4 ms·
> Rancid oil of any kind is foul and disgusting. You'd gag if you tried to eat something made with it. “Rancid” is just oxidized, and its a matter of degree. Y
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> Rancid oil of any kind is foul and disgusting. You'd gag if you tried to eat something made with it.
“Rancid” is just oxidized, and its a matter of degree. Yes, at the extreme this is true. But “rancid” is a continuum, not just the extreme.
> Is this article using some definition of "rancid" different from the rest of us?
No, he’s probably just wrong. Rancidity does not reduce bitterness; rancid olive oil is more bitter. It might at moderate levels be tolerable, but that doesn't make his description of why it would be desirable make sense. What he says it counteracts is, instead, a characteristic distinguishing sign of rancidity.
IIRC, there's a different kind of “bad" olive oil with fermentation products which adds (unpleasant to most people, like rotten fruit) sweetness, which as I understand is mostly oil from poorly-stored olives, not rancid oil. I suppose a small amount of this effect might counteract natural bitterness in olive oil, but for neutral flavor you can usually just buy refined (extra-)light olive oil, instead of EVOO.
Or, because rancid olive oil will have lost other characteristic flavors, some of which some people may not like, he may be right that it is desirable to some people, but wrong in attributing that to a reduction in bitterness.
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoUm no. It's decomposed oil or fat and smells bad. The definition includes 'tastes bad'. Ok we're disputing the definition of 'rancid' which is low-quality discussion. But I think there's only one definition in common use? And it's not 'oxidized'. Maybe the word had been coopted by olive oil people at some point to mean something else? You can't expect the rest of us to understand what's being claimed, if ordinary words have had their meaning changed.