7 ms·
Governments have a problem where they get captured by special interests. If you have a lot of government employees, they vote for politicians who give them more
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
Governments have a problem where they get captured by special interests. If you have a lot of government employees, they vote for politicians who give them more money or benefits or refuse to make them redundant even if something changes and what they do is no longer necessary.
This means that if you're buying something like trucks, it's generally better for the government to buy ordinary trucks from the market than to operate a public sector auto manufacturing industry that would become bloated and inefficient because it captures the government and isn't subject to competitive pressure. Even if the trucks are critical to some government function.
This works fine as long as the bidding process is open to anyone, because then the government just buys cars from carmakers and uniforms from tailors and you ideally don't end up with a voting block of government-exclusive tailors insisting that they need to be able to retire at age 55 with full benefits. Private tailors who insisted on that to a private contractor would be refused because the contractor couldn't give them that while submitting a competitive bid for the government contract.
The problem comes when the government starts making it harder to bid on a government contract, because then the only bidders become companies that specialize in government contracting. At which point the contractors are just government employees by proxy -- they have no private customers, they only work for the government -- so then the government just gets captured again.
What should be happening is that the government puts out bids to design a tank, anyone can submit one, and the winner gets paid for the rights to the design. Then the government takes the design and put out bids to build each of the parts for the tank and gets bids from all of the companies that normally make water pumps and hydraulics for cars and homes and construction equipment. Then they take bids to assemble those parts into a tank. Then they take bids to do maintenance on the tanks. Anyone can bid who is qualified, and because the contracts are each small and as generic as possible, lots of ordinary businesses are qualified.
But instead they put out a single contract to do all of that, end up with a concentrated market of companies who specialize in government contracting, and you lose the benefit of market competition because you no longer have any.
- solardev 3y agoThat's an excellent and even-handed take on a complex topic. Thanks for your thoughtfulness!
- asynchronous 3y agoRight on the money analysis. Could give a dozen examples but Boeing attempting and failing miserably at southern border security in the early 2000s comes to mind.