3 ms·
People don't blame guns exclusively, but it's obvious to anyone (except gun owners) that the scale of gun violence and ease of access to firearms are related, s
by krapp 3y ago
People don't blame guns exclusively, but it's obvious to anyone (except gun owners) that the scale of gun violence and ease of access to firearms are related, so guns are part of the problem. Unfortunately they are a part of the problem which is existentially impossible to address in any effective way, because any gun control or regulation which could effectively lower gun crime would be unconstitutional in the US, so even bringing it up is futile.
>1. Some kind of social dysfunction that's leading deeper levels of anger and isolation in some people.
This happens everywhere. You should ask yourself why school shootings aren't also a problem everywhere.
>2. Massive national advertising campaigns by the media reminding angry, isolated teenagers that shooting up their school is an option they have.
Maybe you should ask yourself why it's an option they have.
- tivert 3y ago> This happens everywhere. You should ask yourself why school shootings aren't also a problem everywhere. Because people in those other places have fewer rights. Taking away rights and adding restrictions are a time-tested solution to many social problems. America should try it. Get rid of the First and Second Amendments, and you solve school shootings, extremism, Trump, the threat to democracy, all in one blow. The problem isn't really that society fucks people up and doesn't bother to help them, the problem is those people aren't impotent enough.
- krapp 3y agoThe fact that you consider shooting up schools to be a right and equate a lack of guns with impotence demonstrates why it's impossible to have rational discussion on this topic. The degree to which gun violence itself fucks people up in the US doesn't even occur to you. Thanks for playing to type, I guess.
- tivert 3y ago> The fact that you consider shooting up schools to be a right... I don't understand how anyone could manage to misread my comment that badly.
- giantg2 3y ago"but it's obvious to anyone (except gun owners) that the scale of gun violence and ease of access to firearms are related," No, it's obvious to gun owners as well. Obviously if one is concerned with "gun" violence, guns are a factor. The difference with gun owners is the perspective - a focus on other factors, a focus on overall violence/crime and not solely on the subset of gun violence, trying to find causation instead of correlation, regulations that would work while still providing protections, etc. Probably the biggest issue preventing support for additional access restrictions is how shitty the justice system is and how the enforcing agencies routinely break the laws they are supposed to abide by. Things like ex parte hearings, lack of legal representation, lower standards of proof (and then judges violating the law by erring on the safe side), ammending previous agency regulations capriciously (and sometimes in volation of statute), etc. There's no genuine debate or search for compromise by either side. It's turned into a religious war.