3 ms·
> I realize a lot of people on HN are super privacy minded and a Ring is not for them, but realistically if you buy a Ring you WANT to protect your home/family
by ryandrake 3y ago
> I realize a lot of people on HN are super privacy minded and a Ring is not for them, but realistically if you buy a Ring you WANT to protect your home/family in which case you would happily hand over footage if police were investigating a robbery next door.
I don't follow the logic. The police are not your friends. They are not the good guys. Their job is not to protect you or your neighbor. It's to put people (possibly you) in jail--as many as they can. Handing surveillance footage over to the police only makes their job easier. It does not necessarily "protect your home/family". In general, getting involved with law enforcement, even as a crime victim or witness, is fraught. Let alone as a subpoena target or person of interest. Best to be as invisible as you can.
I don't really think this is paranoid. Encounters with the police come with a non-zero chance of being put in jail, injured, or even killed. The upside is questionable.
- tzs 3y ago> I don't follow the logic. It's pretty simple. Many of us live in places where if a neighbor is robbed the chances the robber will come back to the neighborhood again and maybe rob us is several orders of magnitude higher than the chances that anything bad (or even mildly inconvenient) will happen to us if he give the police all information we have that might help identify the robber, and where police will in fact use that information to try to catch the robber.
- dreamcompiler 3y agoIn most jurisdictions in the US cops won't even investigate a burglary unless somebody gets hurt. They simply have too many higher priorities. Yes if you can give them video of the bad guy that helps, but only a little. They now have the burglar's face, but that doesn't give them the burglar's address. Maybe your camera got the license plate number of the burglar's car? Won't help: Burglars mostly use stolen plates nowadays because so many people have cameras. Your best hope is for the burglar to actually hurt one of your neighbors, or the burglary wave becomes so egregious that elected officials notice and put pressure on the cops. Cameras are not magic crime-stopping devices: They still require police to take action, and when police are motivated to take action, cameras are useful. For simple property crimes which the cops won't investigate, cameras don't do much. You're better off making your home a harder target with heavier doors, bars on the windows, etc because those things encourage the burglars to move on to the next house. Cameras don't do that. Why? Because the burglars know everything I've written above.