4 ms·
I am extremely confused by this article. Rancid oil of any kind is foul and disgusting. You'd gag if you tried to eat something made with it. Yet this article
by crazygringo 3y ago
I am extremely confused by this article.
Rancid oil of any kind is foul and disgusting. You'd gag if you tried to eat something made with it.
Yet this article says things like:
> Rancidity, for example, isn’t generally a sought after quality in edible products. And yet, when it comes to olive oil in the U.S., people like it. Why? Partly, because rancid olive oil is less bitter than the good stuff.
Is this article using some definition of "rancid" different from the rest of us?
I totally get that some people don't like really fruity flavorful spicy olive oil. They want something more neutral. And that's fine.
But nobody in their right mind is picking something rancid. Nor would a supermarket ever sell it.
So I can't tell if the author doesn't know what rancid actually means, or if there's some separate food science definition of rancid that is different from everyday use -- but that the article doesn't bother to acknowledge or explain.
- Maken 3y ago> But nobody in their right mind is picking something rancid. Nor would a supermarket ever sell it. Unless it is cheese.
- greenhearth 3y agoCheese is not rancid. Cheese is fermented, which is a completely different, harmless process
- chmod775 3y ago> Rancidification is the process of complete or incomplete autoxidation or hydrolysis of fats and oils when exposed to air, light, moisture, or bacterial action, producing short-chain aldehydes, ketones and free fatty acids. > Fermentation is a metabolic process that produces chemical changes in organic substances through the action of enzymes. So by those definitions, rancidification through enzyme-catalysed oxidation, which by proxy probably includes anything microbial, is fermentation. Vice versa aged cheese is produced through rancidification. Doesn't sound completely different to me. Disclaimer: A lot of the terms in those Wikipedia articles go over my head, so feel free to correct me.
- Maken 3y agoIt's essentially the same thing but controlled.
- greenhearth 3y agoNo
- smegsicle 3y agowhat do you mean by this? sure some cheeses can be pretty smelly, but we're talking about olive oil, and whether 'rancid' makes any sense to describe something with subtler flavor than fresh
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chmod775 3y agoSomething tasting rancid is not the same as actually being rancid. Aged cheese is produced through rancidification.
- sophacles 3y agoRancid doesn't mean "completely rotten" even though some people use the term to only mean that. From wikipedia: > Rancidification is the process of complete or incomplete autoxidation or hydrolysis of fats and oils when exposed to air, light, moisture, or bacterial action, producing short-chain aldehydes, ketones and free fatty acids.[1] > When these processes occur in food, undesirable odors and flavors can result. The end stage you describe is accurate, but since it's a process, people will call it rancid before the end stage. Further, since there is a large subjective factor in whether a flavor is undesirable, there are folks who will be more or less tolerant of those flavors - some folks will think the oil is fine or maybe a little stale, while others will be extremely sensitive gag at the same oil. Compare meat: there are people who think aged beef tastes rotten while others consider it a delicacy.
- smegsicle 3y ago'rancidification' may be an industry term for a chemical process, but that doesn't change the definition of 'rancid', which does in fact mean 'smells bad as in rotten'
- sophacles 3y agoHence my entire paragraph discussing the concept of "subjective", and how some people have different opinions of "bad". I hate to be the bearer of bad news but: there exist 9 billion humans, and they have a wide range of opinions of what smells good and bad. Some of those opinions are in opposition to each other.
- dabluecaboose 3y ago>But nobody in their right mind is picking something rancid. Nor would a supermarket ever sell it. >So I can't tell if the author doesn't know what rancid actually means, or if there's some separate food science definition of rancid that is different from everyday use More likely is that the average person doesn't know what rancid actually means in this context. Rancidity is a quality of oil that occurs when exposure to oxygen results in the existence of free radicals in the oil. By and large, Americans actually prefer the taste of rancid olive oil.
- torstenvl 3y ago> More likely is that the average person doesn't know what rancid actually means. That's tautologically impossible. A word means exactly what most native speakers of the language believe it means. And "rancid" means "smelling or tasting unpleasant as a result of being old and stale" or "rank in taste or smell" or "having an unpleasant smell or taste usually from chemical change or decomposition." https://www.google.com/search?q=define+rancid https://www.google.com/search?q=define+rancid https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/rancid https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/rancid https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/rancid https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/rancid If "Americans actually prefer the taste," then it isn't "rancid" in American Standard English.
- dabluecaboose 3y ago>A word means exactly what most native speakers of the language believe it means. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rancidification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rancidification ...except when it doesn't. Is it so hard to understand that words can have different meanings in different circumstances? Context matters, words don't have one universal definition.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- crazygringo 3y agoBut this is an article intended for general readership, so it should use words as they are understood by general readers, or else point out that it is using a word in a non-general sense. You're right that context matters. Which is precisely why this article is badly and misleadingly written, if the authors are ignoring the context of an average reader. This isn't a food science journal for scientists, after all.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoOxidised olive oil loses the characteristic burn you get if you eat a spoonful of it alone [1]. If the oil has oxidised to lose that flavour, it has lost other flavours, lost some of its health benefits and developed harmful compounds [2]. The author is saying many Americans have been conditioned to accept this neutralised taste out of ignorance (and possibly preference) [3]. > some separate food science definition of rancid that is different from everyday use It appears the common definition of rancid conflicts in some cases, e.g. aged cheese and apparently olive oil, with the organic chemical one for rancidification [4]. It might be better to refer to the spoiled oil as rancidified rather than rancid. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oleocanthal https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oleocanthal [2] https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-1-4614-7777-8_13 https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-1-4614-7777-8_... [3] https://www.ucdavis.edu/news/olive-oil-study-shows-some-consumers-it-rancid https://www.ucdavis.edu/news/olive-oil-study-shows-some-cons... [4] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rancidification https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rancidification
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Rancid oil of any kind is foul and disgusting. You'd gag if you tried to eat something made with it. “Rancid” is just oxidized, and its a matter of degree. Yes, at the extreme this is true. But “rancid” is a continuum, not just the extreme. > Is this article using some definition of "rancid" different from the rest of us? No, he’s probably just wrong. Rancidity does not reduce bitterness; rancid olive oil is more bitter. It might at moderate levels be tolerable, but that doesn't make his description of why it would be desirable make sense. What he says it counteracts is, instead, a characteristic distinguishing sign of rancidity. IIRC, there's a different kind of “bad" olive oil with fermentation products which adds (unpleasant to most people, like rotten fruit) sweetness, which as I understand is mostly oil from poorly-stored olives, not rancid oil. I suppose a small amount of this effect might counteract natural bitterness in olive oil, but for neutral flavor you can usually just buy refined (extra-)light olive oil, instead of EVOO. Or, because rancid olive oil will have lost other characteristic flavors, some of which some people may not like, he may be right that it is desirable to some people, but wrong in attributing that to a reduction in bitterness.
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoUm no. It's decomposed oil or fat and smells bad. The definition includes 'tastes bad'. Ok we're disputing the definition of 'rancid' which is low-quality discussion. But I think there's only one definition in common use? And it's not 'oxidized'. Maybe the word had been coopted by olive oil people at some point to mean something else? You can't expect the rest of us to understand what's being claimed, if ordinary words have had their meaning changed.