3 ms·
> that humans only have rights because a law says they do, and that there are no rights inherent to being a human It may be disturbing, but that is the nature
by ben_w 3y ago
> that humans only have rights because a law says they do, and that there are no rights inherent to being a human
It may be disturbing, but that is the nature of reality. We humans indeed have no inherent rights, only those written in law. Sometimes the law says words like "these are universal and apply to all", but thinking those words really have that power because they say so is like thinking Harry Potter has to be a true story because none of the characters say "I'm fictional" when under the influence of Veritaserum.
> AI models are just pieces of software, they're not actual intelligence or sentience or life
Life is just a collection of chemical reactions.
Putting "intelligence or sentience or life" next to each other like that implies you think these are connected.
I don't think "life" is a requirement for either of the other two.
If the abilities demonstrated thus far by AI do not meet your standard for the word "intelligent", what does?
If intelligence were a prerequisite for sentience, would that be with a hard cut-off of "you must be IQ ≥ XYZ to be sentient"? Or do you suspect that sentience is a variable, with less intelligent systems also being less sentient, but also no cut-off? If there is a cut off, where? Why?
When I was a kid, we could happily assume that intelligent computers were pure sci-fi; now that models like GPT-3 have a complexity similar to the brain of a medium sized rodent — the scale may be important or may be a red herring, but we should take the questions seriously and try to come up with actual answers to each before it matters.
I'd rather treat a mindless automaton with unnecessary kindness than treat one that is able to suffer with cruelty; and on the off-chance that full-brain-uploading becomes a thing, I'd want to know for sure if an upload of me could or couldn't have qualia.
> This entire case is just a corporate power-grab seeking to profit from the work of others for free without legal repercussion
Well, some sure is. Some's given away for free, so it's not capable of being a power-grab.