3 ms·
No, by using both a combustion-gas turbine and three steam turbines to recover the waste heat you get 63% efficiency for electrical energy production. By using
by adrian_b 3y ago
No, by using both a combustion-gas turbine and three steam turbines to recover the waste heat you get 63% efficiency for electrical energy production.
By using the residual heat for hot water and for heating in winter and cooling in summer, the global efficiency typically becomes well above 80%.
Even the best Diesel generators may reach around 55% efficiency, while working at much lower maximum temperatures.
For a few seconds I thought that this thermophotovoltaic technique is great, until I have seen that the emitter must have a temperature above 2000 Celsius degrees. For such a great temperature it is very easy to make heat engines with much better efficiency and which might even be less expensive, because these multijunction III-V photovoltaic cells are many times more expensive than normal solar panels.
If these were used for solar power, the concentrators would also be very expensive. Already the concentrators that produce temperatures around 1000 Celsius degrees, which is more than enough for easily reaching 40% efficiency with closed-cycle heat engines, are much more expensive than the concentrators that reach only lower temperatures, like 650 Celsius degrees, which would still be good enough for a steam turbine or for a closed-cycle supercritical carbon dioxide engine.
The only real advantage is that these should need less maintenance than turbo-generators, which may be essential outside Earth or in remote locations, but less important than cost and efficiency otherwise.
- megaman821 3y agoDifferent use cases. This is for taking intermittent electricity production and storing it as heat. It will mainly be used for industrial heat; the TPV electricity production adds a little extra utility to the system.
- adrian_b 3y agoThermal storage at so high temperatures is even less practical than any other application. Thermal storage at low temperatures is cheap and easy with molten salts. Thermal storage at over 2000 Celsius degrees will be extremely difficult, due to the difficulty of preventing heat losses. The best would be for the hot body to be stored in argon, because in vacuum it would evaporate and heavier inert gases are expensive. The storage vessel would be very expensive in any case, being made from multiple layers with high temperature resistance, an external surface with high reflectance in red and infrared and other layers with low thermal conductivity, so it is hard to imagine that it could have a size large enough to store much energy. Another obstacle is that the available power is determined by the emitting surface, not by the volume of the hot body, which is another obstacle for scaling to large amounts of stored energy. Another obstacle to scaling is that when the hot body cools down the conversion efficiency drops extremely quickly (fourth power), which means that it could store energy only e.g. by being heated and cooled between 2400 and 2100 Celsius degrees. So only a very small fraction of the thermal capacitance of the hot body can be used, many times lower than when the heat stored in that body would be used to power a closed-cycle heat engine. So no, these devices may have some useful applications, but energy storage is certainly not one of them, because they are much worse than almost any alternative. Even storing compressed air in a pressure vessel is much more practical.
- ed_balls 3y ago"SMRs are typically anticipated to have an electrical power output of less than 300 MWe (electric) or less than 1000 MWth (thermal)"