6 ms·
Making a "European Edition" in a country that's constantly fighting to undermine the EU (and EU values like LGBTI+ rights and democracy), great idea. Definitely
by wkat4242 3y ago
Making a "European Edition" in a country that's constantly fighting to undermine the EU (and EU values like LGBTI+ rights and democracy), great idea. Definitely not buying this one.
Source for the democracy claim: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/sep/15/hungary-is-no-longer-a-full-democracy-says-european-parliament https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/sep/15/hungary-is-no-...
PS:
> “Unfortunately, due to our customers being in various security-conscious industries, we’re not allowed to tell anyone which countries we are producing these devices in, simply to keep it as secure as possible,” HMD Global chief marketing officer Lars Silberbauer said at the time.
Umm what? "Made in xxxx" documentation with a product is actually required by many security-conscious institutions such as customs.
- diggan 3y agoWasn't that a big selling point of capitalism anyways? Have trade connections with even your enemy so you're less likely to start wars with them. Maybe this is a similar strategy that could get Hungary to undermine EU less because of the new economic connections?
- anonzzzies 3y agoThe article (and possibly the press release) seems to avoid EU in favour of Europe. But yes, it's not a great choice as far as countries is concerned; I think most countries would vote for them to leave if that were an option.
- adev_ 3y ago> Making a "European Edition" in a country that's constantly fighting to undermine the EU Almost all phones are currently produced in a country that genocide some of its minorities, support child labor and claim publicly the right to invade/obliterate his neighbor. And that does not seem to disturb you much ? We need more Silicon and electronics made in Europe. Hungary is definitively not a democracy paradise nor a human right haven, but it is already significantly better than anything we do have right now.
- wkat4242 3y ago> Almost all phones are currently produced in a country that genocide some of its minorities, support child labor and claim publicly the right to invade/obliterate his neighbor. And that does not seem to disturb you much ? It does, yes. My phone was made in Thailand by a Korean company but indeed a lot of the supply chain involves China. > We need more Silicon and electronics made in Europe. Agreed, it just feels like Hungary gets rewarded for its actions here. And making it a proud "European Edition" in a country that is so contrary is just a bit extra sour.
- Citizen_Lame 3y agoHungary is not democracy.
- jeroenhd 3y agoWith European wages being higher than their Asian counterparts, companies have to pick poor countries to produce these things, even inside Europe. Those tend to be the ex-Soviet countries with rather extremist governments. I try to avoid Hungarian products as it's the only way I can affect the country and its government (the EU is powerless against its bullshit). However, let's not kid ourselves into thinking other countries smartphones are manufactured in are any better. India and China are not exactly progressive by EU standards. If the EU model and non-EU model are both sold for the same price, I'd buy the Hungarian smartphone, even if I'd wish HMD would've picked any other European country.
- wkat4242 3y ago> Those tend to be the ex-Soviet countries with rather extremist governments. Not really though. Romania for example is poorer and not extremist in that sense. They are not pro-Russian (especially considering they are pretty worried about what's happening in Moldova/Transnistria) But for now it's really just Hungary and as of this weekend Slovakia that are pro-Russian. (edit: Not Poland indeed sorry scotty79)
- scotty79 3y agoPoland is as far from pro-Russian as possible. Second only to Ukraine I think. We currently have bad kleptocratic populist government which in the last years lead our country back towards the 90-s (which were not glorious in Poland), but even that government treats Russia as an enemy from the start. The only thing that can be said is that due to their intellectual deficiencies they are susceptible to Russian propaganda, intended to undermine EU.
- wkat4242 3y agoYou're right, I should not have put Poland in the pro-Russian camp. I know it's not. I heard it stems from what the Soviets did at Warsaw near the end of the war (apparently they waited outside a few weeks to give the Germans time to kill as many remaining civilians as possible so they could set up shop themselves) But it is populist and not EU-friendly right now. Hopefully it will change.
- Maken 3y ago"Perfect" is often the biggest enemy of "good enough". Hungary may not be perfect, but it's a first step away from way way worse places.
- hoseja 3y agoOK, but do you not see how they might gain opportunity to thrive with putting democracy in the second place in list of values?
- DeathArrow 3y agoI would happily buy products made in Hungary.
- mrweasel 3y agoYeah, also Hungary keeps questionable friends. I suspect that HMD just went with "cheapest" in the EU. I don't see why they didn't just go across the border to Romania or maybe Bulgaria instead.