2 ms·
There's also the moderator stating that Schneier won. The derrier handoff is not obvious at a glance. I think a more neutral title would be better; this is an
by davidw 15y ago
There's also the moderator stating that Schneier won. The derrier handoff is not obvious at a glance. I think a more neutral title would be better; this is an important debate, not cheering for your favorite sports team.
- ktizo 15y agoHowever, it is also worth considering that a more neutral title may not have made it onto the front page.
- rdl 15y agoThe strings "Bruce Schneier" and "TSA" individually make it likely, and together, almost guaranteed.
- ktizo 15y agoI wasn't aware that I was making that contentious a statement. Was just meaning that the titles on a news site are effectively headlines and that the style of how they are written can massively effect how much attention they are given.
- goostavos 15y ago>massively effect how much attention they are given. This is very true. And is also a massive problem with news sites. You didn't post a accurate, descriptive title, you posted an editorialized opinion. Yes, you get lots of views if you distort the article (18% do NOT agree that he lost the debate), but catchy title does not good journalism make. I think HN should shy away from this sort of thing. We'll all complain about Fox, MSNBC and the Drudge Report for their ridiculous headlines (This just in, Obama sacrificed a child! Click for story!!), lets apply the same set of critical standards here. Otherwise we'll become /r/politics..
- ktizo 15y agoI didn't post any title, accurate, descriptive or otherwise. I'm not the OP, I was just commenting is all.
- redsymbol 15y agoI wasn't aware that I was making that contentious a statement. I agree; in fact I found your comment insightful and relevant. Seems strange to me that people were voting it down.
- maaku 15y agoThe moderator was editorializing on the massive skew of votes in favor of Schneier. “Winning” this debate is determined by votes, so there's nothing wrong with that.