3 ms·
I agree with a lot of what Charlie says here, but on the other hand some of the privacy criticisms he makes about the app and Facebook are equally valid critici
by Symmetry 15y ago
I agree with a lot of what Charlie says here, but on the other hand some of the privacy criticisms he makes about the app and Facebook are equally valid criticisms of walking outside in public: if you can tell what race I am by looking at my picture on Facebook you can also tell what race I am by looking at my face when you see me in person. I feel like that sort of throwing out arguments without considering them detracts from having a meaningful debate about real dangers to privacy that social media can pose.
- vasco 15y agoYou can not however, make a database of all the people of a given race that currently live on a X mile radius of some given place by looking at them in person without a lot of time or trouble.
- cstross 15y agoThere are two key differences between walking outside in public and disclosure on Facebook: a) In public, observation is reciprocal (that is, you can see who is watching you) -- less universal in these days of CCTV, but traditionally this has generally been the case, and b) Public observation is real time and line of sight; FB "observation" may take place days, months or years later by persons you have never had an opportunity to see. The long term consequences arising from these new constraints are not yet obvious.
- tensafefrogs 15y agoTotally agree. While there are obviously some differences, I think blaming technology (i.e. Facebook) for horrible things that humans do is just silly. The problem is not that Facebook is making it easier for people to do bad things, the problem is that people do bad things. The technology is here to stay. Information will be shared more easily in the coming years and it will only get easier to categorize people in the future based on their behaviors. So maybe instead of complaining about "bad companies" taking advantage of this, we should be encouraging people to be more accepting of differences. The problem isn't that a girl checked into a local bar. The problem is that someone wants to stalk/rape her. Scaring people into not checking in to somewhere (or not doing so publicly) is getting dangerously close to saying "well, she shouldn't have worn that short skirt if she didn't want to get hassled", which is a terribly flawed argument and ignores the actual problem. There's an entire side of this that is overlooked whenever this debate pops up: All the freaks and geeks who thought they were alone because they were into different things can now find like minded people and know that don't have to feel alone. Look at the "it gets better" campaign. It's beautiful and has likely helped thousands of people. We should focus on the good stuff a little more often rather than focus on the potential bad stuff.