5 ms·
I really can’t tell if you’re being sarcastic or not. We already knew this before those specific abuses in the 50’s-70’s. They were already illegal, which is w
by lazide 3y ago
I really can’t tell if you’re being sarcastic or not.
We already knew this before those specific abuses in the 50’s-70’s. They were already illegal, which is why they were done by the secret agencies, and not by - say - the dept. of health (directly).
Congressional oversight has only gotten weaker since the Church commission (and frankly, the Church commission only made the mildest impact from what I can tell).
The real question is, what are they up to now?
- reaperman 3y agoIt was sarcastic, and your additional commentary is also accurate. We do need more systems to actively protect citizens against these kinds of abuses. It’s “uncommon” in the sense that a very small % of government employees are involved in these, but it’s common in the sense that something along these lines are always ongoing.
- avgcorrection 3y agoThat comment is brilliant because a lot of the commentary on past bad deeds exude that stance without stating it so explicitly. Here's the general lifecycle: 1. Year 0: you are a conspiracy theorist if you think that X is doing Y 2. Year 15: only people on the fringes think that X was doing Y 3. Year [declassified documents]: Some nerd reads it, tells it to a living room full of people 4. Year [declassified documents] + 15: We have learned a lot from how X was doing Y in the past; the leaders of current X will have to reckon with this past [which is definitely the past and has nothing to do with the present] 5. Year [declassified documents] + 30: Yeah, everyone knew that X was doing Y all along, idiot. It was a different time back then and nothing about it is comparable to our current times.
- almatabata 3y agoIt all comes down to how much proof you require before you believe something. Some people do not require iron clad proof before they agree something looks fishy. Others require a very high level of proof before they agree something happened. If you require a high degree of proof you will always have to wait for declassified documents or leaks before you agree on anything. I can understand why people chose to wait. You have so many different conspiracies and most people simply do not have the time to sift through hundreds of documents to make yourself an opinion. People already barely have the time to read the news let alone follow the conspiracy rabit hole. Most people simple chose to wait and see. It does get annoying when people immediately dismiss any doubts you have as conspiracy nonsense though. Most people believe in some form of conspiracy without realizing it. How many agree that Epstein did not kill himself?
- lazide 3y agoOr, most people don’t want to believe something uncomfortable until it no longer matters (if ever), and classifying/making these programs secret is exactly so the general public (which is composed mostly of those people) has plausible deniability? Which is also why whistleblowers get at most some feathers rustled, but rarely results in actual structural change. Because the public mostly is concerned about how they feel, not what is actually happening.
- avgcorrection 3y agoYou're conflating the CIA with the public which makes no sense.
- lazide 3y agoHow so? I’m saying that the public tolerates this situation (and the CIA et al use the classification system this way) because the public prefers feeling a certain way about what their government is doing, over knowing what their government is doing. Nominally, if the public cared more about what was actually happening: 1) Church commission type investigations would be a monthly occurrence (at the scale the gov’t current works at), not a one time fluke (historically) 2) Classified information and secret programs would require third party independent oversight (actual oversight. Not FISA like rubber stamping, which BTW came out of the Church commission investigations). 3) classified information would have very short timeframes before mandatory publication (at most a decade) 4) people would actually go to jail for abuses. None of which happens.
- avgcorrection 3y ago> I’m saying that the public tolerates this situation (and the CIA et al use the classification system this way) because the public prefers feeling a certain way about what their government is doing, over knowing what their government is doing. Based on what evidence? Think about what you are saying. 1. The clandestine arms of the US government has hidden things from the public 2. But this was because the public wanted it Explain how (2) came about. The US was much more open about things like the Vietnam War because there was virtually no public opposition at the start of it. Then a culture of opposition eventually emerged. When Reagan took office his administration interferred in Latin America. But then they found out that they couldn't just do that in the open like in the past because there was too much public opposition. So the operations had to be more clandestine. Public interest in US government operations abroad directly lead to a more clandestine approach—the exact opposite effect that you are claiming. > Nominally, if the public cared more about what was actually happening: And these things would come about how? Again, you're missing a step and somehow think that the public can will these concrete legislations into effect. How? The US government has been around for centuries while what could be called universal democracy only came about in the 1960's (arguably). And what democracy? A stronger one than pre-WWII, but still an elite-ruled democracy.
- yetanotherloss 3y agoThis is observed post hoc rationalization behavior for a lot of subjects, but it's worth remembering that a lot of the kooky stuff from step 1 turns out to in fact be run of the mill lunacy, so there is some harsh survivorship bias.
- avgcorrection 3y agoI was using the much-maligned term “conspiracy theory”, the term used to dismiss everyone from the well-read critic to the “kooky” Lizard International Government crank, but that was just to illustrate the point about how all of these get put under the same umbrella so that they at worst can be all summarily dismissed as dummies or at sort-of best can be equivocated by way of survivorship bias. In the Year Zero (before declassified documents) it's not a bad theory that a powerful arm of one of the superpowers in a very free nation could be used for clandestine purposes since the State has a lot to gain from keeping the free men (people) of that nation from knowing about what it is really up to. Thankfully though we don't need to guess at this point since we have history to back us up.
- Gibbon1 3y agoOff hand thought an a small bit is a game of telephone. What people hear is completely mangled hearsay. Problem with intelligence agencies is no feedback to keep things same like you have when what people are doing is transparent. You don't have the assumption that sooner or later there will be an accounting. It's no one will ever know.
- Chathamization 3y agoI don’t think it’s unreasonable to say that while, conspiracy theorist tend to both greatly exaggerate what actually happened, and use things that we have evidence of to push wild conspiracies we have no evidence of. Let me give an example I just found. Because of this post, I looked at the Wikipedia page for MK Ultra and found this line: > The people under this interrogation were CIA employees, U.S. military personnel, and agents suspected of working for the other side in the Cold War. Long-term debilitation and several deaths resulted from this. Thought that was an interesting claim, so I checked the source - footnote 36 - which was Rappoport, J. (1995). "CIA Experiments With Mind Control on Children". Perceptions Magazine, p. 56. It took me a while to track that source down, but I found some pages that had it such as this one[1]: It claims that there was a vast effort to create children sleeper CIA agents in the U.S. to control America. The evidence is based on “recovered memories,” which is a defunct technique that in the 80’s lead to conspiracies about a nationwide underground Satanic movement that was secretly controlling the U.S. Those theories, this Rappaport article, and even some comments here all lean heavily on Operation Paperclip, with the implication that the scientists the U.S. brought over post-WWII created a secret Nazi movement within our own government. Looking at Rappaport’s website is interesting too. He believes the “Covid shots were kill shots” and that January 6 was a staged false flag event. That’s enough time spent on crazy for me today. It takes a ton of time to track down each of these individual sources like this. Honestly, it’s exhausting, and too many people think that some evidence of wrong doing decades ago is an invitation to shut down critical thought and open the door for all sorts of craziness. [1] http://web.archive.org/web/20070608225401/http://www.totse.com/en/conspiracy/mind_control/161916.html http://web.archive.org/web/20070608225401/http://www.totse.c... [2] https://nomorefakenews.com/ https://nomorefakenews.com/
- lazide 3y agoCrazy gloms onto these things - both inside and outside the gov’t, and confusion is often used as a tool by ‘friends’ and adversaries. ARTICHOKE was the predecessor program to MKULTRA, and was explicitly to figure out how to trigger a cut-out to assassinate someone (especially high profile politicians). Here is the memo - https://nsarchive.files.wordpress.com/2010/04/project-artichoke-22-january-1954.pdf https://nsarchive.files.wordpress.com/2010/04/project-artich... (Copies of course, that I found googling around). These were real and dangerous programs. The CIA director explicitly ordered the destruction of all MKULTRA documents 2 years before Congress started to investigate it, after a suspicious and rather public death of one of the major Directors of the program. The only reason we have much documentation at all related to it is because several reports got misfiled and were missed during the shredder party, but were found later when the investigation got started. Unfortunately they were mainly financial overviews, not useful program documents. We know something very similar happened when Congress started looking into the CIA’s ‘extraordinary rendition’/torture programs. Along with active interference in the investigation. And no consequences for anyone involved. So take that as you will.
- caseysoftware 3y agoYes. My only critique of your lifecycle is that in more recent times, "Years" should be replaced with "Months".. or sometimes Weeks.
- BitwiseFool 3y agoThe trouble is, how do you effectively oversee an agency that specializes in lies, misdirection, cover-ups, coercion, and blackmail? I also worry that our three letter agencies have collected an immense amount of dirt on Millennials and Gen-Zers. It's not hard to imagine blackmailing politicians or releasing dirt on candidates running on a platform to curtail or rein-in such agencies in order to prevent them from getting elected.
- mcpackieh 3y agoIt's known that the FBI was spying on and blackmailing civil rights activists like MLK Jr. They even tried to coerce him into suicide. They were never held accountable for this, so why would they stop? And without anybody to hold them accountable, what would stop them from doing this to elected officials too?
- lazide 3y agoYup, and a lot more - the wider program was COINTELPRO
- mc32 3y agoAnd more recently the Congress[1] and a presidential candidate[2] —that we know of. Much we may not. But even Congress doesn’t have the will to do anything about the apparatus. What chance does the public at large have to have their constitutional rights protected? [1]https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/01/the-danger-of-nsa-spying-on-members-of-congress/282827/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/01/the-dan... [2]I'm sure some people will find no problem given an unsympathetic person, but it's still wrong.
- lazide 3y agoCongress is also likely a lot easier to manipulate/control (in a general sense).
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 3y ago> our three letter agencies have collected an immense amount of dirt This is something I can't help being reminded of any time there's "breaking news" about a political candidate and some taboo subject, even today. It seems at least naive to believe it never happens. I don't think it's too wrong to say that political candidates today either have very clean histories or "play nice" to some extent with these agencies.