11 ms·
The first examples that comes to mind is reproducing an entire copyright-protected article, either a single copy for personal use by a researcher or multiple
by dragonwriter 3y ago
The first examples that comes to mind is reproducing an entire copyright-protected article, either a single copy for personal use by a researcher or multiple copies for classroom use.
- jazzyjackson 3y agoRight, determined fair use by the supreme court in Williams & Wilkins Co. v. United States. You can walk into a library and make a wholesale copy for research purposes. The case involved a medical journal publisher suing medical doctors, who made a strong argument that their ability to make copies was a matter of life and death. Winner: Xerox. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Williams_%26_Wilkins_Co._v._United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Williams_%26_Wilkins_Co._v._...
- DoughnutHole 3y agoThat's an interesting example because it illustrates out how fair use is in part defined by its effect on the market. A teacher copying a New York Times article verbatim and distributing it to a classroom for the purpose of analysis or criticism is likely to be held by the courts as fair use. On the other hand a teacher photocopying an entire textbook (or distributing a PDF) would probably not be considered fair use. Both are copying educational material in full, but they have a different impact on the market. Distributing copies of an old news article to 30 students realistically isn't a direct substitute for 30 subscriptions to The New York Times. But a textbook publisher's business model specifically revolves around selling its textbooks to students - the teacher is distributing their copyrighted material to their target market and removing any incentive for the students to pay the publisher.
- pclmulqdq 3y agoYes, the damage to the market of the original is a key factor in a fair use analysis. It makes you wonder why "Open"AI started getting into legal trouble only when they closed everything down and became a commercial project. When they were a research project, stepping on copyrights was a lot more acceptible (both socially and legally).