8 ms·
Meta wants to charge EU users $14/month if they don't agree to personalized ads
- register 3y agoLet's hope that they go this route. Can't wait to see it happen
- rolph 3y agoCan't wait to see what happens if they go this route. bowl of popcorn time, for sure.
- philihp 3y agoI'm hopeful as well, although pessimistic. The demographic of people who would pay money to escape advertising are also quite profitable if you can successfully target in your advertising campaigns.
- ehPReth 3y ago…do they even make that much money per user per month from ads?
- ch_sm 3y agoaccording to this[0], they don‘t (those are annual figures I think) [0] https://www.statista.com/statistics/251328/facebooks-average-revenue-per-user-by-region/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/251328/facebooks-average...
- AlexandrB 3y agoWow. The "US and Canada" ARPU is crazy high. I thought it would be around $10/year not 5 times higher. Could the increase in ARPU over time be used as a "harm to consumer" argument in favour of antitrust action? The effective "price" of using these services is increasing.
- sschueller 3y agoI wish but it will never ever happen. How may people would pay $14 for Facebook? 0.001% maybe? That's more than Netflix!
- techdragon 3y agoIf it meant they couldn’t spy on me… I might consider it a worthwhile trade to finally use Facebook after all these years ignoring my account.
- orange-mentor 3y ago$14 is pretty high, but if they actually follow through on this I think we'd see downward pressure on price.
- chasd00 3y agoi think they'd still spy, you just wouldn't get ads. The more they spy and learn about their users the more accurate the ads become for those that chose to see them.
- rglullis 3y agoWouldn't it be easier for everyone if we switched away from Facebook to another social network instead?
- darth_avocado 3y agoI would pay for it if on top of removing ads, I do not see cringe “suggested for you content”. I mean there are only so many DIY hacks, people nodding to a video running in the background, dancing people who can’t dance, people lip syncing an unoriginal audio etc. I can watch.
- wenc 3y agoIt’s not either or. Some people will pay it. Others won’t and so will have the normal as-laden experience. Win-win.
- rolph 3y ago>>The bloc's regulators ruled last year that Meta must give users the option to opt out of personalized ads based on their activity on their platforms. The suggested subscription model could yet change, as it is not clear whether EU regulators will deem the new plan as compliant with EU laws.<< extortion, is not 'giving an option'. amazon has done this a number of times, it seems FB is following a play from MS, by copying the competition a day late and a dollar short.
- LanceH 3y agoWhich side is extorting? Do what we say or you can't do business in Europe? Pay for services or don't get served?
- ko27 3y agoWe are talking about consumers vs companies. Of course governments will "extort", that's what regulations are for.
- sebzim4500 3y agoHow is this extortion? People who want to use the service but don't want to pay with their data can pay with their wallet. Everyone wins.
- rolph 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37755590 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37755590
- Moldoteck 3y agoLoool, this sounds interesting. If it'll get to this point, I'll delete all meta accounts for sure, but I guess I'm a minority, still, interesting if someone will switch to say Snapchat bc of these changes
- ch_sm 3y agodoes snapchat let you opt out of personalized ads? (genuine question)
- local_crmdgeon 3y agoNo, but it does have Snapchat Discover, the Worlds Shittiest Clickbait!
- Moldoteck 3y agoYeah, installed it recently and just was shocked abt amount of trashy content compared to reels/tiktok (at least content presented to me)
- tick_tock_tick 3y agoSeem's pretty reasonable to make it up front. Instead of this BS 'free' people can explicitly opt for which style they'd like. Pay or tracked ads. No more issues of consent. I expect the EU in general won't stand for it though as too many people will make the 'wrong' selection.
- EMIRELADERO 3y agoIt's not reasonable because consent must be freely given. That includes there not being any negative consequences for saying no. A paywall is a negative consequence.
- jpadkins 3y agoDoes it not also apply to the service provider? Does the service provider also get the right to consent to show their content or services under certain conditions? In a voluntary society, both parties must consent to the arrangement for a user to (freely) use a service.
- PeterisP 3y agoThe core principle of how EU and GDPR treats privacy rights is that they're inalienable, they're not for sale, they can't be traded away in a contract or arrangement. So for use cases where you need the user's consent because you don't have a different GDPR-valid reason for processing data (many reasonable use cases don't need consent, but user tracking for advertising generally does), that processing is permitted only if that consent is freely given i.e. willingly 'gifted'. One way how it's implemented is that if some service if conditional upon 'consent' then there is literally no way to get 'GDPR-valid' consent - the user clicking 'I consent' to bypass a paywall doesn't count as the user consenting, and neither does signing a personalized pen&paper contract saying that the user consents to tracking in return for getting free use of some service, because that's not "freely given consent" and so it doesn't permit Meta to track that user. It's just like signing a contract where you get $10000 in return for agreeing to be enslaved for some time - your freedom is not something that can legally be sold, and so are the privacy rights. The other way how it's implemented in GDPR is that it must be possible to withdraw consent at any time (including 5 seconds after signing up to a service) without any adverse consequences such as the service being cancelled or increasing in price. Obviously that's not a problem if the consent is freely given, but if someone tries to figure out some roundabout way of buying or trading for consent, the consequence-free cancellation makes the point that it's not supposed to work that way. Of course, companies are not required to provide any service, and they can require a fee for some services - however what they can't do is buy 'consent' with discounts or free service; the GDPR limitations to tracking users are intended to apply to all tiers of users, no matter what Meta does or wants to do. Meta can gift users free service; users can 'gift' Meta consent to tracking, but they can't make a binding contract on that because under GDPR conditional consent is literally meaningless and worthless.
- Simulacra 3y agoI use Facebook for about 2 minutes per week. If they want to charge me then that makes it very easy to just walk away.
- wenc 3y agoOr you could use it for free like you do now, with ads.
- orange-mentor 3y agoPaying for stuff is the endgame. Not DRM, not endless ad blocker proxy wars. This is all really positive, and proof that these regulations are working, imo.
- AlexandrB 3y agoThe pricing reminds me of when contractors quote 2-3x normal for jobs they don't want to do. I'm sure Facebook is expecting that 99.99% of people will just agree to tracking and in a few years they can shutter the paid tier as an "unsuccessful experiment".
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI would say the opposite. The people who are able and willing to pay are worth the most to advertise to. So if Facebook wants to maintain revenue, it has to set the ad free price high because they are losing their most valuable product, richer people’s attention.
- mk89 3y agoI am not sure they are their most valuable product to be honest. They make money with literally anybody on the planet.
- mk89 3y agoI think it's more like "in order to match my megaprofits, you need to give me this". I really believe they make a lot or money with custom ads - I don't have data though.
- Enginerrrd 3y agoThat's exactly it. It's a bit more complicated, in that creating and maintaining all the payment processing infrastructure is a huge hassle to make without recouping sufficient cost per user. There's still not really a good option for microtransactions and it's a big problem. But... There's no way on earth Facebook is making $14/mo off me in adds. It's just not even close. I'd be happy to pay if the value were anywhere close to a match, but it's just not. I mean, that's en par with streaming services and youtube. If Facebook thinks they're even in the same order of magnitude as far as content quantity and quality as that, they're delusional. If I had to guess an actual fair value for the average user, it'd be around $3-5/mo max. For me personally, it can't be more than $1-2/mo. But maintaining all the payment infrastructure for that when any amount deters most users is pointless. Companies always price these non-free tiers really high.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Animats 3y agoThat's great! Competition will develop.
- mulmen 3y agoWhat will change about a Facebook with users as customers. Will Facebook (re)invent the chronological feed? Will they employ fewer dark patterns? Anyone have experience running ads on Facebook? How is the UX?
- LordDragonfang 3y agoI'd be willing to bet money that the operative words here are "wants to". As in, they'd like to, and someone floated it as a possibility, but no one on the team is actually taking it seriously as a real strategy going forwards. $14/month is a crazy high fee. This is just financial reporters taking a random brainstormed idea out of context and misrepresenting it as a serious strategy to generate headlines and buzz.
- user3939382 3y agoI wouldn't accept $14/mo to use any of their "products". Maybe 500-1000.
- standardUser 3y agoI might pay $14/mo for Facebook + Instagram + Threads + WhatsApp if there was no tracking or ads whatsoever. Emphasis on the "whatsoever". And it's not just because of how I use these apps now, but also for how I might better use them if they actually had a user-first mentality. Or at least not user-last.
- rglullis 3y agoMy time to shill https://communick.com https://communick.com. Mastodon + Pixelfed + Matrix hosting, an not ads whatsoever.
- gigel82 3y agoCan we charge Meta $14/month for tracking us across the web without consent then? It's only fair...
- highwaylights 3y agoThe most fascinating part of this is that it puts a concrete figure on how much your attention is worth to Facebook with regards to what it makes from advertisers. $14 a month is (to me) an astonishing figure when you see it written out. To think that just Facebook’s cut, of just the profit, of just what you’ve been manipulated to buy beyond what you otherwise would have would mean that earnestly the data suggests that the average person is likely spending well over $100 a month on things they didn’t even want in the first place because of targeted advertising.
- wholesomepotato 3y agoI need X. A and B both have X product. It's worth for them something to make me aware of and buy their product over competition. So that $14 is not just "didn't even want".
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoAlthough there is the old saying that 50% of all advertising is wasted, but you don't know which half. There must be companies that spend on advertising and do not get any good return on it.
- traverseda 3y agoWith google advertisements mean that your competitors page doesn't appear above your search listing. It means that if you sell something you more or less have to buy ads for your own name, or else people searching explicitly for you will be led to your competitors products. It's sort of like a race to the bottom. With facebook I understand that if you want to actually get a message out to people who've explicitly subscribed to your content you need to pay them. Same sort of thing. Sure, it's an "ad", but not in the same sense as like a billboard or a TV spot. It's actually game-theoretic coercion.
- Enginerrrd 3y agoIt's not though. These ad-free tiers are always priced way higher than what they're getting in ad revenue per user.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoPrivacy is a luxury. That said, I have disposable income and always pay for ad free experiences when offered.
- rglullis 3y agoIf you use any of Mastodon, Lemmy, Matrix or XMPP, I'm waiting for you at https://communick.com https://communick.com :)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 28304283409234 3y agoHow about you get my data and we split down the middle? Pay me my share, Mark!
- Gys 3y agoInteresting number: how does this relate to their monthly profit and monthly users?
- rglullis 3y agoThank you, Zuckerberg. Now you just made explicit how much each user is worth to you.