2 ms·
> You have to recognize that each of those lines is creating a magnetic field, the closer you stack them, the more likely cross talk is. PC desktops have 2 mem
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> You have to recognize that each of those lines is creating a magnetic field, the closer you stack them, the more likely cross talk is.
PC desktops have 2 memory channels. EPYC servers have 12 channels per socket. It's not the physics, it's that ~8-core processors generally aren't bounded by memory bandwidth and it's not worth the cost of increasing the number of pins.
The server sockets do it because they have 128-core processors.
If this changes what we may start seeing is CPUs (or iGPUs) with a few GB of HBM as L4 cache.
- simcop2387 3y agoIntel is doing this today in the Xeon MAX line, up to 64gb of hbm ram, you don't even necessarily need ddr5 on them. serve the home has a good article about them but it's all very new so it's hard to say how it'll shake out.
- dathinab 3y ago> not the physics no physics matter because it makes it much harder and in turn more costly to the more channels you have to have high quality reliable connections server RAM is for example also slower to compensate this e.g. recent EPYC processors run at up to 4800MT/s but a Ryzen 9 runs at up to 5200MT/s (without overclocking, with running at 6000MT/s isn't that uncommon) server also tend to always use EEC memory so it's a benefit/cost balance calculation
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> server RAM is for example also slower to compensate this e.g. recent EPYC processors run at up to 4800MT/s but a Ryzen 9 runs at up to 5200MT/s (without overclocking, with running at 6000MT/s isn't that uncommon) Zen3 EPYC has 8 channels per socket and uses the same 3200MT/s DDR4 as Zen3 desktops, so this little explains why desktops couldn't have e.g. 4 channels if there was a need for it. They already commonly have 4 DIMM slots. The rated speed for DDR5 is 8% higher for desktops, but the additional channels don't seem to be why. Intel uses 8 channels of DDR5 rather than 12 and it's still 4800MT/s. > so it's a benefit/cost balance calculation But that was my point?