7 ms·
MasterCard, Visa Warn of Processor Breach
- clicks 15y agoLots more discussions and explanations over at Reddit: http://www.reddit.com/r/netsec/comments/rkudd/mastercard_visa_warn_of_processor_breach/ http://www.reddit.com/r/netsec/comments/rkudd/mastercard_vis...
- groby_b 15y agoSome discussion, yes. I'm still curious how the author ties this to "Dominican street gangs" - that seemed a rather surprising finishing note.
- obituary_latte 15y agohttp://blogs.gartner.com/avivah-litan/2012/03/30/new-credit-card-data-breach-revealed/ http://blogs.gartner.com/avivah-litan/2012/03/30/new-credit-... I think this blog post might have something to do with it. In it, she mentions that "she heard" that the breach had to do with taxi's and/or a parking garage in NYC.
- brandonb 15y agoMy startup works on fraud detection, and it's amazing to see how sophisticated criminals get when there are such large sums of money involved. The black market for stolen credit card numbers is a real market with division of labor: some people hack in to processors to steal the numbers, others resell those credit card numbers, others write scripts to create fake accounts for a particular site, others integrate all of those tools to actually execute the fraud, etc. Just in the past couple of months, we've seen online criminals try to: * Run money laundering schemes by posting fake items for sale on a marketplace, and "purchasing" their own item using a stolen credit card. * Create fake accounts from different browsers to get tons of free machine resources, which they then use for more nefarious purposes. * Rent a bot net to run a distributed fraud ring from many different machines, in a way that's almost undetectable. * fool SMS verification by setting up a Twilio server to make it look like they have a U.S. phone number. You can imagine how fun it must be to outsmart them. :-) By the way, if any of you are running online stores or marketplaces, and seeing a sudden spike of fraud or chargebacks from this breach, feel free to ping me (brandon@siftscience.com). We may be able to help.
- white_devil 15y agoTo summarize: Lots of people are Scum.
- pavel_lishin 15y agoSturgeon's Law.
- wglb 15y ago94% is it?
- mahyarm 15y agoHow did you detect that it was a money laundering scheme in the first place !?
- brandonb 15y agoI'd love to say but then it'd be obvious to any fraudsters out there. :-(
- thinkcomp 15y agoThe Senate Banking Committee held hearings yesterday on mobile payments. Unfortunately they're totally unaware that it's possible to initiate a mobile financial transaction that doesn't make use of a credit card or cell phone carrier's billing system, and that it's basically impossible for startups to compete with the card networks (possibly by offering new anti-fraud technology, for example) when the cost of regulatory compliance nationwide is $20 million. So we'll probably keep on seeing a lot of stories like this one...
- tptacek 15y agoThat suggests a regulatory cost of under 0.0001% of the dollar volume of a large credit card processor. Given the high cost of securing transaction processors and the regularity with which these companies --- all of whom pay millions to staff security teams --- manage to cough up customer data to transactions, I'd suggest the problem is in the other direction: it may not cost enough to be a transaction processor.
- thinkcomp 15y agoBased on our history, Thomas, I believe this represents the kind of behavior that reduces the quality of debate on-line or off. To argue that $20 million is a small amount relative to Visa's total transaction volume, and consequently too little (!) as an arbitrary barrier to entry for startup companies, is puzzling. I don't know of any license fees that are calculated based on what the largest market participant could afford to pay as a percentage of revenue.
- pg 15y agoPlease stop making this personal.
- tptacek 15y agoI don't understand this argument. We're commenting on a thread where lax regulation of a payment processor appears to have resulting in a breach that disclosed 10 million credit cards. I'm not sure how that story admits to a pivot about over-regulation of payment processing. Different people have different value schemes. For instance, personal liberty is far more important to me than airport security. But in my value scheme, which I think is probably widely shared, the safety of consumer financial data is more important than whether it costs $500,000 or $20,000,000 to operate a payment processor at scale. (I don't, for what it's worth, really believe that all new market entrants to payment processing have to pay 8 figure sums to launch). Also: in case anyone's wondering, I've never worked for or with Greenspan, or even met him in person. I assume the history he's referring to is on HN.
- fudged 15y agoI have a Visa card, and I haven't been notified. CNET said that Visa customers were notified, but I have no idea what sort of scope this notification was.
- dfc 15y ago"But affected banks are now starting to analyze transaction data on the compromised cards, in hopes of finding a common point of purchase." If they know the processor was compromised what is the point of finding a common point of purchase? Is the common point of purchase where the criminals are extracting the money?
- rogerbinns 15y ago> what is the point of finding a common point of purchase So they know who to notify. It isn't every US card holder that is at risk, so they want to know who is. The Gartner article says this: > From what I hear, the breach involves a taxi and parking garage company in the New York City area so if you’ve paid a NYC cab in the last few months with your credit or debit card – be sure to check your card statements for possible fraud.
- dfc 15y agoI thought the processor was breached?
- rogerbinns 15y agoThe current gossip is that it was an administrative account for the parking garage/taxi at the processor.
- dfc 15y agoThanks. I guess when I read that the processor was compromised I guess I assumed it was at Ring0 (couldn't resist). It never occured to me that it was within a client's account at the processor.
- wglb 15y agoThe article has been edited to note that the payment processor is Global Payments.
- DiabloD3 15y agoThis would have never happened on Bitcoin.
- epscylonb 15y agoAgreed, bitcoin wallets can and have been stolen, but it is difficult to imagine a scenaerio involving bitcoin and 10 million separate individuals. The only thing I can think of is if bitcoin becomes really popular and lots of people use hosted wallets over the web. This will always have a certain amount of risk, after all who thought linode would get hacked? (seemingly from the inside). The solution will probably be some kind of insurance, much like how gold is secured today. I can envision bitcoin savings wallets(which don't need to be online) being put into some kind of uber secure virtual vault.
- wmf 15y agoIndeed; Bitcoin has entirely different problems.
- kylebrown 15y agoSupposedly (or so I heard), UnionPay in China doesn't provide fraud protection/reimbursement to users (irreversible). Ditto for Alipay, where a large portion of transactions are done using escrow. China is said to be a "cash society". Quite interesting that (if I heard correctly) their biggest credit/debit card and online payment companies don't offer any protection to users - the biggest challenge payment processors face in the U.S.