3 ms·
I don't disagree with this response. It's actually a good one. But I think we need to be really aware of the trade-offs here. My problem is that people use thes
by godelski 3y ago
I don't disagree with this response. It's actually a good one. But I think we need to be really aware of the trade-offs here. My problem is that people use these metrics as if they are hard proof of competence. But the truth is you have to pick your noise: nepotism or lazy evaluation. Either way, you aren't getting rid of noise.
I actually think scale is part of the problem here. In small communities there is more natural nuance and correction as there's high accountability. But with scale accountability often disappear as you disappear into the crowd. And you'll always be able to point at winners and losers to whichever noise you favor. The problem is we're not looking at things holistically and ensuring that our metrics are aligned with our desired outcomes. Instead we often pick a metric because it reasonably looks like it should align with the desired outcome (not proven, just intuited) and then just tell anyone that disagrees that it is obvious instead of acknowledging the downsides. Every metric has limitations. Ignoring them is the problem.