9 ms·
Infinite Copyright Is Killing Culture
- FairThought 15y agoSo, what happened during the 1990's and 2000's?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- regularfry 15y agoNothing unique. If Amazon had existed in the 70s and someone had gathered the same data, I'm sure you'd see the same shape. In fact, the publishers and booksellers probably did gather that data, so it ought to be possible to check whether this is true or not.
- drcube 15y agoRecent popularity? The graph basically says that copyrighted works older than 10-15 years are simply ignored. Public domain works, however, are almost as widespread as recent blockbusters.
- floppydisk 15y agoI would posit the graph is showing the ephemeral popularity of books that either represent seminal landmarks in literature, philosophy, or other categories that lend themselves well to the written word OR republications of books from the public domain for use in the classroom. For instance, several courses I took in Uni required books like Plato's Republic and Thomas Paine's Common Sense. Works that are in the public domain but were republished more recently.
- jcromartie 15y agoThe data here is the number of books sold by Amazon, arranged by the decade they were published in. So Amazon sells lots of contemporary books, and lots of pre-1922 public domain classics, but much fewer books published under copyright (since they are now basically locked away, virtually forgotten, and will not be republished).
- guelo 15y agoMy explanation of the graph: When a new book comes out it receives marketing and promotion and will sell for a few years. Then the book enters the dead zone where it will be slowly forgotten over a couple decades but it is not able to enter the public domain anymore because copyright protection continues to be extended to protect Disney's movies from the 1920s. Since most of the books in the dead zone are not reprinted by the publishers they are inaccessible except via rummaging through the used book market.
- elviejo 15y agoCompletely agree as a friend of mine said: "I wouod rather have a law that shortens copyright terms to at least the death of the author. and that law has an exception just for Disney..." (ben litton)
- travisp 15y agoEnding the copyright of a work at the death of the author without any minimum would have significant problems. People who are old or ill would not get book deals (or at least not good ones) because what publisher would want to take the risk? And, they might not bother self-publishing either, since their children could not benefit if they die soon.
- wisty 15y agoHow about 20 years after publication? That would give Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone another 5 years. I'm sure JKR could live with that. CJR Tolkien would have to live off the savings of the Tolkien estate, and takings from his own works (The Silmarillion, which he finished off and published over 20 years ago, and some other more recent publications based on JRR's unfinished work). Less popular authors wouldn't make enough, but they don't make enough regardless. There's very few books which make any real money 20 years after publication, as the chart shows. The downside would be the moral rights of authors. Some authors are a bit tetchy about their characters being used by other authors. JKR is reputedly pretty cool with fan fiction (she knows her fans will just buy more of her stuff), but some authors would be a bit offended at their characters being used in slashfic, or whatever other weird use people could think of. On the upside, educators could use it. Sure, there's "fair use", but it's too badly defined to get a definite sense of what "fair" is (for good reasons - a narrow definition would encourage people to abuse it). Teachers and textbook publishers are too stingy to hire copyright lawyers or buy rights, so they just use stuff that's clearly in the public domain. Want to know why textbooks are boring? The lack of public domain materials is one reason (others are listed here: http://www.edutopia.org/textbook-publishing-controversy http://www.edutopia.org/textbook-publishing-controversy)
- jstalin 15y agoThe original copyright act in the US granted protection for 14 years with an option for 14 year renewal. I think society would be much better served if we went back to that.
- roc 15y agoIf the goal is to ensure creatives can make a living at creating things that are trivial to copy, 14 years may be too short. And registering for renewals strikes me as an unnecessary fig leaf to entrenched publishers (who else would have the money or inclination to register and pay for such?). 25 years seems fair.
- _delirium 15y agoThe original motivation for renewals I believe was that orphan works and abandoned/discontinued projects would lapse, since nobody would bother to renew them.
- roc 15y agoWhich is a reasonable goal. But I find such rules create little more than traps for the lone creator or industry outsider; someone who is already at massive disadvantage in the industry. Unnecessary bits of procedure are naught but hand-outs to those who have the time to professionally game the system. And companies [1] are highly unlikely to pass on paying a nominal fee [2] when the potential return is so high. [1] Only companies are likely to have orphan works that are even known to exist by anyone willing to appropriate them. [2] The fee must necessarily be nominal, lest you again disadvantage the lone creator/outsider.
- m_eiman 15y agoWhat could you possibly create that will take you more than 14 years to earn back that would only be protected by copyright?
- roc 15y agoThe problem is that the copyright clock starts ticking the moment you've fixed an expression, not from any registration or publishing date. So a creation that is largely done but is being shopped around to publishers, or sitting in a drawer collecting small tweaks and edits is losing its monopoly. And if you erode much off 14 years, it starts to sound unnecessarily short. Just ask any writer, comedian or musician how long their original creations were kicking around before they got anyone interested in paying them for it. Several years is common for their pre-discovery work.
- known 15y ago"If I have seen further it is by standing on the shoulders of giants." -- Isaac Newton
- ghaff 15y agoI'd really like to see the source of the data and what exactly is being measured. The implication of the title is that these are new physical books. If that's the case, I guess I'm a bit skeptical. I suppose it's possible that there are an outsize number of books published between about 100 and 150 years ago that get read for school and the like, which would account for that big spike. But these books are mostly not all that cheap just because they're in the public domain. And, presumably, the number of different titles still being read from that era is relatively small. And the top n% (where n is a small number) most popular titles from any era are mostly still in print, whether they're out of copyright or not. Now, on the other hand, if this includes e-books, there's a pretty simple explanation. Many of the pre-copyright titles are available for free and very low cost and most of us with Kindles and Kindle apps have downloaded quite a few even if we haven't gotten around to reading all of them. (I'm not arguing against shorter copyright terms by the way. But my personal experience is at odds with the suggestion that there are vast numbers of 20th century books that people would be reading in droves if only there were in print.)
- AnthonyMouse 15y agoI think the mistake may be in discounting the long tail: Even if the top n% are still in print, the bottom (100-n)% aren't. The volume from a million out-of-print old books that would each sell on average fifty copies a year can easily dwarf that of a few thousand in-print old books that each sell a thousand copies a year. As for the e-book explanation, even if that turns out to be the case, isn't that an even stronger argument for shorter copyright terms? Now that public domain books are "free" you get a lot more public benefit out of something being in the public domain, because instead of the price going from $17 to $15 it goes from $17 to $0, which results in far more people getting access to the book.
- ghaff 15y agoIf the million books are out of print, Amazon certainly can't sell them as physical copies. (OK, there's PoD but I can't see that skewing these numbers in a big way.) And even Gutenberg has "only" 36,000 e-books, which I assume corresponds pretty closely to all the available public domain works that have been converted to text. That's a big number but it's still a fairly small slice of all published books even allowing for the fact that the number of published books has gone up over time. > As for the e-book explanation, even if that turns out to be the case, isn't that an even stronger argument for shorter copyright terms? Sure, at least in principle. Insofar as copyright law is supposedly about balancing the public good with encouraging the creation of new works, making the good relatively more valuable (through wider distribution) once out of copyright would presumably change the balance point. As I said, I'm certainly not going argue for the current copyright regime.
- nkassis 15y agoMy proposition(probably not original at all) is that we let Disney(and anyone else) extend copyright on thing it wants at an ever increasing (exponential) rate. If they have to pay they will make sure to only keep things under copyright that are still bringing them value. Also, we need to move towards a registration based copyright system. This post doesn't need copyright protection.
- dmayle 15y agoI agree completely. First 14 years: free. Beyond that start raising the price. Registration only kicks in once you have to start paying...
- kijin 15y agoThat looks like a very reasonable compromise between short default terms and paid registration/extension.
- jessriedel 15y agoCopyrights are currently free. Under your system, you'd have to figure out how to decide what counts as a single "work" for setting prices.
- vaksel 15y agohow about this...let them decide on the yearly value...and enforce licensing costs equal to X% of that value. that way they won't want to set the value high to pay the fees...and not too low since then the licensing costs would be too low
- roc 15y agoWhich would harm outsiders and new creators while giving an advantage to corporations that knew the rules and could afford to play the game. Publishers would be only too willing to pay registration rates that independent creators could never afford. It would allow them to never pay original authors for their copyrights in favor of simply waiting them out and plucking the work out of the public domain once the creator had given up. If you thought "work for hire" was bad today, imagine what it would look like if publishers all knew that independent creators were likely only a year or two away from not even having that copyright with which they currently negotiate.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- protomyth 15y agoI bet a lot of it could be mitigated by allowing works to pass into the public domain, but allow parties to keep the characters / settings under some type of trademark for new works. I would say infinite sequels, reboots, and remakes are killing culture more than infinite copyright.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- cletus 15y agoI actually don't understand why the so-called Mickey Mouse copyright extensions aren't treated on a case-by-case basis or at least don't require renewal say every 20 years so truly orphaned works can do what they're meant to and go into the public domain. That being said, patents have time limits. Why do copyright holders feel like they have the right to profit in perpetuity? It seems inconsistent and not in the public interest but I don't need Mickey Mouse to be in the public domain. Orphaned works however should become so.
- luriel 15y agoYou have to understand that the IP industry sees public domain content as competition, they want to restrict the amount of stuff in the public domain as much as possible. Also, if people get used to things being in the public domain, they might start to question how much sense it makes to have the government go around granting monopolies (copyright and patents).
- sliverstorm 15y agoIt seems inconsistent and not in the public interest but I don't need Mickey Mouse to be in the public domain Honestly, I agree with you. I suspect it is in part because at this point Mickey Mouse is practically Disney's logo, and we certainly don't expire other company's rights to their logos.
- pyre 15y agoLogos fall under trademark law. Will it really hurt Disney's brand if someone else is selling DVDs of Steamboat Willie?
- steauengeglase 15y agoIn that case Mickey Mouse is already protected as a trademark. The real question isn't if Mickey is protected, but if Steamboat Willie is protected from now until the end of time.
- TheAmazingIdiot 15y ago
- cafard 15y agoFirst, what exactly is the Y axis? Titles stocked or volumes stocked, and what is the order of magnitude? Second, what is the effect complained of? That it costs too much to purchase books, movies, and music, or that one can't "read a version of Good-bye, Mr. Chips in which he protects his students from the werewolf menace as well as offering them solace through the Great War." If the former, among the moderately prosperous of the developed countries, is this really having a large economic effect? Grabbing at random some non-tech stuff that happens to be in my office, I find, all in copyright: one novel at $15.95, one volume of humor ditto, one collection of essays on food at $12.95. Second, if the cultural effect is the problem, just how grave is that problem? We do not seem to be thinking of Mozart and da Ponte overhauling Beaumarchais here.
- vilya 15y agoWhen I stop to think about it, it seems strange to me that ownership of copyright is transferable at all. I suspect it comes from years of thinking of intellectual property as if it were physical property. Just as a thought experiment: could a system where copyright isn't transferable but lasts until the death of the author work? Assuming a suitable definition of "death" which covers both individuals and companies, that is.
- zem 15y agospider robinson's short story "melancholy elephants" is relevant here: http://www.spiderrobinson.com/melancholyelephants.html http://www.spiderrobinson.com/melancholyelephants.html
- michaelw 15y agoRecommended reading on this subject: http://www.spiderrobinson.com/melancholyelephants.html http://www.spiderrobinson.com/melancholyelephants.html
- visarg 15y agoCopyrights are restrictions on the rights of everyone. We can do without restrictions today. What we need is a system for reimbursing the authors, not a system for restricting copying. In my opinion we need a flat anual fee (a tax) levied on everyone, then we could do away with all restrictions on all media. The only problem would be to count the usage and distribute the money. This could be achieved by some technological system.
- tripzilch 15y agoA very cool short story taking this topic to a strange and dystopian extreme is Melancholy Elephants: http://www.spiderrobinson.com/melancholyelephants.html http://www.spiderrobinson.com/melancholyelephants.html