4 ms·
New satellite outshines nearly every star in the sky
- rbanffy 3y agoWhile some observations will be harder to conduct (say, if they rely on continuous data at high time resolution), but can't longer exposures avoid satellites by closing a shutter when the satellite crosses the very narrow FoV of the telescope? For the amateur equipment I've seen, they already work by adding lots of shorter exposures and discarding the photobombed ones shouldn't be too much of a problem.
- defrost 3y agoThere are at least three issues: * It's not just one, two, or several satellites: BlueWalker 3 is the most brilliant recent addition to a sky that is already swarming with satellites. The spaceflight company SpaceX alone has launched more than 5,000 satellites into orbit, and companies around the globe have collectively proposed launching more than half a million satellites in the coming years — a scenario that astronomers fear could hamper scientific observations of the Universe. * There's more than just extremely narrow Field of View work going on. Many people like wide FoV shots, the moon and other objects (at various times of year) is a popular wide target. The satellites impact "Fireballs" telemetry which now has a global network from humble beginnings here in W.Australia and looks for light streaks to zero in on recoverable meteorites. http://fireballsinthesky.com.au/ http://fireballsinthesky.com.au/ * Telemetry | Communications satellites muddy up interesting parts of the radio spectrum. They don't always STFU crossing designated quiet zones, for example: https://www.atnf.csiro.au/projects/askap/ARQZWA.html https://www.atnf.csiro.au/projects/askap/ARQZWA.html and, just on a personal note, for those people that live in areas with zero light pollution and stunning views of the night sky that they've enjoyed for decades .. that's been pretty much lost now that the blinken lights have invaded the last corners of the planet. https://www.lightpollutionmap.info/#zoom=6.78&lat=-25.1726&lon=117.3805 https://www.lightpollutionmap.info/#zoom=6.78&lat=-25.1726&l... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mA54NBtPKdI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mA54NBtPKdI
- rbanffy 3y ago> have collectively proposed launching more than half a million satellites That doesn't mean there will be nearly as many in LEO at any given point in time - their orbits decay and their service lives tend to be short compared to other satellites. It'd be problematic to track them manually, but any reasonable mobile phone can track that many spacecraft. > Many people like wide FoV shots A lot more people like broadband coverage in remote areas, on airplanes, or in the middle of the sea. Having better connectivity in these cases can save a lot of lives. And, still, a lot of wide FoV shots are dozens or hundreds of stacked exposures. It shouldn't be that difficult to automatically remove the photobombed ones (and we also know where the satellites will be). > looks for light streaks to zero in on recoverable meteorites. Again, orbits are predictable and we can easily discard false positives that way. > They don't always STFU crossing designated quiet zones This is a real problem and spacecraft operators should be held accountable for that. I understand light pollution from below and, now, from above, impacts the views of the night sky - I too always loved to sit back in our vacation home, away from the city, and just watch the stars above, but the benefits these spacecraft bring can't be neglected and, even if a single life is saved because someone could connect to ask for help, it's a worthy sacrifice. Also, I can do that after dinner, past the hour satellites are still reflecting the sunset of places west of me. I guess the option will be to find nice rural places in high latitudes where we only need to deal with birds in polar orbits.
- defrost 3y ago> > have collectively proposed launching more than half a million satellites Global proposed in orbit active constellation sizes are large and we've barely started with what is planned: At the forefront among companies that plan to put up satellite swarms is Elon Musk’s SpaceX. Around 2000 satellites in its Starlink program are currently in orbit, with the full system envisioned to have around 40 000. When SpaceX and others have put 65 000 satellites in orbit, “one out of every 15 points of light you see in the night sky will be a moving satellite,” says Samantha Lawler, who studies the Kuiper belt at the University of Regina in Saskatchewan, Canada. OneWeb has launched 358 of a planned constellation of 6372 satellites—down from earlier plans for 48 000. Amazon’s Project Kuiper is preparing to launch 7774 satellites. Other planned constellations include ones from China, with 12 992 satellites; Rwanda, with more than 327 000; and the Canadian company Kepler Communications, which has launched a few satellites and plans to create—or sell spots in—a constellation of 115 000. https://pubs.aip.org/physicstoday/article/75/4/25/2842796/Ballooning-satellite-populations-in-low-Earth https://pubs.aip.org/physicstoday/article/75/4/25/2842796/Ba... > any reasonable mobile phone can track that many spacecraft. That's not the issue - they're still there disrupting visible and non visible imaging. > A lot more people like broadband coverage Ah, yes, the Joe sixpack argument for littering the world, pissing on gardens, and painting adverts on the walls of the grand canyon. > in remote areas I'm 60 and I've lived and worked in remote areas my entire life as, indeed, have the people that live and value remote areas - paper maps work fine, tourists need GPS, trad. radios work for communications, somehow humanity has survived for more than the last 30 post WWW years no matter what the mobile phone addicted think. > even if a single life is saved because someone could connect to ask for help, it's a worthy sacrifice. Don't need starlink for that though, do we? We have ePIRBs, we have sat phones, if someone can't survive outside a city without bring the city with them, perhaps they shouldn't leave the city. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uL44EAyz8Qc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uL44EAyz8Qc