4 ms·
Good. I can take or leave the practice as a customer. I generally tip 20% unless the service is exceptionally good or bad, so it'd work out mostly the same for
by kstrauser 3y ago
Good. I can take or leave the practice as a customer. I generally tip 20% unless the service is exceptionally good or bad, so it'd work out mostly the same for me if restaurants just raised their prices 20% and got rid of tipping.
But there are a couple of recent developments I absolutely loathe:
1. Mandatory service charges on top of the bill. No, sorry, that's bullshit. If you want to charge more, charge more. Yes, that will make your published price reflect the real cost. That's a feature, not a bug. When I find out I'm at such a place -- usually too late, after I've eaten -- I tip max(0, 20% - service fee). In other words, I apply the service fee toward what I would have tipped. If the servers aren't getting that fee and they quit because their tips suck, that's on the owners.
2. Asking for tips for everything. Earlier this week I went to a shop that sells cakes that're made off-site and shipped in. I asked a cashier for the cake I wanted, she turned around and picked it off a rack and handed it to me, and the checkout terminal asked for a tip. For what? Nothing against the cashier, but I'm offended at the shop for having the nerve to even ask.
I get why employers like tipped positions: they can get away with paying less, guilt tripping customers to make up for low wages with donations. Nah. I'll continue tipping people I would've tipped 5 years ago, like waitstaff, barbers, etc. I'm not going to start tipping every not-traditionally-tipped employee just to cover for their employers.
- tomatotomato37 3y agoI have to wonder how much the tips on those new advanced checkout terminal actually go towards the particular worker; most of the time it just seems like a default situation where the business barely understands how to setup the terminal let alone turn it off
- abeppu 3y agoBut _should_ they go to just that particular worker? In HS, I washed dishes in a restaurant in my hometown. The waiters (all white, young attractive 20 somethings) would _occasionally_ share out a few dollars of tips to us on a very busy night. The dishwashers were highschool students immigrants. The work for dishwashers naturally scales linearly with the number of orders. Certainly I think it's BS that as a customer, I'm not sure whether the management is just taking these (and telling their workers "oh, you're getting minimum wage; you don't need tips"). But if we're gonna be tipping for _every_ service, should the person that takes your coffee order get the whole tip, rather than the person who's making drinks, or doing prep work in the back?
- Gigachad 3y agoNo one seems to know how to configure them. I'm in Australia and the tip screens show up on them now so the staff press "skip" on it before they hand it to you. Including the business owners.
- abdullahkhalids 3y agoVisa/Mastercard also have an incentive not to help the shop owners not remove the tipping screen, because Visa/Mastercard charge a percentage of the transaction size. Removing the tip option has an impact on their profits.
- anuraaga 3y agoDoes anyone know if all the time, it is not possible for the staff to know if you tipped or not when using the terminal? Not for post-pay but pre-pay, e.g. buying a coffee. I would generally be inclined not to tip in these situations but am worried my drink will be contaminated if I don't. I have a feeling the answer is yes, or don't know, and if there were any regulation enacted the best would be to ensure gratuities before service provided are either banned or guaranteed to be hidden. Gratuities after service provided don't seem to require any restriction. Disclaimer: I live in a country without tips and love it, would feel better on trips to the US if it were the same.
- pc86 3y agoThe thing that really gets me, which I've only ever seen in Chicago is this mysterious 3-5% fee added to every bill, but which the restaurant will immediately remove for you if you ask what the hell it's for.
- Simulacra 3y agoIn DC we call that a tourist fee. Several of the restaurants near the National Mall will add a "guest fee" or "tourism fee" to the bill, but you won't find it explained or listed anywhere. They probably rake in a lot of money from foreign tourists that way.
- aksss 3y agoWell, you don't _have_ to give a tip even if prompted. Part of the struggle here is learning to ignore any internal shaming mechanism for valid conditions where no tip is warranted - specifically, taking a product off a shelf and charging you money for it. There is no circumstance where I'm tipping in a retail environment, specifically basic shopping activities. I'm starting to wean myself off of pandemic-era tipping for take-out orders (I tip 10% for to-go now). Part of the whole donation industry and now tipping-everywhere practice is just basic money-harvesting, like putting a net in the river and seeing what they can harvest from randos at scale. But there is some interest-balancing that needs to be considered, specifically my need to not hemorrhage money. At some level the expectation gets kind of insulting. Checking out at a grocery store? Want to round up to donate to some non-audited cause you never heard of that has a plausibly good name? Wassamatta? You hate kids/puppies/poor/refugees/war victims/elderly???? No, I hate being taken advantage of and hate my kindness being leveraged, GTFO.
- kstrauser 3y agoI'm with you on every bit of that. I'm good about turning that potential internal shaming into annoyance with the employer. For me, that means that every ridiculous request for tips gives me a bad feeling about the business, either shame for being pushed into tipping, or frustration that I had to spend emotional effort to avoid it. Either way, it leaves me with a bad feeling about the place, and makes me less likely to go back.
- radicality 3y agoWhen you say “10% for to-go”, is that for delivery or when you’re yourself picking up food to go? If it’s just picking up food to go, why tip at all, hasn’t pretty much zero service been provided to you?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aksss 3y agoPicking up, I tip excessively for delivery, and honestly it's because I've been both a delivery driver and standing at the ovens, so it's purely a personal sort of nostalgic solidarity/empathy/love to send some joy their way in the form of cash. I know I appreciated it back in the day and was very grateful for it. I don't have any love or respect for the social glare or tip shaming, however. It's gotten out of hand.
- mattrick 3y agoI was always under the impression that the mandatory service fees (like for groups of x or more) was just a way to make sure that the wait staff don't get stiffed. If the service fee is 20%, I just tip 0% unless I feel inclined to tip more on top of that.
- kstrauser 3y agoThat's the interpretation I'm going with. Here, though, there are quite a few restaurants that add a service fee to all dining. If you eat there alone, you're getting a 20% fee.
- OkayPhysicist 3y agoIt's worth asking if the service fee is actually a gratuity or not. If it's not listed as a gratuity, then legally the owner can be taking a cut.
- kstrauser 3y agoIf it’s not a tip, that should be illegal as hell. It’s just a way to have higher prices without advertising them as higher up front.
- thiht 3y ago> people I would've tipped 5 years ago, like waitstaff, barbers Why would you tip a barber? (I am not from the US, trying to understand)
- kstrauser 3y agoI don’t know, we just do. Here’s an article about who to tip: https://lifehacker.com/who-should-i-tip-and-how-much-5970143 https://lifehacker.com/who-should-i-tip-and-how-much-5970143 I don’t agree with all of that, like no way I’m tipping at a buffet where I’m not receiving any service. It’s more illustrative of how weirdly complex this all gets.