4 ms·
This is a classic programmer response. The problem is not Amazon's software, it's their marketing, distribution network, huge audience that searches for product
by satvikpendem 3y ago
This is a classic programmer response. The problem is not Amazon's software, it's their marketing, distribution network, huge audience that searches for products exclusively via Amazon, "free" and very fast Prime deliveries, etc. That doesn't all happen via simply open sourcing some code.
- EGreg 3y ago[flagged]
- kimbernator 3y agoIt's trivial to create a website (frontend and backend) that offers similar functionality to Amazon. There's nothing special about their software platform. You can't open-source marketing and the insane delivery network Amazon has. Those, among other things, are the reason they are successful. They could release all of their software completely open source and literally nothing would change.
- boredpeter 3y agoYou can’t open source it but the government could nationalize it and make it a benefit to small businesses everywhere without the anti competitive profit seeking motives of a private business controlling it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- slowmovintarget 3y agoExpropriation is the first step to destroying the thing. There no reason for unbelievably good customer service if you get paid by taxpayers regardless of outcome.
- lapphi 3y agoThe employees at my local usps are pretty good at their jobs. But they are all Korean ladies.
- bee_rider 3y agoThe original commented suggested that an open source Amazon was the “real solution.” Open sourcing Amazon’s software and then nationalizing their distribution network is a very different suggestion!
- JohnMakin 3y agoThe infrastructure of a large ecommerce website is extraordinarily complex as well, as well as issues that arise with warehousing tech.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoYou're talking about the infrastructure for a specific seller, which in itself is by no means trivial. What you want here is an open source replacement for Amazon's product search that will find products from multiple independent sellers. The hard part is probably how to curate it; you want to allow legitimate small sellers without allowing the thing to be filled with scams. But Amazon hasn't done a very good job here either, so maybe it's not a high bar. And then a payments system which is something in the nature of GNU Taler. Amazon's logistics is an advantage, but is it an advantage that can overcome the need to pay them a vig instead of having the product shipped directly from the manufacturer? Lots of people willing to wait a week for shipping if the price is 10% lower.
- hef19898 3y agoNo need to open source. Just to pick some examples to build something similar to Amazon's fulfillment part as it was like 6 years ago: Shopify as the front end CargoWise for transportation, warehousing and everything logistics Which leaves some of the more sophistiticated stuff like demand ballancing across the network, but that is doable by either developing something in-house or throwing an ERP system into tue mix. All available off the shelf as we speak. There are other reason why nobody manages to seriously challenge Amazon.
- ericjmorey 3y agoHow do you get people to visit your site or use your app?
- 303uru 3y agoThe basis of this entire case is that you can open your own shop and Amazon disallows you form competing with their monopoly. There are plenty of open source options to open a web shop. That part is almost laughably easy.
- pierat 3y agoI vouched for this and un-flagged it. I find most of your content here to not have any good follow-through. Amazon isn't just some software on a few servers. It's a whole vertical enterprise. Suggesting that some front-end and back-end servers can take the place of warehouses, delivery people, fleets of machines (served by AWS no less), payment companies, 3rd party billing is just laughable, and shows the naivete of a sw engineer. However, that last paragraph is terrible and absolutely true... > Otherwise, at best, you are just reduced to begging Daddy Government to force these corporations to break up. How well did that work for Ma Bell? The pieces were still a cartel, still charged $3 a minute. What the government couldn't do in a decade, open source technology and open protocols did in a few short years ... VoIP dropped the price to practically nothing. Now we have videoconferencing all over the world. Because once we decoupled the software (AOL, MSN, etc.) from the infrastructure via open protocols, the infra providers became a dumb pipes competing in a free market. I remember Ma Bell. Charged stupid prices for long distance, but was a good service. And then, the splitup happened. Did we get better services? Nope. We just got dozens of smaller monopolies all engaging in the EXACT SAME SCAMS that Ma Bell was broken up for. It was when we started pushing data around and got away from POTS lines did we finally break the stranglehold of the baby bells. Even DSL has been basically thrown away, given how little the RBOCs dont want to advance and grow. Monopolies are like that.
- EGreg 3y agoThanks for un-flagging. How does one become an admin on this site, anyway? I've been active since 2008 but still get dinged for stuff, not sure for what in advance. Yep, I think we are in agreement. My point is that for many decades, the government was barely able to make the prices drop. And then open protocols like VoIP did it in a couple years. I am a libertarian and believe that good open-source software and open protocols cause the centralized services to face a free market of incumbents. Much of the vertically integrated systems can be unbundled. Another great example is how the Web (HTTP was the open protocol) disrupted AOL, MSN, CompuServe etc. Or how Wikipedia disrupted Britannica and Encarta. How Apache and NGiNX disrupted IIS. And so on. Basically, we need standardized, open protocols. Maybe one day OpenStreetMap and Mastodon and BlueSky will disrupt their centralized alternatives. In any case, the first step is to have open source software and federation. I'm not saying it's the only thing that needs to happen, but FBA and many other services can be done "sharded" per-product. We can do the same for other marketplaces, like Uber, Fiverr, etc.
- oblio 3y ago> VoIP dropped the price to practically nothing. Now we have videoconferencing all over the world. Cool example you chose there. 99% of VoIP is actually closed source, proprietary solutions. WhatsApp, Facetime, Skype, Telegram, Google Whatever, Slack, Teams, ...