2 ms·
So only true scotsmen aren't tools? I'd argue that if a concept is so badly explained that both its most zealous proponents and antagonists are mistaken, that
by ajross 15y ago
So only true scotsmen aren't tools? I'd argue that if a concept is so badly explained that both its most zealous proponents and antagonists are mistaken, that perhaps it's not such a useful design concept in the first place.
I mean, who could possibly be confused about what the transfer of representational state means?
- debacle 15y agoWe're getting off track here, so I'm going to recuse myself, but I would argue that the most zealous proponents and antagonists of any concepts are likely mistaken, in some way.
- czzarr 15y agosince when does a concept need to be easy to explain for it to be great? Ever heard of general relativity or quantum physics?
- ajross 15y agoThose are laws of nature, not design paradigms. They have different (almost opposite) metrics for "great". Relativity (both variants) and QCD are "great" precisely because they were discovered and characterized in spite of the fact that they are counterintuitive and difficult to visualize. Good software design, on the other hand, is all about human communication. And a design paradigm that can't be communicated easily has less value than one that does.