3 ms·
The models themselves record the training data. ChatGPT is happy to spit out Albus Dumbledore when asked about a hypothetical magic school. If you don’t have
by Retric 3y ago
The models themselves record the training data. ChatGPT is happy to spit out Albus Dumbledore when asked about a hypothetical magic school. If you don’t have the exact training dataset that’s not going to be an actual defense.
The only protection is specific jurisdictions ruling this stuff is fair use, which is risky when you could be found liable in literally any country.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> ChatGPT is happy to spit out Albus Dumbledore when asked about a hypothetical magic school. How are you supposed to know if that's because it ingested the text of Harry Potter or a bunch of fan blogs talking about Harry Potter? > The only protection is specific jurisdictions ruling this stuff is fair use, which is risky when you could be found liable in literally any country. Saudi Arabia has quite strict blasphemy laws but people don't seem to be bothered much by it when hosting quite obvious violations of them on their servers in North America.
- Retric 3y ago> or a bunch of fan blogs talking about Harry Potter? Doesn’t actually matter here because those fan blogs are also derivative works. I may have read “Call me Ishmael” in a blog, but the quote is from Moby Dick. ChatGPT can argue for a fair use exception, but combining lots of derivative works can be copyright infringement even if none of the things you directly copied where. IE: If you copy a lot of excerpts from a poem and recreate the poem that doesn’t mean you can now use the poem. Being able to say Harry Potter isn’t directly in their training data is at best useful to arguing something was unintentional copyright infringement rather than not actually being copyright infringement. > Blasphemy laws That’s a criminal not civil issue and there aren’t a huge number of treaties on the subject. If a US company is sued in Australia for copyright infringement they don’t get to move the case to the US.
- __loam 3y agoWorth noting that Fair Use is more than just transformative work. Your work can still be found to be infringing even if it's transformative if it egregiously violates other tenets of fair use, like disrupting the market for the original.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Doesn’t actually matter here because those fan blogs are also derivative works. Not necessarily. To be a derivative work it has to contain copyrightable elements, not just a small number of words in the same order. > ChatGPT can argue for a fair use exception, but combining lots of derivative works can be copyright infringement even if none of the things you directly copied where. IE: If you copy a lot of excerpts from a poem and recreate the poem that doesn’t mean you can now use the poem. This is the argument for why the model itself isn't infringing, isn't it? All of the excerpts as presented in their original context isn't the same thing as all of the excerpts purposefully rearranged back into the original work. It's like on the one hand arguing that a dictionary is infringing because it contains all of the words in Harry Potter, and on the other hand claiming that you can reproduce the text of Harry Potter without liability because you reconstructed it by rearranging the words in a dictionary. One of these things is not like the other. > If a US company is sued in Australia for copyright infringement they don’t get to move the case to the US. If a US company has no operations in Australia, how does an Australian court have jurisdiction?
- Retric 3y ago> has to contain copyrightable elements Fictional character names are copyrightable elements. Sure, it’s no issue for actual place names, but those aren’t the words people will be looking for. > a dictionary is infringing because it contains all the words in Harry Potter The argument is the model may have recreated the story of Harry Potter from being fed so much information about it. DALL·E can’t contain a copy of every image in it’s corpus simply based on information theory, the model just isn’t that large. However it has no problem recreating the Mona Lisa because so many of its source images included it. That’s no problem for something out of copyright but it’s a big problem for major works in our culture like Harry Potter or Star Wars where potentially hundreds of thousands of derivative works get stitched together into a copy of the story. If ask ChatGPT to summarize Harry’s first year at Hogwarts and it spits back a detailed summary of his year including dialog etc that’s wildly past the de minimis standard. I assume OpenAI has tried to prevent this, but this kind of reconstruction seems like a legal landline.
- 3y ago
- TrueDuality 3y agoThat kind of information is present in fan fiction, Wikipedia, reviews. Plenty of other sources. You're also incredibly wrong on being able to assume a book is present in the dataset. It is up to the complainant to prove the case, you are not guilty because you didn't keep sufficient records.
- Retric 3y agoCopyright is like a shit sandwich, just those two words alone prove it’s a derivative work. This is true even if you copied from a copy. Once something is demonstrated as a derivative work, proving your use is fair use is now on the person who created it. That’s normally fairly easy with a book, but harder with LLM’s if they easily spit out large chunks of a clearly copied work. Remember lawsuits aren’t beyond a reasonable doubt the standard is much lower.
- diogenes4 3y agoSurely this opens a door where, because an agent is unlikely to reproduce work verbatim but rather in a more compressed or decompressed wording, humans are held to a different standard? Otherwise humans would remain an effective way to launder the output of the agent.
- Retric 3y agoCopyright still applies if you’re copying elements of the story, it’s just harder to detect and less obvious in court. The value of names to copyright holders is simply how distinct they are. John Smith isn’t particularly unusual but if you name a bounty hunter Boba Fett it’s hard to argue originality. Complete originality isn’t required as long as you’re safely inside a fair use exception, but overwhelming originality is required. So it’s generally safer for a character to talk about their favorite parts of Star Wars than have your stories plot be a group of rebels trying to destroy a planet killing doomsday weapon guarded by a sword wielding space wizards.
- diogenes4 3y ago