3 ms·
I think this (experiential vs bland) and parent (urban vs rural) are huge components of the AirBnB experience. Generally speaking, most people prefer bed and b
by ethbr1 3y ago
I think this (experiential vs bland) and parent (urban vs rural) are huge components of the AirBnB experience.
Generally speaking, most people prefer bed and breakfast experiences at their best:
- Interesting home
- Home furnishings / kitchen
- Optional home cooked meals
- Local recommendations
- In a residential community
However, there are only so many of those. Especially in urban areas, where an efficient supply of hotels already existed.
Far fewer actual bed and breakfasts than AirBnB needs, once it went public.
Consequently, it pulled an eBay/Amazon/Etsy and lowered its standards to increase volume to drive revenue.
And in doing so, diluted and devalued their own product, because the worst experiences are synonymous with the best.
What AirBnB should have done was recognize that they want to provide fundamentally different things:
{Boutique bed and breakfast experiences} that meet strict standards but have lower volume (especially in urban areas)
{Bland housing} that meets minimum standards but has higher volume
Not doing so was an egregious marketing and product design failure on their part.
- ghaff 3y agoYeah. I've certainly stayed at B&B's/small inns--especially outside of cities on vacation--and have generally appreciated the experience. Some were listed on AirBnB although that's not how I booked them 99% of the time. Not sure that "good"/vetted B&Bs is a VC-scale business model. I do book trips through agencies that arrange housing at places they've had experience with (doing so at the moment) but that's basically a specialized travel agency-level scale model--not a VC one.
- ethbr1 3y agoAgreed. And therein lays the bait-and-switch that AirBnB was forced to pull -- we'll market the best of our properties, but the average experience will be far worse. That's not a winning brand formula. Chain hotels, love them or hate them, are more honest about exactly what you're going to get.
- ghaff 3y ago>Chain hotels, love them or hate them, are more honest about exactly what you're going to get. Yep. I'm almost certainly not going to single out my whatever Marriott brand chain hotel as one of the highlights of my trip. And, maybe I had a decent view out my window and maybe I didn't. But I pretty much knew what I was getting. There were almost certainly no issues with checking in if my flight was delayed. And I could leave my luggage at the desk if I wanted to walk around before departing the city. But it's a case where "meets expectations" is what I'm looking for. I get that others, especially traveling with friends or family, have different needs than hotels are generally setup to cater to and that's fine. And if someone with local knowledge can book me a place with more character that's generally good too. But I admit that neither I nor my parents when I was growing up ever felt a need to cook meals where I was staying.
- ethbr1 3y agoIt finally clicked for me when my father pointed out that most hotels weren't in the business of providing luxury, but rather consistency. In the same way that McDonald's is. One newer Marriott brand that always flummoxed me was Moxy. Until I stayed in a few in Europe and realized "Oh, this is a Marriott hostel." Which we don't have the underlying reference for in the US.
- ghaff 3y agoI'm not sure I'd describe Moxy, which I generally like and have stayed in both in Europe and the US, that way although I see some commonalities. It overlaps a lot with Marriott's Aloft--which I think was originally a Sheraton brand--(and to a lesser degree Yotel which downsizes rooms to a greater degree). A certain self-conscious hipness, comfortable but somewhat minimalist rooms, and generally welcoming non-stuffy public spaces without restaurants, fitness centers, and other hotel features that I rarely use in an urban hotel. Agree with respect to consistency although McDonald's tends to be below my baseline if I have any choice in the matter whereas most of the big business hotel chains are pretty much fine for my needs. Most of the time I wouldn't take advantage of what more luxe properties had to offer nor would I use a kitchen (aside from maybe a refrigerator).