3 ms·
Child comment is now dead (and rightly so, but this was my reply). > Yep. Have you read the headline of this post? Yes, I did, as well as the post itself, in
by jacquesm 3y ago
Child comment is now dead (and rightly so, but this was my reply).
> Yep. Have you read the headline of this post?
Yes, I did, as well as the post itself, in fact this sort of comment is against the guidelines but since you're a new account maybe you want to give them a read? Link at the bottom of every page.
> Good luck with that. Trust me, we tried.
I've had several dealings with lawyers in Estonia and no reason for a complaint so far. But I didn't get them from some other website, I asked around in Estonia with business contacts there.
> Again, if financial institutions are involved I am not sure you are right. This are is heavy regulated from AML to KYC to whatever.
That doesn't matter.
> Crypto scammers plague Estonia’s e-residency program
Yes, they do. Unfortunately. They also plague Twitter, Facebook, HN at times, the United States and the start-up scene in general. That's nothing to do with Estonia per-se but more a reflection of how easy it is to set up a business somewhere.
> This comes only three months after the crypto-friendly nation became the epicenter of a $220 billion money laundering scandal.
Latvia had a similar issue a few years ago, they US basically pulled the plug on that and since then it's a lot better. But countries with underpowered regulatory entities will always be at risk of these things. But that does not make it 'the businessmodel of the country' any more than that the drug trade is the business model of the Netherlands or the United States. It's a clear reflection of facts of geography, ability to regulate and oversee, ability to police, experience and so on. The Baltics are attractive because (1) they don't have a whole lot of experience fighting this stuff (2) are proximate to some very large sources of illicit funds (3) lack manpower and funds themselves (see your quote about 'how big is their GDP' -> that's not proof this is their business model but an excellent reason why they can't do as much about it as they should).
As far as I'm concerned Estonia (and Latvia and Lithuania) can pull the plug on all crypto companies in their respective company registries. And let's not get started about Slovakia, Serbia and Macedonia who all have their own problems to work through.
- Beijinger 3y agoI was not aware that I violate any guidelines. But that a lawyer is your first choice when fraud is involved with financial institutions is not obvious for me. Reminds me when people called the BaFin in Germany and wanted to report fraud agains wirecard and they just hung up on those people. "I've had several dealings with lawyers in Estonia and no reason for a complaint so far. But I didn't get them from some other website, I asked around in Estonia with business contacts there." We did not have this option. To get a reliable, English speaking lawyer in a foreign country, the list provided by your embassy is normally a good start. Again: One scandal 220 billion? I mean, how big is their (Estonias) GDP "Latvia had a similar issue a few years ago, they US basically pulled the plug on that and since then it's a lot better. " It really should not be another country pulling the plug on you. Today, only 353 companies own a crypto license in Estonia while 1,234 companies did so at the end of 2019. No comment.
- jacquesm 3y agoWhat you are proving is that they are in fact working on this problem. And it is a problem, but it is not Estonia doing this, it is simply criminals taking advantage of an underpowered state in the EU that tries very hard to create ways to hook up to foreign entrepreneurs. Unfortunately the crypto gangs are like cockroaches. But it isn't Estonia itself doing this and you really should stop making silly statements like that. The US did the right thing in forcing Latvia to have a higher standard, at the same time, these countries are very weak in terms of controls and yet they have to have all of the trappings of a fully functional EU state to be able to play by the rules. This stretches local resources, sometimes beyond the breaking point. As an illustration: you, a citizen of another country also did business in Estonia, something that likely would be quite difficult in many other places for exactly those reasons. Finally: BaFin had problems, they run a lot deeper than WireCard and you would be similarly silly in stating that fraud was the businessmodel for Germany. Such generalizations serve no purpose.
- Beijinger 3y ago"What you are proving is that they are in fact working on this problem." The scam site has been up for many years. "be similarly silly in stating that fraud was the businessmodel for Germany" No, I never stated that [financial] fraud was/is the business model for Germany. Especially Germany, while a hub for laundering money in other ways, is not very finance heavy. I was just pointing out that German authorities did not do their job in a nearly criminal way. Germany considered ‘paradise’ for money laundering https://www.refire-online.com/investment/germany-considered-%E2%80%98paradise%E2%80%99-for-money-laundering/ https://www.refire-online.com/investment/germany-considered-...
- jacquesm 3y ago> No, I never stated that [financial] fraud was/is the business model for Germany. Please read more carefully. > The scam site has been up for many years. And likely will continue to be so until someone successfully brings a case to the Estonian courts. And that will require that party to go by the book, it will likely be costly (as it always is when bringing suit in a country not your own) and will take a long time. > What you are proving is that they are in fact working on this problem. But what I meant was: the fact that the numbers are going down is proof positive that something is being done, but probably just not fast enough. Otoh governments tends to be ridiculously ineffective in thse things. FWIW Estonia has ~1.3 million people living there, the vast majority of them earn their living in legal ways and silly generalizations are not going to help you gain much sympathy. Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania (and a number of other EU states) all have underpowered financial, legal and enforcement branches in large part because they are simply not the wealthiest countries and this situation attracts scammers and other criminals like flies. This is a real problem. Solutions are neither going to be quick nor easy.
- Beijinger 3y agoIt actually reminds me of a newspaper article about Mexico that is now unfortunately behind a paywall: https://worldview.stratfor.com/article/mexico-and-failed-state-revisited https://worldview.stratfor.com/article/mexico-and-failed-sta... It argued that Mexico is not a failed state and compares the contribution and profit margins of the Mexican industry to GDP and the contribution and profit margins of the drug industry to GDP. The conclusion was that the country is basically geographically divided between the industrialized area and the drug trade area and both parts provide roughly similar shares to the Mexican GDP and that it would be irrational for the Mexican government to change or fight this. Sorry, don't shoot the messenger.
- jacquesm 3y agoThe Mexican situation is entirely different from the Baltics, you can't compare the two.
- Beijinger 3y agoSorry, maybe I did not get my point clear here. The article about Mexico suggested that it would be irrational for Mexican authorities to really fight the drug trade. My thought was, for such a tiny economy as Estonia, were one fraud alone counted to 200 Billion, how rational would it be to fight this? Maybe I am wrong. Probably. But it is at least worth a thought.
- jacquesm 3y agoIt would be very rational for both to fight it. But in the case of Mexico, if not for the DEA and a lot of assistance from the USA the government would be overrun by the narcotics operators, the fact that this isn't the case is the result of decades of work (and not all of it legal or above board). Mexican politicians are very much at risk, see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_politicians_killed_in_the_Mexican_drug_war https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_politicians_killed_in_... This means that it may be right and rational to fight the drug trade and they are trying but the personal risks and risks to the rest of society are non-zero and may well be fatal to those individuals seen as instrumental to that fight (same in Colombia, perhaps more so). For Estonia the desire to fight these things is definitely there, but the manpower simply isn't. And this is the only thing that I really begrudge the Estonian authorities in particular: they never really sat down to think through the abuse potential and what likely would happen as a result of their e-* programs. They went into it all naive and starry eyed whereas professionals the world over saw it and thought that it was going to attract a very mixed crowd with a very large risk of abuse.