5 ms·
How Neuralink Keeps Dead Monkey Photos Secret
- mdhb 3y agoAlso an interesting introduction piece also from Wired on this topic from 2 weeks ago here https://www.wired.com/story/elon-musk-pcrm-neuralink-monkey-deaths/ https://www.wired.com/story/elon-musk-pcrm-neuralink-monkey-...
- mandmandam 3y ago> “If you want to split hairs,” a former employee tells WIRED, “the implant itself did not cause death. We sacrificed her to end her suffering.” What an awfully stupid way to think. "I didn't kill her your honor, I sacrificed her to prevent her suffering from the bullet wound." > As it is a public records law that UC Davis is fighting, its arguments against greater transparency are centered around what’s best for the public. According to the school's attorneys, that means the public should not see images of Neuralink’s work. "What we did is so horrific that we can't tell you, because you might get violent about it. So don't worry about it, don't ask, and keep giving us money."
- worthless-trash 3y agoNot apologizing or justifying the event with the monkeys, I've had to put down animals that have broken their hind legs, damaged intestines and been gnawed at by local dingo (or wild dog) populations. I _could_ have kept that sheep or cow alive, but the quality of life would be so low that it wouldn't be cruelty. There is a certain point where the compassionate thing is to terminate the life. I imagine some researcher was in the very same position, they may not have been the cause, and they could save the animal but at that point its not going to have any life that isn't all torture for every day of the rest of its life. I kind of envy people who have never had to make these kinds of choices. The fact that it was this bad from a lab procedure makes the situation even more saddening.
- WesolyKubeczek 3y agoThe crucial difference is that it wasn’t you breaking their hind legs, damaging their intestines, and/or gnawing at them in the first place.
- worthless-trash 3y agoThats true, I can imagine the poor lab tech who didnt make that mistake either having to make the tough call.
- chriskanan 3y agoSacrificed is a term commonly used in biology and neuroscience, so the person quoted us just using specific jargon to their field: https://slate.com/human-interest/2015/07/the-surprising-history-of-scientific-researchers-using-the-word-sacrifice-to-refer-to-lab-animals.html https://slate.com/human-interest/2015/07/the-surprising-hist... I'm sure the photos will look terrible, but if you have ever seen this kind of work in photos or papers, it is unpleasant, but as another poster points out: this is not neuralink specific. Far more animals are sacrificed for much more mundane science than what neuralink is trying to achieve, which could enormously improve quality of life for a lot of people.
- mandmandam 3y agoThis was Neuralink specific though. Neuralink have been breaking the laws which govern animal trials, and then cynically hiding the evidence of this from the public. That animal needed to be 'sacrificed' - after a day or so of horrific suffering - directly because Neuralink leaked toxic glue directly onto the animal's brain. They took notes on the horror show which followed instead of killing the animal immediately, and then took steps to hide all this from the public as well as the law. > Far more animals are sacrificed for much more mundane science Guess what - I don't agree with that either. But Neuralink are breaking the law, deliberately, and then deliberately covering that up. It's not the fucking same, and it's wild how y'all aren't getting that.
- mft_ 3y agoI’m not for a second justifying needless animal suffering, but you’re picking on the wrong thing, presumably due to a lack of understanding of the area under discussion. A solidly established concept in regulated animal trials (e.g. of human drugs in early development) is to prevent further suffering, once a line has been crossed, by way of killing the animal quickly and cleanly. It isn’t palatable but this fundamental concept, and the term ‘sacrifice’, aren’t issues here.
- perihelions 3y ago- "“The interest in protecting the safety of public employees and ensuring research that benefits the public can proceed without risk of violence clearly outweighs the public's interest in viewing said photographs,” the document says." By that logic, wouldn't you conclude you should censor anything that causes people to protest in the streets? I doubt this one-sided document written by attorneys representing the Univ. of California is an accurate representation of applicable law—I hope it isn't, this is just awful civics. The public-interest priorities are inverted: stuff that infuriates the public is precisely the stuff that's most strongly in the public interest to disclose.
- fsckboy 3y ago>>protecting the safety of public employees and ensuring research that benefits the public can proceed without risk of violence >By that logic, wouldn't you conclude you should censor anything that causes people to protest in the streets? no, only in cases where you're ensuring research that benefits the public, and also ensuring that things that are legal can proceed without risk of violence. If the photos were to lead only to petition signing, that would be a different matter. now, you can be cynical about things "the authorities say", and you can be worked up about monkeys and feel that their lives are equal to human lives; but just going on what the words mean, I don't think your interpretation is correct.
- perihelions 3y ago- "If the photos were to lead only to petition signing, that would be a different matter." What you're describing is a heckler's veto: denying the right of the public to participate civically, out of a fear response to a fringe minority.
- 20after4 3y agoIt's a pretty big assumption that this research benefits the public. It sounds like the results of said research remain the proprietary property of Neuralink and that's not what I would call a public benefit.
- simonebrunozzi 3y ago
- iancmceachern 3y agoThe picture of that poor monkey suffering in that preventable way and holding hands with its roommate is so sad. I've worked in medical device development for 20 years, I've seen a lot, cadavers, animals, actual surgury, etc. But reading that really stuck put at me. How aweful.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Janicc 3y agoCall me evil however you want. But they could kill 1000x the amount of monkeys if the outcome is severly disabled humans regaining their life in some capacity. Worse is being done to animals for less useful things.
- voz_ 3y agoOkay, you are evil. These are sentient beings, and the cold calculus here is the very nature of the banality of evil.
- comboy 3y agoI'm surprised that HN is pretty much a single voice against Neuralink. How many chickens do you think it is ok to sacrifice to potentially help some paraplegic humans? How many monkeys? Is sacrificing a human life worth it? I mean surely depends on the probabilities involved, whether or not we can find some other path which is better at minimizing sufferring etc. These are difficult questions, so I'm surprised people so quickly jump to an answer. And why focus on Neuralink. Here I found some animals usage report [1]. I'm too lazy to analyze it properly, but eyeballing it I don't think Neuralink datapoint is even meaningful. In 2017 75,000 monkeys were used in research [2]. It does not say for how many of these pain was minimized as [1] does, but ugh.. can somebody present a good case why Neuralink specifically is worth focusing on when discussing this issue? I'd also be happy to listen to good arguments for not experimenting on them at all, since it's not at all obvious to me. I've read Mama's last hug [3] and I understand why we may not want to, but at the same time, the trolley. In my twisted mind we should probably be experimenting on humans more [4]. If after psychological evaluation somebody gives they full consent, moving science forward can be some way to live a meaningful life, if you think monkeys are very much like humans then with humans we can at least clearly communicate and better minimize suffering. 1. https://www.aphis.usda.gov/aphis/ourfocus/animalwelfare/SA_Obtain_Research_Facility_Annual_Report/CT_Research_Facility_Annual_Summary_Reports https://www.aphis.usda.gov/aphis/ourfocus/animalwelfare/SA_O... 2. https://www.science.org/content/article/record-number-monkeys-being-used-us-research https://www.science.org/content/article/record-number-monkey... 3. https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/45894068 https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/45894068 4. I'm sure Nazi Germany surely fires for some after such statement as it does for me, but they did not minimize suffering. We should. We should just allow people to take risk if they want to. We allow skydiving and trying to climb Mount Everest. Why not allow to take it with benefit to other humans.
- yipbub 3y ago> I'm sure Nazi Germany surely fires for some after such statement as it does for me, but they did not minimize suffering. We should. We should just allow people to take risk if they want to. We allow skydiving and trying to climb Mount Everest. Why not allow to take it with benefit to other humans. The problem is that incentive structures of profit, monopoly, and power accumulation mean that people will get put into economic situations where they might do this to get out of desperation or not being well informed enough. Regulation will not work well enough, and we can't proceed assuming it might. We can't engage in such risky/dystopian behavior unless we can reduce the risk of systematic abuse, and right now we definitely can't. For example: We now are so much more productive than any time in history because of automation, but our work-life balance has not significantly improved. The US (and I'm assuming other) economies are structured in a way that 0 employment would mean extremely high inflation, so they intentionally increase unemployment instead of curtailing price-gouging. The impact will not only be abuse in terms of negative outcomes for "volunteers", but the ugly psychological impact on everyone the more hellish the bottom of the economy becomes as people become desperate to avoid it. Why don't we slice apart one perfectly healthy human to save 10? Maybe their family will be rich. Suicide becomes noble. Blood, kidneys, livers, eyes, etc. What if someone is coerced? The practical consequences of what you are suggesting are abhorrent.
- ricardobeat 3y ago> Around 65,000 NHPs are used every year in the United States, and around 7,000 across the European Union These are all “kept secret” too. Testing on monkeys is much, much larger than Neuralink and one can imagine there are even more gruesome stories coming from infectious disease and toxicity studies. It is cruel and heart breaking, but we don’t really have an alternative, how would anything get to a safe human trial stage otherwise? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animal_testing_on_non-human_primates https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animal_testing_on_non-human_...
- beebmam 3y agoTest on humans and pay them appropriately.
- Faaak 3y agoAnd a simple drug would then cost 1000+ bucks/dose
- ricardobeat 3y agoGreat idea, there is no chance masses of poor and disenfranchised will flock to it as a means of survival. Right? Worldcoin happened just two months ago…
- hef19898 3y agoBut honestly, why pay those poor folks for it, if the same can be had for free?
- DoingIsLearning 3y agoIf you look up any pharma or medical device company that has 'pre-clinical' trials that is usually a politically correct term for "N monkeys/sheep/pigs suffered in the process". Animal suffering should never be frivolous and that is why you have ethics committees but to think that we can advance without their suffering is naive.
- mandmandam 3y ago
- ShamelessC 3y agoThe comments here are a dumpster fire of bad takes. Shut it down, imo.
- mentalpiracy 3y agoFor those of you about to reply with some variation of “the ends justify the means” - this ain’t it. Plenty of commenters here will defend the idea that bleeding-edge science sometimes requires an uncomfortable amount of actual blood. (edit: I see several already have). If that is what you believe, fine — but this does not have to be the ideological hill you die on. Nothing about this is redeemable, and your viewpoint gains no credibility by defending this horror show of bad science and worse execution.
- madaxe_again 3y agoDo you eat meat?
- hef19898 3y agoThat question is relevant how exactly?
- bendbro 3y agoIf you're sad about Nueralink monkeys you should be sad about slaughterhouse cows. Are you just acting in bad faith or are you truly this dense?
- hef19898 3y agoI am sad about unnecessary suffering of the animals I eat as well. You should notice the key word "unnecessary" here. Sad isn't the right word so, I am rather pissed at the people and companies causing this unnecessary suffering because they cannot be bothered with even trace amounts of ethical behavior in the pursuit of a single dime. Even worse are the people findokg excuses fornthis kind of behavior, at least the perpetrators have some monetary motivation, while the appologists are somewhere between edgy and and morally bankrupt.
- curlicue77 3y ago[flagged]
- atleastoptimal 3y agoFor me this is just another "wait for AGI" technology.
- vlovich123 3y agoI talked with someone who worked at Neuralink years ago. They mentioned that it is a legit horror show, the science doesn’t justify it, and they were looking to get out of there ASAP.
- deadlast2 3y agoI just cant believe we are doing this type of stuff. But then veal, foie gras, chicken farming, bull fighting, rodeo.
- hef19898 3y agoAll of which are regulated, also the last two clearly don't belong there. Animal trials are necessary. And regulated and monitored. What Neuralink does is ignoring any best practices and rules, causing unnecessary suffering and, topping it all off, don't even have anything to show for it. Despicable is not really doing that behavior justice.
- threeseed 3y agoI would add just how dubious Neuralink looks from the governance side. CEO has no relevant background [1], no mention on the website about who the scientists, ethics or scientific advisory boards are. Or if they even have them. And their Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee has the company's Web Developer as a voting member [2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jared_Birchall https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jared_Birchall [2] https://neuralink.com/blog/the-role-of-the-institutional-animal-care-and-use-committee/ https://neuralink.com/blog/the-role-of-the-institutional-ani...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]