3 ms·
> In this case, even if you created the SWF yourself (using tools like haxe), you'd still have to pay the tax. Can that actually be legally enforced? I assume
by crazygringo 15y ago
> In this case, even if you created the SWF yourself (using tools like haxe), you'd still have to pay the tax.
Can that actually be legally enforced? I assume this tax would be part of the TOS for using an authoring tool. A consumer has to agree to the TOS for using/downloading the Flash client. But if I want to put up an SWF file I built without Adobe tools... who can legally stop me?
Unless there's some kind of encryption key for generating signed Flash files necessary for the functionality, and circumventing them would run afoul of the DMCA...
- rdw 15y agoI think it's pretty clear that they will use some sort of signing process to validate swfs, and in some respects it'll be pretty similar to DRM. In the original announcement, they say, "When the premium features licensing terms go into effect, unlicensed content will continue to run but will no longer have access to the premium features tier". Which implies that somewhere in the player they're planning to have a if(date() < August 12, 2012 || signed()) bit of logic.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoWelcome to the new world of proprietary software. If you're running on someone else's APIs, and there is an incentive to charge you for it, they probably will. When you buy your computer/phone/tablet you are not purchasing hardware and software to use as you please, you are purchasing access to a "platform" that can reach into your computer and make decisions based on not-your self interest.
- smacktoward 15y agoNEW world of proprietary software? Proprietary software has been around for a long time, young Padawan. And for all that time, using it has meant knowing that the platform owner could step in at any time and ream^H^H^H^H"monetize" you.