3 ms·
In my experience, this isn't anything special about therapists. Going through the listings for any kind of doctor in your health plan is a nightmare. When I ne
by crazygringo 3y ago
In my experience, this isn't anything special about therapists.
Going through the listings for any kind of doctor in your health plan is a nightmare. When I needed to see a primary care physician, it took two hours of calling 10+ listed offices to find one that was actually a primary care physician, was still practicing in the geographic area, was accepting new patients, and still accepted my health insurance (apparently dropping plans is common?). And the earliest they could see me was in 6 weeks.
It was the exact same type of experience when I needed to see a particular type of specialist, except the earliest appointment I could find was in 3 months.
The insurance companies just don't update their lists for any type of doctor, as far as I can tell. Whether this is due to sheer incompetence or deliberate deception or some combination of the two, I couldn't tell you.
- edgyquant 3y agoWhy in the world is the whole network thing even legal? It’s seems like a way to guarantee certain doctors and insurance companies a steady stream of cash flow without having to compete with one another. It is a hilariously corrupt system, but that’s par for the course with the medical industry. One of the only professions where you can charge people to have provided no solutions to their problems. Image a mechanic who tells you your misfiring engine and squeaky breaks are nothing and then charges you a few grand for the pleasure of them being obviously wrong.
- Clamchop 3y agoAside from such a scheme dominating a particular region and being a potential playground for other anticompetitive practices, nothing about the idea in general strikes me as inherently anticompetitive. Insurance cos can still compete on the merits of their networks and, in theory but sadly I think not in practice, these schemes could work in favor of the patients if the insurance company uses their network to balance cost with service quality. A very dominant one could effectively rule a region as a cartel, though.
- RajT88 3y ago> Why in the world is the whole network thing even legal? Lobbyists
- leetcrew 3y agomost professions that bill by the hour work this way? squeaky brakes isn't a plausible example, but this isn't uncommon for electrical issues in luxury cars. the mechanic spends days/weeks chasing it down and eventually asks you if you want to keep paying them to look. if you say no, you still have to pay for the time they already spent. if you say yes, there's no guarantee they eventually fix it. or they come up with a root cause and give an estimate to fix. you still pay if they're "obviously wrong".
- TuringNYC 3y ago> Why in the world is the whole network thing even legal? The answer is on some of the other comments on this page. Insurance companies make reimbursement so difficult that some doctors do not want to accept the insurance.
- patch_cable 3y agoDoctors can be out of network and still accept the insurance.
- TuringNYC 3y agothey can accept the insurance, but if the insurance doesnt pay the bill, the doctor has rendered services w/o payment. That isnt fair to the doctor. As many other comments point out, insurance companies pull many tricks to try to not reimburse. I've submitted claims directly to insurance before and had the same issue. - Your claim gets rejected for missing information, but they dont tell you what is missing - Your claim gets rejected for being a duplicate, but the previous claim also got rejected, or both got rejected - Your claim is "not received" there is no record of a claim - Your re-submitted claim gets rejected because 90 days have passed, but of course, it is because you were forced to resubmit over and over
- fallingknife 3y agoEasier to just look for doctors on Google and call them and ask if they take your insurance. Hit rate is very high.
- cortesoft 3y agoHonestly this is why I really like having Kaiser as my insurance provider (for those who don't know, Kaiser is an HMO that is both the insurance provider AND the hospital/doctors office/pharmacy. You get all your care from them). Some people don't like not having choices for doctors, but I would much rather just have one system to deal with. I don't have to print out medical records like I have to for my wife and kids (they are on a different plan), or call a bunch of different providers to find care, or go back and forth as two different providers say the other side is the one that has to do anything. I never have to argue with my insurance provider about paying for something, I never have to wonder if something will be covered.
- htss2013 3y agoWhat do you do if you don't like your doctor? Or your doctor just gets it wrong? Are you just screwed? For example, a therapist is a very personal thing and I'd imagine you might have to try many to get it right. Psychiatry is as much an art as a science, so it's not like they're fungible. Or what if, say, your internist dismisses your heart problems as anxiety, but you'd like to see a specialist because you know the difference and it's not just anxiety. That's it? Not allowed?
- cortesoft 3y agoYou can request to change your primary care doctor. There is an online list of Kaiser doctors who have capacity and you can choose to change to them... the list is accurate and you can do it online, though, unlike those described in the article. You can also make appointments with other Kaiser primary care doctors, either because you want to see someone else or your doctor doesn't have availability. You don't always have a choice to see a different specialist if you live in a smaller town, but in larger cities you can request a different one. In general you can't make direct appointments with specialists on your own, you need to be referred by your primary care doc. Once you have seen a specialist, though, you can make direct appointments with them. You can also call and tell them why you think you need to bypass the normal system. They have staff who are there to help navigate those situations. I have never had to do it personally, so I can't vouch for how accommodating they are. I will say, though, that in my experience I have a lot more say over my care than my wife does with her traditional insurance provider. She has had to fight to get things paid for and been rejected way too many times. Sure, she could make an appointment with any specialist she wants... but will insurance pay for it? In your example, if you have another doctor who has said the problem is just anxiety, will insurance pay for your second opinion? If insurance isn't going to pay for it anyway, it doesn't really matter if you have Kaiser or a traditional insurance provider. Both of us can make any appointment we want if you are going to pay it yourself.
- distract8901 3y agoMy insurance automatically assigned the geographically closest doctor as my PCP. That person was actually a nurse at the local high school.
- FireBeyond 3y agoOh yes. Physical therapy after a car accident. "Start immediately" say ER and PCP. Only PT available to me? "Sure, I can see you in 10-12 weeks from now..."