5 ms·
Do you not have a computer at home? Because devoting a few gigs of my Home PC to work is easily worth avoiding 12 minutes per day on the train + however long i
by Retric 3y ago
Do you not have a computer at home?
Because devoting a few gigs of my Home PC to work is easily worth avoiding 12 minutes per day on the train + however long it takes walking to the station and waiting for the train twice.
Really I used to live 1 subway stop from the office and WFH was still a significant time saver.
- unshavedyak 3y agoYup. I'd pay (and do! for 10 years now) my own dime to maintain a good PC solely for work. It's a stupidly easy investment for me compared to 1-3h of commute every day. I also now require extra rooms for offices anytime i look at homes. The life balance is just so amazing for me i'm never giving it up, if i can. I feel respected in a way i never thought possible, before.
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoYou're reducing WFH to just avoiding a commute. In my case, I found that WFH only was isolating, impacted focus, and cut me off from the information flow of the organization, something electronic means cannot really substitute. I have a sense of being more involved and informed about the business instead of being plugged into the Matrix and receiving a paltry trickle of information over narrow channels. The benefits of hybrid for me offset the burden of commuting enough to justify coming in.
- markhnthoraway 3y ago> In my case, I found that WFH only was isolating, impacted focus, and cut me off from the information flow of the organization, something electronic means cannot really substitute. I worried about feeling isolated but found I didn't feel that way. And I think generally WFH has improved my ability to focus. My company is fully remote so there are not many in-person channels for information to flow. Before the pandemic I would not have taken a remote job, I would have not been sure it would work out for me, but having done it for 3 years now, I'm real happy with it. I do still like seeing people and will go out to work occasionally or cowork with friends. Traffic where I live is horrible though and avoiding a 30 minute dance with death twice a day is an amazing reduction in stress levels. I guess it's going to work out that this is just one other thing to consider about a workplace and there's no one right answer where all businesses should do the same thing, people need the options.
- Retric 3y agoI always felt more connected to my coworkers when we are regularly working from home. The office is such a false environment people just act very differently.
- ideamotor 3y agoThe office is the real environment. When working from home, people are more isolated and heavily restricted by silos and tracking systems. That’s the false environment. Compare talking to a friend in person to texting them from miles away.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Retric 3y agoThat’s far from my experience. It sounds like you’re dealing with a horrible job / company here.
- deprecative 3y ago> I always felt more connected to my coworkers when we are regularly working from home. The office is such a false environment people just act very differently. Jokes on you, I don't care if my coworkers get hit by a bus either way! I cannot stand anyone I work with. Every meeting that should be 15 is now an hour minimum why? People want to chat and I sit there with my soul leaving my body totally unable to do anything but smile fake and try not to look like I'm dead.
- kyleee 3y agoAs hard as it may be to hear, to some extent that is likely a “you” problem. Start a culture of not having to have the camera on, figure out good reasons to have to exit such wasteful calls, etc. Continuing the same thing and whining about it melodramatically is unlikely to be fruitful
- 3y ago
- MSFT_Edging 3y agoIn my experience, the office can be even more isolating and mentally taxing. I rather just type out my thought process if I need to talk to a coworker. Like cool, I can spend an hour getting an overpriced lunch with my coworkers and push the "going home" aspect back another hour.
- 8note 3y agoI haven't found RTO to make the information flow happen, at least not the way it used to, where I could just listen to all the background noise of people talking, and occasionally overhear something of interest.
- isykt 3y ago> Do you not have a computer at home? I have several and I would never install work software or store work materials on it. The privacy and security risk alone is just not worth it — and I work for a company that respects privacy. I would also never pay any money to maintain a computer to do work for a company. I value my commute tremendously. It’s one of my favorite parts of the day.
- Retric 3y agoVM or hot swapping a drive works fine. > I would also never pay any money to maintain a computer to do work for a company. Yet you’re seemingly happy to shell out your own time and money to pay for a train trip when it rains. I doubt your arguments here.
- isykt 3y agoMy employer pays for transit. They didn’t buy my umbrella though, so you got me there
- deprecative 3y ago> I would also never pay any money to maintain a computer to do work for a company. But you would maintain a car to [do] work for a company. I'm going to have to take my three hours a day that I have working remote, more if you include prep time to even leave the house, and spend that on bumper to bumper traffic baby!
- isykt 3y agoI don’t own car.
- hightrix 3y ago> I value my commute tremendously. It’s one of my favorite parts of the day. My guess is that you either don’t live in the US or live in one of the small handful of cities that have decent public transportation. Sitting in SoCal traffic for an hour both ways every day will certainly change your mind about commutes.
- mr_mitm 3y agoEvery thread about WFH immediately devolves into people listing the pros and cons of WFH vs RTO. Guys, it's a matter of preference and dependent on individual circumstances.
- klardotsh 3y agoThe problem is that RTO companies refuse to recognize that, and are making "do it or get fired" demands of employees regardless of where they find it productive to work. Those more productive in an office have always had coworking spaces available. Those who work better from home can get stuffed under these mandates. So whose preferences really matter here? Who holds the power in the equation? I'll give you a hint: it's not anyone who actually cares how productive work gets done.
- ike2792 3y ago+1 to this. I work with people who would love returning to office and others who are adamantly against it. Even though I overall prefer WFH there are still things I miss from being in the office. I used to commute an hour each way by bus and that was some of my favorite time; I could read, sleep, listen to podcasts, whatever. OTOH now that I WFH full time I can work out before work and help run kids around right after work.
- hightrix 3y agoIn addition to what others have said, the biggest issue is that RTOers want to force their will upon WFHers because they don’t want to work in an empty office. I get it, social people want to be social, but forcing us WFHers into your paradigm because you don’t want to be lonely is not the answer, it creates resentment from both parties. WFHers sit there with headphones on, blocking out the world while RTOers wander the halls looking for interaction. It is absolutely a difficult problem for modern companies to deal with. Hybrid seems like the best/worst solution so that no one is happy and both parties compromise.
- addicted 3y agoThe problem with WFHers is that they don’t realize that they’re like blue collar workers in the 80s voting to offshore their jobs away.
- vlunkr 3y agoWhat's so bad about a short commute like that? It's good for you to physically get up and look around, and mentally to either clear your head or listen to a podcast/music.
- mathgeek 3y agoAs the OP said, they go for a run with that time.
- vlunkr 3y agoOk, the thread here is someone talking about a 6 to 21 minute commute. IMO that's not a significant amount of time saved.
- Clamchop 3y agoWe can count getting your things in order, gussying yourself up so no one sees you for the garbage that you are, and just kinda... not wanting to some of the time. And framing it as 40 minutes saved is kind of missing part of the story, because it's every day. Forever! That in fact will amount to A LOT of time saved. Your employer would care about a 40 minute change in your hours one way or the other; why don't you? Packed lunches or eating out. Shit coffee further tainted by the lingering smell of microwaved tuna. That feeling that you have to be seen looking busy even if you're not doing anything or just really need a break. And there's Steve, who's always smacking on gum and humming while he works. You're awful, Steve.
- vlunkr 3y agoThis is why the conclusion of the study makes sense to me. I enjoy my short commute as a buffer between work and life, but sometimes I just don't want to, so I stay home occasionally. Also, I think some WFH zealots on HN forget that other people may not have the mean, or the space, or the internet connection to have a nice office at home, and have pets or children that can be just as distracting as co-workers.