4 ms·
That's the fate of all large cities: infrastructure gets more and more complicated, and bureaucracy always keeps growing. The way to fix it is to stop building
by cyberax 3y ago
That's the fate of all large cities: infrastructure gets more and more complicated, and bureaucracy always keeps growing.
The way to fix it is to stop building large dense cities. We need tax incentives for companies to create jobs in sparsely-populated regions and for remote jobs. Also probably something like cap-and-trade for dense office space.
This way, eventually we won't need Downtowns with super-concentrated offices.
- afavour 3y agoNope. NYC’s problems are specific to the city. Take a look at the transit Paris has built in the last decade or so. It’s been built faster and far more cheaply than any MTA project. Cities also appeal to people for reasons other than dense employment opportunities. Small towns are hardly free of bureaucracy. So on and so forth.
- marmaduke 3y agoIn another article about high speed rail, someone pointed out there's a big difference in France: once the govt votes the build, it becomes law and can't be preempted whereas the US, any entity can pause infra projects with a suitable complaint. Perhaps something similar applies to this comparison. Edit: prolly this too https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37813487 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37813487 does not apply to Paris
- _3u10 3y agoNah it’s North American thing lots of stuff gets built in South America reasonably efficiently, and certainly much more quickly. Look at how much the Rio subway has expanded recently despite being about the same size as NY
- crazygringo 3y agoWhat are you talking about? The Rio subway has barely expanded at all -- and where it has it has been neither quick nor efficient.
- School-Cotton 3y ago> That's the fate of all large cities: infrastructure gets more and more complicated, and bureaucracy always keeps growing. This is simply not backed up by reality; the article cites examples of European major cities without this problem. And do you really think Tokyo, Seoul or Shanghai have trouble building the transit they need? The issue is that American institutions specifically are not fit for purpose, not an issue with large cities in general.
- kiba 3y agoIt does costs more to build in highly urban areas, but American problems are well...American.
- ramblenode 3y agoHumans have been aggregating into cities for thousands of years because they are more economical than living sparsely. With sparsely populated areas you also have logistics problems but no economy of scale. Every stand-alone dwelling adds new infrastructure requirements to the road/power/water/fuel system and increases maintenance costs. Cities tend to be net tax payers while suburban and rural areas tend to be net tax beneficiaries, subsidized by the taxes from cities. Both types of places are important, but rural and suburban are already heavily tax-advantaged.