how to do it). You could argue this both ways, I think there's value to the defaults making it harder for your average user to run software which could be unsafe... just think how bad the malware problem used to be on Windows for example.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoThe malware problem used to be bad on Windows because everything had admin access. And the later "we don't have this program in our database, do you still want to execute it?" dialog wasn't too bad (especially when paired with an integrated blacklist of known malware !). And why do you assume that other software distributors than OS makers aren't going to do due diligence ?
- schmorptron 3y agoNah, I think it's perfectly fair to charge more for a mac version of a program, especially if it's a donation funded open-source one. If you can afford a macintosh, you're more likely to also be able to afford a couple of bucks to support it.
- redserk 3y agoI'd be willing to bet the demographics of those on Hackernews aren't exactly in the "I'm using Linux because I cannot afford to use any other OS" crowd. It is the other way around. Linux users should be more vigilant about donating to the projects they find important if they care for the longevity of the project continuing as desktop Linux is a very tiny market to support and has heavy fragmentation issues within it.
- jacquesm 3y agoSeconded. I can afford any OS but I'm using Linux out of principle. It's also - at least for me - the most seamless developer experience out there because I'm running the same OS on servers and my desktop. Whenever I have to work with Windows or a Mac I feel like a fish out of the water.
- smoldesu 3y ago> as desktop Linux is a very tiny market to support and has heavy fragmentation issues within it. It's also free to use and distribute software on, regardless of the hardware/software you own. That's the big difference. Plus, MacOS also commands a relatively small market share with it's own fragmentation issues (doubly so if you're cross-platform). If Mac users want perpetual builds of their software, they have to perpetually fund a development environment. Linux doesn't really work the same way.
- auggierose 3y agoYes, of course it is fair. You can charge whatever you want for your program. But Ardour is free. Accepting donations is not the same as charging for something.
- master-lincoln 3y agoYou also need to afford a Mac machine for testing as a dev. That's another few hundred bucks on top. I don't think macOS users have a bigger responsibility for paying, but as a publisher I would always make a paid macOS version just to try to regain those expenses again. Time is not equal to money for many people
- diggan 3y ago> I don't think macOS users have any more or less responsibility paying for this software than Linux users I don't think that either, it's only a hope from my side. A hope that they recognize that the binary they are using cost someone money to generate only because of restrictions put forward by Apple.
- OliverM 3y agoI thought Ardour was a commercial product? If you want to download a binary from their site it's either a demo version with injected silence every 10 minutes, or a paid-for option (either a small monthly sub or a larger one-off payment). You can build it locally yourself for free of course, but I don't know if many non-devs would do that.
- ninjin 3y agoIt is not really a commercial product, rather it follows an old, but somewhat rare, tradition of making usage slightly more difficult in order to raise funds. OpenBSD used to do the same and not provide pre-built images to raise funds via CD sales from those that could not be bothered to learn how to build images from the source code. You can certainly object to this, but I do find it reasonable as there are few good ways to fund open source software. As for Ardour itself, it is clearly completely open source [1]. https://git.ardour.org/ardour/ardour/src/branch/master/COPYING https://git.ardour.org/ardour/ardour/src/branch/master/COPYI...
- globular-toast 3y agoYou're talking about orthogonal concepts. Ardour is free software (and therefore open source). Ardour is not proprietary software. Ardour is a commercial product. They sell pre-built binaries, updates (perhaps some level of guarantee/support for those binaries?) etc. Ardour is not "freeware", shareware or a hobby project or anything else like that.
- ninjin 3y agoI am not sure it is clear cut as you present it. Clearly Ardour the project is not a commercial product and the same should go for the source code. Arguably the pre-compiled binaries are a commercial product as they are presented to a market for a price (although the same of course does not hold for Ardour binaries provided through package managers and elsewhere). To me, the confusion mostly arises from the fact that we use Ardour to refer to all of the above, while clearly they are all different things.
- ilyt 3y ago> Hope macOS users live up to the commonly referenced "Apple users are more likely to pay for software" and donate either time or money to Ardour if they use it, as it seems making applications available to them cost developers actual money now. Just make it $5 on macos. If Mac users can support this shitty company they can actually pay for other software too.
- dist-epoch 3y agoThey didn't do that for the Windows version though: > Because we object to paying Microsoft for the privilege of allowing you to more easily use our work, this application is unsigned (more information here).
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoWe will likely start doing Windows notarization during the 8.x series. Our friends at Harrison, who make Mixbus (based on Ardour) already figured it all out a long time ago; it's a bit more complex than the macOS version of the process.
- electroly 3y agoThe message is a little confused--Microsoft never charged for code signing. You don't pay Microsoft. You have to get a code signing certificate from a third party CA; you choose your favorite. Microsoft themselves doesn't offer them. This is different than notarization. Notarization is a process by which Apple centrally scans your binary and decides if it's ok, then stamps their approval on the binary if so. Code signing is a process by which you sign your own binary so that users (and, more importantly, Windows) know it's from you. Microsoft doesn't do notarization, instead relying on the reputation of the certificate and their client-side malware scanner. The reputation from one executable you sign with the certificate carries over to other executables that you sign with the same certificate (e.g. newer versions of the same app). This impacts SmartScreen prompts. If you get an EV certificate you get the initial reputation for free and can skip SmartScreen prompts out of the gate. source: have done it; my open source Windows app is signed with my Sectigo certificate
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]