3 ms·
First thought: "There's a sucker born every minute" Second thought: "Nobody ever went broke [by] underestimating the intelligence of the American people" Da
by bell-cot 3y ago
First thought: "There's a sucker born every minute"
Second thought: "Nobody ever went broke [by] underestimating the intelligence of the American people"
Daydream: When the feds actually catch a scammer, they shift through the guy's records to see who his victims were. For the best-born and best-off ~1% of those, they publicly ask a judge declare the victim non compos mentis, and appoint a trustee to manage their affairs. For the next ~10%, they ask the family to try to convince the victim to move to a care facility and appoint a trustee. Goal: Fear of devastating loss of social status might motivate at least the most-profitable scam victims to be somewhat more difficult to cheat.
- LinuxBender 3y agojudge declare the victim non compos mentis FWIW I've been trying to bring back nincompoop into the vernacular. It just doesn't catch on. I like your ideas though. There have been so many extortion scams they are making an action movie about them. [1] [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SzINZZ6iqxY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SzINZZ6iqxY [video][3 mins]
- stouset 3y agoI don’t know that the outcome of that would be what you hope, but at the very least it would help prevent those same people from being victims again.
- yieldcrv 3y agoThey’re not going to move Gen Z to a care facility, read the article theyre falling for most of these scams, not the elderly. Maybe per capita would show something different, based on population in each demographic, but incident wise its the suckers actually recently born
- nullc 3y agoI think the figures look worse for the elderly when you look at total value taken, but a significant part of that is just "Because that's where the money is."
- circuit10 3y agoThis is ridiculous victim blaming. Anyone can fall for a scam in the wrong moment with the wrong luck, this mentality of thinking you’re too intelligent to be scammed is how people get scammed
- BenjiWiebe 3y agoI hear this sentiment over and over. However, of my acquaintances, some are prone to falling for scams over and over, and others never have fallen for any. I can confidently say I'm less likely to fall for a scam then the average American. I guess I'd say I'm a naturally suspicious person.
- rileymat2 3y agoSo a real life example, I was trying to sublet an apartment in an area near a university. I put the apartment on Craigslist. I got a response with interest, then after a couple of emails... This person claimed to be an international student with a stipend. He would give me his stipend check from the university and then I would send back the rest, I could wait until it cleared in my account to send it. This is a textbook nigerian check scam, but if I did not know about it or was more desperate to sublet, I absolutely would have fallen for it. The suspicious person that is not aware, assumes when it clears it has cleared, but they are ignorant, this is not the case.
- VancouverMan 3y agoPretty much every sentence describing that situation involves what should be pretty obvious risk or blatant red flags. Renting anything to others involves obvious risk. Subletting apartments involves obvious risk. Financial dealings with university students involves obvious risk. Classified ads involve obvious risk. Financial dealings with foreigners involves obvious risk. Accepting payment by check involves obvious risk. Back-and-forth payment shenanigans involve obvious risk. Dealing with financial institutions involves obvious risk. All parties involved with such an obviously risk-filled situation should inherently know to be on high alert at all times, no matter how desperate they might be. The involvement of desperation itself should raise even more red flags. It's hard to feel sympathy for somebody who has somehow managed to overlook one obvious risk after another in such a situation.
- nullc 3y agoThe way you'll fall for a scam like this is by thinking you couldn't fall for one. To be safe you have to always reject the scammer. To be successful the scammer has to only trick you once. When you're drunk, half awake, your gold fish just died... when the scammer got lucky and had a routine that sounded a lot like a legitimate call you were expecting? Some of the victims fall for scams because their faculties are failing, but I bet that isn't the case for most (a large portion aren't even elderly)-- and it's certainly not the case for all. A very large portion are romance scams that particularly target younger men. Accepting that anyone can be scammed including yourself is the very first step to protecting yourself from scammers!
- antifa 3y ago> The way you'll fall for a scam like this is by thinking you couldn't fall for one. It sounds possible, and I don't believe in that declaring 1% of victims non-victims thing, just sounds like cartoonish reverse hunger games non-sense. But there are a lot of scams that I (and let's presume a lot of HN) categorically can't fall for. Random account on whatever social media account DMs me with studio quality model photos and a flirtatious opening? What's the first thought that goes through your head? Is it "oh geeze another spam bot" or is it "finally! the perfect hot swappable replacement spouse I'm entitled to has contacted me directly out of nowhere!"? Maybe it's also only because I already know about the check cashing/delayed not clearing scam, but who TF is accepting checks and sending them back out to randos they've never met online? When these people are losing $5,000, that was their last $5,000, too! I'm not totally sure what categories of scams I am personally vulnerable to, maybe I'll have paid $100 for a $10 drop-shipped low quality garbage a few times a year. I consider funkpops a scam and I haven't fallen for them. But some of these other scams require some kind of narcissist "finally what life owes to me is promised by this emoji filled DM from someone I've never heard of before or met IRL!" or other possible, but eventual, mental decline that will likely come with age. There's not a 20th Nigerian Prince who's going to eventually get lucky on me. It's the other way arround. One prince's 20th email will get lucky on a random sucker.
- nullc 3y agoSure, it won't be a nigerian price that gets you-- knowing about the scheme is perfect protection for almost everyone. It'll be the nigerian call center's 208th scheme that involves absolutely no princes that gets you, one you've not heard of yet, one that you're in the audience for. I think the clearing scams are actually a really good generic one that absent knowing about them most people with something valuable to sell could fall for. If you really thought a check was absolutely irreversible then someone paid you, but then had to back out and said you could keep 10% of your trouble why wouldn't you return the payment? What are you going to do instead? steal the money and leave yourself exposed to a successful civil lawsuit and public reputation smearing? As far as the romance scams, many aren't that obvious. They start off with simply a missent SMS, then count on you says "sorry wrong number" then they slowly chat you up. If you're lonely you might engage. Most don't send super hot photos, or at least not right off the bat. And it's "real" in the sense that you're talking to a real person. The span of these is often months long -- and I suspect that HN user (esp in highly gender lopsided bay area communities) are probably prime targets for the more sophisticated of these. I've often seen scams on ebay that I expect could hit people on HN, exotic tech equipment at unreasonable prices, where they try to talk you into some off platform irreversible payment. Of course, a sufficiently advanced scam is indistinguishable from just a sus deal so it's hard to give examples. Here's a recent sus deal that I've had my eye on: https://www.ebay.com/itm/256208014829 https://www.ebay.com/itm/256208014829 (no one should blame me if you buy it and it turns out to be bullshit!): super cheap refurb gpus with oversized memory for running language models and big diffusion models. Would make for an easy scam. Buy a bunch of dead gpus from cryptominer farms. delay for as long as possible, ship a dead gpu, vanish. Because it's an odd duck (a configuration that never existed) it doesn't exist as part of the liquid market, so it can be suspiciously cheap without being too good to be true. But if it is a scam its one with a really niche market. > require some kind of narcissist I think that each one of us contains almost the full spectrum of human experience to some degree, in some contexts, and at some times. At the right moment with the right setup, pretty much anyone could feel they're finally getting a break, finally getting the recognition they deserve. As I said upthread-- to lose to a scammer you just need to screw up once. Even if a scam requires you to have a character flaw it doesn't require that you consistently have that flaw, only that you exhibit it for the scammer just once. You might think, okay well what about someone so humble that they could never fall for a scam that required a narcissistic perspective? There are scams for those too, usually where the scammer accidentally "overpays you" and then relies on your kindness and pro-social behavior to quietly return the funds before the scammer loses his job.