3 ms·
Server sockets have more memory channels and server motherboards usally have more memory slots. Layout limitations probably make ram on four sides not very feas
by toast0 3y ago
Server sockets have more memory channels and server motherboards usally have more memory slots. Layout limitations probably make ram on four sides not very feasible.
But, more memory channels means more pins and larger sockets, and that adds cost and layout issues for motherboards. HBM ram that attaches on top of the cpu addresses the layout issue (and the bandwidth issue), but interferes with heat removal and removes expandability. Apple makes it work, but they limit clock speeds and were never big on expandability. Intel and AMD have a hard time in the market when their top consumer chips don't clock to the moon, even if the last 10% of clock speed takes 50% of the power and delivers 5% of performance (percentages made up). Server chips don't need to clock so high, so AMD can release clock limited compact cores that have about the same IPC in a bit more than half the area, and the difference in clocks for a max-cores regular zen4 and a max-cores zen4c isn't too much (L3/core is half for zen4c though, so may not be a benefit depending on your working set)
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> but interferes with heat removal and removes expandability Eh. RAM generally consumes a single digit number of watts and will do so regardless of where it's physically located in the system. If you put HBM on the CPU socket then you have to replace them together, but you can still replace them. It could also make sense to do both: If you have 16GB of HBM and 16GB of DDR5, you have 32GB of RAM and half of it is faster. Or 80GB of RAM and 16GB of it is faster. Cache hierarchies are a good way to strike a balance between performance and cost, and then the latter can still be expanded independent of the CPU.
- ta988 3y agoRoughly 3W per 8GB in DDR4. DDR5 is said to use less.