9 ms·
Charlie Stross on Girls Around Me
- bigiain 15y agoKey quote: "Unfortunately you don't need a special purpose tool like "Girls Around Me" to do this, if you have a reasonably powerful Facebook query tool and know how to use it. I can't stress this strongly enough: the problem was not invented by SMS Services O.o.o. of Russia, who wrote the app. And banning the app will not make the problem go away."
- itsmequinn 15y agoThis is exactly what I was saying last night. There is much MORE information available than this app accesses. This is just one of the first times someone had put a particularly creepy wrapper on it.
- flomo 15y agoIndeed. One can imagine an entirely different reaction if the app was called something like "Popular People Around Me" and had come out of the US startup community rather than Russia.
- nevinera 15y agoI initially thought that the app was an amusing attempt to point out how creepy fb and 4sq are.
- J3L2404 15y agoEFF should build a MaxCreepOut app just to highlight the situation.
- Symmetry 15y agoI agree with a lot of what Charlie says here, but on the other hand some of the privacy criticisms he makes about the app and Facebook are equally valid criticisms of walking outside in public: if you can tell what race I am by looking at my picture on Facebook you can also tell what race I am by looking at my face when you see me in person. I feel like that sort of throwing out arguments without considering them detracts from having a meaningful debate about real dangers to privacy that social media can pose.
- vasco 15y agoYou can not however, make a database of all the people of a given race that currently live on a X mile radius of some given place by looking at them in person without a lot of time or trouble.
- cstross 15y agoThere are two key differences between walking outside in public and disclosure on Facebook: a) In public, observation is reciprocal (that is, you can see who is watching you) -- less universal in these days of CCTV, but traditionally this has generally been the case, and b) Public observation is real time and line of sight; FB "observation" may take place days, months or years later by persons you have never had an opportunity to see. The long term consequences arising from these new constraints are not yet obvious.
- tensafefrogs 15y agoTotally agree. While there are obviously some differences, I think blaming technology (i.e. Facebook) for horrible things that humans do is just silly. The problem is not that Facebook is making it easier for people to do bad things, the problem is that people do bad things. The technology is here to stay. Information will be shared more easily in the coming years and it will only get easier to categorize people in the future based on their behaviors. So maybe instead of complaining about "bad companies" taking advantage of this, we should be encouraging people to be more accepting of differences. The problem isn't that a girl checked into a local bar. The problem is that someone wants to stalk/rape her. Scaring people into not checking in to somewhere (or not doing so publicly) is getting dangerously close to saying "well, she shouldn't have worn that short skirt if she didn't want to get hassled", which is a terribly flawed argument and ignores the actual problem. There's an entire side of this that is overlooked whenever this debate pops up: All the freaks and geeks who thought they were alone because they were into different things can now find like minded people and know that don't have to feel alone. Look at the "it gets better" campaign. It's beautiful and has likely helped thousands of people. We should focus on the good stuff a little more often rather than focus on the potential bad stuff.
- reidmain 15y ago"The problem is this: all social networks run on the principle that if you're not paying for the product, you are the product." I wonder what percentage of Facebook/Foursquare/etc users realize this?
- scotty79 15y agoYou are a product to almost everybody who shows you pretty pictures or talks to you not asked. It's nothing unusual.
- scotty79 15y agoI don't really like the whole privacy debate. Should my safety rely mostly on the fact that people don't know anything about me? I'd rather much prefer the world where me not being stalked relies not on the fact that my potential stalker knows nothing about me, but on the fact that everybody knows everything about my potential stalker. I think that the world I'd prefer is where the technology currently drags us kicking and screaming.
- scribu 15y agoIn other words, "Screw privacy! If you're honest, you've got nothing to hide."
- scotty79 15y agoNo. Rather "Screw privacy! Regardless of your honesty you'll eventually won't be able to hide anything. You might as well demand open access to this kind of information about everybody because some people will know those things about you."
- amcintyre 15y agoSurely there's a point where you'd want it to stop, though, because it's too invasive? The only way to make sure we know everything about the potential stalker is to coerce everyone into frequently providing detailed information, since (I'm just guessing here) people that are inclined to be the most dangerous stalkers are not going to be obsessively updating Facebook with all the activities that would flag them as a stalker.
- scotty79 15y agoJust an information who accesses information about me would be a good thing. When, how often and exactly what information. Also I'd like to see what other people say about the guy who accesses my information. And no stupid anti-defamation laws. I'll make up my own mind whether someone is slandered or just exposed. Also you are on every security camera in public space. Why this information is allowed to be non public? I'd like to check out if anyone was following me.
- bugsbunnyak 15y agoHow the hell does this have anything to do with the Rwandan genocide (linked in second paragraph)? I agree that this confluence of apps/search/sharing is potentially dangerous, but that kind of hyperbole doesn't help -- especially when it is a non-sequitur.
- cstross 15y agoIt's not a non-sequiteur; it's a hook for the last-but-one paragraph, which provides a rather more concrete example of how such tools might be misused in future.
- gyardley 15y agoI don't know, Charlie - yes, these tools can facilitate genocide, but we've shown ourselves to be pretty good at the genocide thing with a lot less sophisticated technology. The next time we have a genocide, we'll use a lot of different tools to do it, maybe even iPhone applications and Facebook data, but I have a hard time believing the same horror wouldn't have occurred absent this information. The problem isn't the app, and the problem isn't the behavioral targeting industry that encourages others to share. The problem is us. When one group of us makes up our minds to kill another group of us, it's going to happen whatever the technology at hand.
- unreal37 15y agoI think there is a generational difference in the concept of privacy. And a misunderstanding that the general public "doesn't understand" the privacy controls on Facebook. My 69 year old mother, when she was on Facebook, had her privacy controls to maximum. You couldn't find her on search. She didn't use her real name even! And she was sending me articles by email every other week when Facebook had some privacy breach. So whenever I hear someone say "most people don't understand privacy on Facebook" I call bullshit because my own mother is the counterexample. She's since deleted her account because of privacy concerns. I think kids of today (teens and twenty-somethings) don't care as much. They don't mind telling the world they are at a bar tonight. They add people they don't know as friends. They have 800, 900 Facebook friends. There is no privacy when you have 900 Facebook friends and they know it. All these arguments about stalkers, rapists, and white supremacists are straw men. As another commenter said, you don't NEED an app to find random people. Just use your eyes. A supremacist after Jews? Not hard to find if you know where to look. A rapist looking for women? Not hard to find if you know where to look. This has nothing to do with Facebook.
- dmbaggett 15y agoI think kids of today (teens and twenty-somethings) don't care as much. They don't mind telling the world they are at a bar tonight. But is this view the result of rational consideration, with full knowledge of all the implications, or is it something these young people have been drawn into without stopping to think about the implications? Or worse: without the full implications even being clear? In other words: is this really a demographic shift we're seeing, or simply a stage-of-life effect? Will the same teens holding the quoted view of privacy recoil in horror at their actions twenty years later? Will these privacy choices alter the courses of the lives in ways they wish they could later undo? If so, then it seems unreasonable to wave away this mass choice as morally or societally neutral. Simply put: is privacy a public safety issue or not? If it is, then an argument can be made to restrict young people's (and even grown adults') freedom to choose their "policy" on it, just as many societies do with drugs, alcohol, driving, etc. I think Charlie's post makes a pretty strong argument that privacy is a matter of public safety and societal well-being. Putting words in his mouth, his argument might be that companies like Facebook are inducing people to relinquish their privacy rights without the full knowledge of the long-term implications -- just as profit-seeking tobacco companies induced large numbers of people to smoke without full knowledge of the long-term implications. Many governments now see the public policy advantages to making the consequences of smoking clear to the public; the same is not yet true of privacy rights.
- trestacos 15y agoI think Charles is right to be concerned about the current state of privacy in social media, but I take issue with his statement that facebook is deliberately making it harder to make your content private. If you click on Privacy setting in facebook today the first thing you're greeted with is a big control asking you if you want your profile to be public /friends/custom. But first you have to care enough to click on it. Building social network privacy controls is not an easy problem b/c people don't want to do the extra work that's involved in setting privacy on things that they post AND it's confusing. Most people just don't want to choose a circle for their 300 fb friends. Facebook has gone through many iterations of privacy controls - https://blog.facebook.com/blog.php?post=391922327130 https://blog.facebook.com/blog.php?post=391922327130 goes into some of that history. Some of them even included google circle-like functionality for privacy. No one used them. I'm not saying that these controls couldn't be improved, but the point here is that privacy controls take work from users. Until society as a whole is aware of these issues (and Girls Around Me does a great job of it :), people aren't going to invest the time to do it. TL;DR - building privacy controls are hard. The industry as a whole needs to improve them, but society also needs to learn to care about their privacy so they actually use what's available to them.
- shadowfiend 15y ago“However, to make such micro-targeted advertising practical, the social networks need to motivate their users to disclose information relevant to advertisers. ” This is what makes most complaints in the facebook-makes-money-off-of-you vein a complete misunderstanding of technology. For the purposes of advertising, facebook does not need you to disclose relevant information to anyone but facebook. Advertisers need never come anywhere near that information. The data doesn't even need to be sent to them in aggregate. All advertisers need to do is say “I want to target this demographic”. They then need to get no data other than “someone from this demographic clicked on your ad”. That's it! Facebook has the data, facebook does the matching, facebook provides feedback in clicks—this, yes, in aggregate—and no other information needs to be exchanged. There is a broader argument being made here, about exposing personal information and what have you, but facebook doesn't need you to make your information public so that advertisers can get to it, they want you to make your information public so that that guy you met at a party last night can find you, friend you, and start liking your posts, thus making you feel that your posts are getting more attention, thus making you feel good about yourself, thus making you want to post more, thus making others want to get on more to read your posts, etc, etc. Of course, they also want it public so that guy over there can look you up and see some of your pictures, even if he doesn't necessarily intend on friending you. That way, said guy is also on facebook, using it more than before. So I would argue that how public information disclosure is on facebook is far more about retention and usage than it is about advertising. Advertising can be and, at least as far as my understanding of it goes, is done without having to disclose anything to the advertiser. And that's as it should be, since the technology lets them not leak that info. Why would they want to provide that information if they can achieve the same results without doing so? With that in mind, I wish the facebook privacy argument would stop presenting advertiser information swapping as a real issue. There are reasons that privacy is an issue on facebook, foursquare, etc., (indeed, this app is an excellent example) but I don't think advertising is one of those reasons. That can be done with very little information revealed, even in aggregate. (It's possible I missed a detailing somewhere of facebook explicitly exposing information to advertisers in a way different from what I mention above; if so, I'd love a link and I'll sit down and be quiet now :) It's also true that between fb advertisements and installing fb like buttons, it's possible to gather more data on a user than concentrating on advertisements alone. But that's a complaint about fb giving your information to apps, and while it's a lot harder to tease out the motivations there, I think they still derive a greater benefit from that in terms of retention and usage than they do in terms of advertising.)
- rdl 15y agoI wonder how many billions this app could drop off Facebook's IPO, if it either causes people to avoid sharing (unlikely) or brings in a heavy-handed regulatory response in an election year (much more likely). FB should just buy the company to kill the product; would be cheap in comparison. 1% chance of 100mm loss would warrant it.
- trestacos 15y agoA fundamental part of charles' argument is that in order to sell ads, facebook must encourage you to set your profile settings to public. That's not the case. It doesn't matter whether you've set your profile to fully private - Facebook's privacy settings don't affect whether or not marketers can target you with ads. In fact, in that regard facebook is incented to protect your privacy so that you'll be comfortable putting more information in the site, which they can then use for better targeting. Since marketers don't get specific information about you when you're targeted, your privacy hasn't been breached in doing so. This doesn't change that people should be very careful about their privacy settings, but the fact that facebook does targeted ads doesn't mean they have incentives to encourage you to make everything you post public.
- AndyKelley 15y ago"Or even just an unscrupulous ass-hat in search of a one night stand who isn't above researching his target's taste in music and drinks without their knowledge." Why is he so up in arms about this? What's wrong with this behavior, other than that it is arbitrarily discouraged by most of our culture? These women are making this information public. If some guy wants to try to use this publicly broadcast information to meet women and attempt to seduce them, who cares? Maybe she'll even enjoy the fact that the guy has bothered to find something common to talk about.
- RobAtticus 15y agoI think the implication is the guy doesnt actually share the interests but can pretend he does to appear like he has something in common with her. The tactic isnt new or anything, just a bit easier to pull off.
- fredBuddemeyer 15y agois there any evidence that the loss of privacy is more than the gains we share from being open and sharing? is there any reason to believe that even such thoughtful posts about privacy will not look quaint and absurd in a couple of years? a loss in privacy is a gain in openness and understanding and thats why real (and much more often) hypothetical horrors aside it is an intrinsic and evolutionary trend for humanity.
- dfc 15y ago"It's probably possible to apply this sort of data mining exercise to determine whether a woman has had an abortion or is pro-choice." Using a social graph to figure out if a user is pro-choice is probably not that hard. I'd love to hear how this guy is going to use it to determine if someone has had an abortion. But I'm afraid to know what assumptions he makes about women who have abortions in order to come to this conclusion.
- ams6110 15y agoTarget was able to figure out when a woman had likely become pregnant. So it's probably not impossible to figure out when a woman has had an abortion.
- dfc 15y agoTarget is not a social network, but I will play along. Target was able to discern pregnancy because of purchases made or not made over a span of months, many months. In the case of abortion there is a significant motivation to not wait; namely abortion laws but also social stigma. Expectant mothers purchased folic acid and other vitamins. There is not a recommended vitamin routine for an abortion. The same thing can be said for many other purchases made by expectant mothers. How are you going to separate abortions from miscarriages?
- dfc 15y agoWhat is a "reasonably powerful facebook query tooi"? Is this an app category that exists? Are there any good examples?
- vectorpush 15y agoReal human beings live complex lives in which they occupy different roles which are exposed to different people. Facebook tries to bundle everything up into one amorphous blob. This is my biggest issue with Facebook. I was once a moderately active Facebook user, back when it was cool and before it became ubiquitous. Over the years, without really thinking about it, I've allowed my Facebook friends-list to accumulate dozens of extended (and my entire immediate) family as well as professional colleagues and many other miscellaneous acquaintances of various walks. I was once fond of posting interesting articles and commentary, but now I am compelled to consider the politics/religion/sensitivities of ~250 individuals lest I end up in a flame war with my aunt or boss or individuals who I've been actively avoiding who are suddenly pissed because I made a FB post but didn't reply/comment/like their relationship status update. Facebook has managed to make social interaction online more uncomfortable than real life, and as a result it's been over a year since I've made any type of visible activity on Facebook, but I still can't escape... Socializing in the real world, I have to explicitly state things like: "Hey, please don't geotag me to this pub, and don't post pictures of me chugging this pint of Blue Moon". In conclusion, fuck Facebook.
- rmc 15y agoDelete your account?
- vectorpush 15y agoFair enough, and I've considered it, but deleting my account still doesn't prevent others from tagging and posting pictures of me for the benefit of those who can identify me through name or face alone. At least with an active Facebook account, I receive notifications whenever my likeness is invoked. Additionally, Facebook has become the defacto communication platform of the day and not having one is sometimes viewed as a social red flag (or as a lie). My cellphone # has changed three times since 2004, but the respective Facebook query has only become better at finding me. My point being, "delete your account?" is something akin to "cancel your cell service?" except nobody calls and everyone uses Facebook.
- 15y ago
- tptacek 15y agoThis notion that Facebook artificially suppresses the multiple "roles" (parent, teacher, officemate, spouse) people live in their real lives is a red herring. Stross tries to make a point by suggesting teachers don't want students to see into their private lives. Yes. And this is why teachers don't friend students on Facebook. In reality, Facebook doesn't suppress those roles; it just doesn't support them (and when it comes close, perhaps accidentally, that's when Fb can start to get a little awkward --- like, my Dad is an Fb friend; but: some people have adult friendships with their parents! [My dad is still my dad]). But most people do have a somewhat coherent role of "adult out in the real world interacting with peers, friends, and acquaintances in a social setting". It's the role you play when you go to a coworker's house party, or to a bar, or to the park. This is a huge part of most people's lives. Capturing it in social software is not a minor achievement. The expectation that Facebook should do so much more than that, dividing people's lives perfectly into facets like "immediate family" and "work group", seems off. It may not even be possible. Just don't friend those people.
- zeroonetwothree 15y agoExactly. For some people it makes sense to be Facebook friends with their parents, because they interact with them socially. It probably never makes sense to be Facebook friends with your students, but then why would you want a relationship with them at all on any social network? It just doesn't seem like an appropriate forum for that relationship. It's not as if Facebook is meant to replace all communication online.
- ghshephard 15y agoI signed up for Facebook back when it required you to have an email address associated with a university. I acquired my 300 or so friends, various extended family members (each of which in their own carefully crafted privacy circles) and an impressive collection of pictures of debauchery at various parties (ergo, the carefully crafted privacy circles) The point a which FB became a $100 Billion entity is about when I realized that perhaps it was time to move on. This article was the catalyst that let me pull the rip cord and delete my Facebook account. All credit to Facebbok - they make it exceptionally easy to do. Took me all of 90 seconds (and most of that was deciphering a captcha). I've switched Path with a much smaller group of five friends (funny how there were only five of the 300 i really felt the need to share with) - i'll hang out there until that becomes intrusive in some way I don't appreciate - who knows, maybe a rolling history of increasingly privacy oriented social networks is the way to go. Maybe, one day, there will be a social network upon which, -I- am the customer. I would certainly pay for that service.
- icebraining 15y agoAll credit to Facebbok - they make it exceptionally easy to do. Took me all of 90 seconds (and most of that was deciphering a captcha). They seem to have a tendency to restore it if you so much as look at one of their buttons during the two week period after you "delete" it. Only after that it becomes "deleted".
- golden_apples 15y agoTangential to the actual topic of discussion: what exactly has changed in Facebook's developer/app policies that an app like this is possible today, while a year ago something like Breakup Notifier was blocked from Facebook's API? Was it just that Girls Near Me hadn't gotten noticed yet? (I see that Foursquare blocked Girls Near Me from their API, but I haven't seen a response from Facebook yet.)
- georgieporgie 15y agoAm I the only one who thinks the saddest part of all this is the fact that people immediately jump to the conclusion of "OMG STALKERS AND RAPISTS!"? We're addicted to worst-case thinking. We see men as aggressors and dangerous, and we reinforce notions of "weak" members of society (i.e. women and children) needing to be hidden away in what we perceive as safety.
- drblast 15y agoYou're not the only one. What's a bit silly is the idea that there's someone sitting at home wishing to perform a stalking or rape, but is prevented from doing so by the lack of an app for that.
- epo 15y agoWhat's a bit silly (actually idiotic) is your second sentence. No one is claiming that stalking or rape is impossible without these apps, they are saying such apps makes life easier for stalkers and rapists.
- georgieporgie 15y agoactually idiotic Take that attitude elsewhere. No one is claiming that stalking or rape is impossible without these apps And nobody was claiming that anyone was making that claim. If you're going to call someone an idiot, you should really be more careful with what you subsequently write.
- zeroonetwothree 15y agoIt seems unlikely that social media has had a significant effect on making rape easier because rapes in the US been declining for a while now.
- ebiester 15y ago8% of women have been stalked in their life. http://www.musc.edu/vawprevention/research/stalking.shtml http://www.musc.edu/vawprevention/research/stalking.shtml Between 15 and 20% of women have been raped in their lifetimes. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rape_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rape_in_the_United_States - (now, this gets complicated due to under reporting, and that most rape is done by someone known my the attacker.) I would say it is a legitimate concern.
- RandallBrown 15y agoThe whole purpose of FourSquare and Facebook is to show off information about yourself to other people. You sign up for FourSquare because you want to tell people where you are. You want other people to know where you are. You sign up for Facebook so you can show other people your photos and see other people's photos. You can talk to them, interact, and share your beliefs. Both services make it possible to limit who this information is shared with. Saying "it's confusing" is a pretty poor argument as to why that makes these things creepy or dangerous. Most people WANT this information to be public. That's why they signed up for these services in the first place. Personally, I feel MUCH safer that people know where I am and what I'm doing. If I ever go missing, there will be a solid documented trail of where I've been up until I go missing.
- Aftershock21 15y agoWhy do you need an app to find girls AROUND YOU! I find them around me all the time.
- Katelyn 15y agoI disagree with many of the arguments you make to support your theory, namely 1)the idea that the way users use Facebook wont evolve and get more sophisticated as they share more information, and 2) the idea that sharing more information about yourself even makes you more susceptible to stalker and hate crimes. After I read your post, I went back up to the top re-read your proposal, which, in its simplest form, makes a the claim that reads: "Facebook-as-a-business will eventually kill the very users it needs to survive, because in order for Facebook to grow and profit, it will encourage users to share more about themselves with others, and as a result, users will share so much about themselves with others, (who they are, their interests, behavior, location) that they will become victims of crimes like rape, murder or even hate crimes and genocide. This sounds outlandish, of not even a little silly. Surely, our acculturation with Facebook and the way we use it will evolve over time to protect our selves from this kind of thing from happening.
- martswite 15y agoI may be way out here but, it's been mentioned that the data facebook holds that is publicly available could be used and mined to target certain groups of people... Am I way out here in mentioning historical organisations that also stored masses of data on a population like the stasi (maybe extreme)? I just find it extremely uncomfortable that people are so blasé about what they share on facebook. What worries me more is that I dont think people are ignorant of the privacy settings. Amongst my friends that do use it, they know, they just dont really care, purely because as some people have said it takes maintenance, makes it more difficult to connect with people or makes it impossible to be connected with... I just find this whole culture of sharing intimate details with a) facebook and b) with each other, that we never really shared previously to be disturbing and the organisations that encourage this to be sinister.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- donnaware 15y agoThe obvious opportunity here is to develop an app to counter it called "Creeps Around Me" to alert "Girls" (AKA Women) that there is a creepy stalker like dude around them, bonus points if you figure out how to alert her that the creep is eStalking.