5 ms·
The final seconds of a fatal Tesla Autopilot crash – A reconstruction
- notamy 3y agohttps://archive.ph/2023.10.07-124426/https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/interactive/2023/tesla-autopilot-crash-analysis/ https://archive.ph/2023.10.07-124426/https://www.washingtonp...
- vsskanth 3y agoI have no opinion on Tesla or their autopilot system, but this is a poorly researched article even for wapo. It's focusing on the wrong thing in this particular case. Even normal collision avoidance systems cannot easily detect a semi truck sideways, because semi trucks and trailers in NA aren't required to have side skirts and protection bars. This won't happen in EU because all their trucks have mandated side skirts and bars. So when the car hits it the occupants are protected through the air bags and crumple zones. The objective should be to prevent severe bodily harm or loss of life to the occupants in the event of a collision, with/without an avoidance system. Find out why trucks in NA don't have mandated side skirts. Who's lobbying against it ? If they really want to talk about lack of proper safeguards in autopilot they could've investigated many other reported scenarios like Teslas suddenly steering into the opposing lane, dividers. There are also reports of their system behaving erratically when the road slopes up into the horizon.
- nullindividual 3y agoAdding those rules in the US has been tired more than once. https://www.truckinginfo.com/10138132/underride-legislation-calls-for-side-front-guards https://www.truckinginfo.com/10138132/underride-legislation-...
- vsskanth 3y agoIt seems to have gone nowhere, I suspect due to lobbying.
- iudqnolq 3y agoYou seem to be conflating impact mitigation with obstacle detection
- vsskanth 3y agoI'm focusing on neither. I'm saying there should be regulations to prevent loss of life even when impact happens, especially when other regions have implemented known solutions.
- iudqnolq 3y agoI see. I missed that because it's quite tangential. WashPo didn't miss the point by not talking about it.
- lolinder 3y ago> Even normal collision avoidance systems cannot detect a semi truck sideways because semi trucks and trailers in NA aren't required to have side skirts and protection bars. You know what can detect a semi truck sideways? Human eyes. Collision detection systems are meant to trigger far later anyway, potentially after it's already too late. Side skirts would be helpful for sure in reducing fatalities in the event of a collision, but better still is avoiding the collision in the first place. This kind of response is extremely condescending: "this is a poorly researched article because it didn't focus on the aspect of the story that I find most important." It's a perfectly valid approach to focus on the fact that Tesla's marketing of their "fancy cruise control" (their lawyer's words) causes people to trust it with their lives in unsafe ways, even when it's apparently incapable of something as simple as seeing the broad side of a semi truck. If you think the lack of side skirts is such an important issue, write your own article on it, don't cast aspersions on someone else's article.
- monkaiju 3y agoIt really says so much that we allow these systems on our public roads.
- ergonaught 3y agoI don't know if you've paid much attention to the other systems we allow on our public roads, but they're looking at their phones instead of avoiding collisions, or they're aggressively refusing to cooperate instead of collaboratively producing flow and throughput, or they're impaired by substances or medications or diseases or untested capability degeneration, or
- HarryHirsch 3y agoWe don't allow these things on public roads, there's laws against texting, alcohol, aggressive driving &c. But Tesla's autopilot with no sense of the world around it is the equivalent of a teenager in his second driving lesson. We don't let those drive.
- screamingninja 3y ago> there's laws against texting Not in several US states, including where I live > alcohol Most states legally allow BAC up to 0.08, which is too high for someone expected to make split second decisions > aggressive driving Maybe there's laws against it but never seen it enforced. Aggressive driving is extremely common here. And you say we don't allow these things to happen on public roads?
- ergonaught 3y agoSome places have some laws against those things, but they are still "allowed on the road" and only "punished" after they are "caught". In any case, I assure you Tesla's autopilot is vastly beyond a teenager in their "second driving lesson." Driving lessons! How quaint! As if these are obligatory prior to being "allowed on the road" everywhere! Simply darling.
- 1970-01-01 3y ago
- uuddlrlrbaba 3y agoThe guy would still be alive if he chose a different car manufacturer
- yreg 3y agoOr if they paid attention while driving.
- uuddlrlrbaba 3y agoPaying attention isn't optional in a car without a half-baked autopilot feature.
- bannedbybros 3y ago[dead]
- cj 3y ago> Because of the orientation of Tesla’s cameras, the person said, it was sometimes hard to discern the location of the tractor-trailers. In one view, the truck could appear to be floating 20 feet above the road, like an overpass. In another view, it could appear 25 feet below the ground. What sort of camera or lenses are they using that causes something to appear 20 feet underground or 20 feet in the sky?
- lolinder 3y agoIt sounds like it's less about the type of lens that they use and more about the fact they put the cameras in awkward places (presumably to preserve the aesthetic of the car), looking down and looking up in ways that make it hard to judge distance. It doesn't help that they also chose to avoid using lidar or radar, because Musk was adamant that if human eyes can do it with just visual light then his computers would too.
- cj 3y agoI googled a bit (and read the model 3 handbook) but found 1 source that said Tesla's forward collision warning does use radar. Anyone more knowledgable know whether that's true? I'm curious how much it's relying on object recognition via cameras vs. the more traditional radar based foward collision braking that are standard on "dumb" modern cars. ...or in other words, would a "dumb" modern car still fail in the same scenario?
- katbyte 3y agoIt did, but they removed it in 2021, and I think disabled it in software of cars shipped with it
- sunflowerfly 3y agoThey disabled in software, and disabled the hardware on many vehicles taken in for unrelated service.
- dtgriscom 3y agoI'm a WaPo subscriber, and saw this on the front page. I haven't read it, though, because I really don't want to get a thrill from exploring someone else's tragedy.
- appplication 3y agoLooking at the evidence, it would be quite hard to argue that Tesla is not in the wrong. Despite the other commenter focusing on tangential issues like semi side skirts, the fact is that Tesla autopilot has been represented as being capable of handling complex road conditions as well or better than a human. And this is a simple case that demonstrates that it is not capable of detecting an object in front of it, on a flat road in good weather, that it will clearly impact. The problem is not Tesla experimenting with self driving tech. The problem is Tesla is overstating its capabilities, confusing consumers with mixed messaging between their marketing/CEO statements and reality, and reaping the financial benefits of convincing users they are buying autonomous-capable cars when they are nowhere near autonomous.
- katbyte 3y agoI would say the problem is they are experimenting with self driving tech on the general public. And it’s resulting in deaths of people not driving teslas - like heck read how the truck driver feels post incident dudes shook up
- beebmam 3y agoIt's wild that this experimental feature is legal.
- katbyte 3y agoEven more wild they haven’t been fined or successfully sued for millions by the families of the dead yet
- Slartie 3y agoTrue. Where is this crazy habit of American consumers winning absurd amounts of money in court for big corp faults of extremely varying severity when you need it just once to stop an actually severe practice?
- judge2020 3y ago
- yreg 3y agoI don't get the point. Autopilot is "just" an adaptive cruise control with line assist. It is not self driving. Of course it is going to crash when you are cruising at high speed and a semi suddenly rolls across the street. It also doesn't stop for stop signs or red lights, those are known limitations. We can proceed into the discussion whether it is okay to call such a system 'autopilot'. One side will say that autopilot (also in airplanes) means driver's assist, not self driving. The other side will say that a common person thinks it means self driving and therefore it is misleading. But I think this terminology was debated to death on hacker news.
- malfist 3y agoAutopilot is not advertised or described to consumers as "just" adaptive cruise.
- belltaco 3y agoSource(s)?
- diggan 3y ago> Autopilot - Future of Driving - Autopilot enables your car to steer, accelerate and brake automatically within its lane under your active supervision, assisting with the most burdensome parts of driving. [...] https://www.tesla.com/en_eu/models https://www.tesla.com/en_eu/models Reading this, without any other context or knowledge about their capabilities, it does sound like the car can control itself and pilot itself automatically. The name is disingenuous and misleading, so no wonder people think the car can steer, accelerate and brake by itself even though in cases like this, it did neither.
- galangalalgol 3y agoIt can do all of those things though. Usually does. Usually is why you are there. I can't imagine anyone who has even just test driven one doing anything but frantically scanning the roadway while somehow white knuckling with a loose grip. The manual and the somewhat erratic behavior of the 3d model representing what it is aware of are not confidence inspiring. Added since this incident, the driver monitor camera, which uses ir illumination at night, disables autopilot if it decides you aren't looking at the road, has some false positives. The only thing I trust it for is stop and go traffic on a major highway. It does that reliably. I'm still scanning nervously to avoid a low speed collision. I've had it automatically engage brakes once in what it thought was an emergency when cruise control was off. I saw the person cutting me off and was about to brake with plenty of time. My wife agreed with the car...
- musha68k 3y agoWhatever happened to the oath of the engineer? I’m not buying that this issue is only about psychopathic business people. Neither domain nor pay grade leave room for “professional” excuses here. Oh and yes “even” interaction design including nomenclature / wording used to fall under engineering considerations / vetting as well. For a “software” car the interaction on the whole is terribly designed. UI out of immediate view, low contrast, distracting, etc. I was appalled how bad the experience was driving a Tesla over a recent short vacation (2022 Model 3).
- ferbivore 3y agoMost people don't care about others' lives. Engineers are no different. It takes regulators to keep them from killing people, not an oath.
- belltaco 3y ago> A Washington Post analysis of federal data found that vehicles guided by Autopilot have been involved in more than 700 crashes, at least 19 of them fatal, since its introduction in 2014 19 fatalities in 8 years... less than 2.5 fatalities per year compared to 42,795 automobile crash fatalities in just 2022 in the USA. Has the WaPo or anyone analysed the break up of those fatalities to see what's causing them and what can be done easily to prevent at least 3 fatalies per year, since that seems to be the bar for going to the effort for such deep and painstaking analysis in the article? Or would that not get enough clicks(including on HN) to warrant a story even if it eventually leads to saving way more lives?
- nickthegreek 3y agoThe Tesla aren’t driving in the nearly the same conditions of those 42k deaths along with many other differences means that you cant directly compare these numbers. The EV number will probably be lower, but you aren’t using the correct data to support your point.
- katbyte 3y agoYour data and comparison is bad. Just bad and wrong. Autopilot deaths vs all car crash death? When Tesla is <1% of cars on the road? And that 19 is just autopilot not all involving a Tesla, the stat your comparing to??
- belltaco 3y agoIf you wanted to save lives, you would focus on the low hanging fruit in the 43K deaths per year, not the 2.5 deaths per year. You could save 5 times more lives by banning all vending machines in the US or by making them safer when they fall than by banning AutoPilot, since they directly kill about 13 people a year by falling on them. That's not even counting the number of lives potentially saved by AutoPilot because human drivers cause 43K/deaths a year.
- katbyte 3y agoYou are still comparing meaningless numbers. If Tesla assisted driving systems are less safe then the rest that is where the focus should be, and last I checked 70% of accidents involving driver assisted systems where teslas, and they are only 1% of cars on the road. That is a HUGE problem and 100% where regulation should be focusing. https://amp.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/jun/15/tesla-us-car-carashes-driver-assist-systems https://amp.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/jun/15/tesla-us-car...
- notorandit 3y agoWas really autopilot (full autonomous drive, I mean) available at that time?